Yami on lack of media acknowledgement - Page 12

Originally posted by: pathaka

Oh I could go far ..same as u trying desperately to prove it as bullshit

My original post (again if u even read it before giving me ur “expert” opinion on it) talked about how even if someone does hold auditions of 1000s of non nepo kids to select , they select on subjective terms like “screen presence”, “expressions” and looks …which is a personal preference …it’s up to the person who is putting in the investment for the film

So technically there is no “fairness” there too because there is nothing absolute actors can do to prove their competence …they have to eventually get someone to “like “ them…

Read read and read

And this whole essay was written to justify nepotism and cronyism right? Otherwise what were you trying to prove huh?

Answer the question instead of repeating your points.

Originally posted by: pathaka

Go on…I’m listening

Because u have absolutely no business labelling someone else’s argument as bullshit with sound logic like that …

Oh no you just can't listen. You got to have the last word even if you have no points left.😆

Originally posted by: AwaamKiJaan

Any this whole essay was written to justify nepotism and cronyism right? Otherwise what were you trying to prove huh?

Answer the question instead of repeating your points.

It’s a discussion

Because this is a discussion forum in case u haven’t noticed …ppl have discussions and are not here to be merely sorted into nepo pile and anti nepo pile …

My original post which u swiftly labelled as bullshit wasn’t to prove or justify anything …it was merely an argument that there is only so much “standardisation” that can apply to this field which is predominantly run on favouritism and preferences ..due to the inherent nature of “acting” being a personal preference …

Originally posted by: AwaamKiJaan

Oh no you just can't listen. You got to have the last word even if you have no points left.😆

I wasn’t the one who didn’t properly the read the original post and made grand assumptions 😉

Originally posted by: pathaka

It’s a discussion

Because this is a discussion forum in case u haven’t noticed …ppl have discussions and are not here to be merely sorted into nepo pile and anti nepo pile …

My original post which u swiftly labelled as bullshit wasn’t to prove or justify anything …it was merely an argument that there is only so much “standardisation” that can apply to this field which is predominantly run on favouritism and preferences ..due to the inherent nature of “acting” being a personal preference …

Your argument was there is no fair and unfair in selecting actors for roles because acting is subjective (which is again wrong. Saying Salman is a better actor than Nawaz is not a subjective opinion. That's just you not knowing shit about acting).

And I proved you wrong by asking a simple question. Now you can keep on backtracking from your statements all you want. Acting is not subjective, and there's a lot of fair and unfair when casting decisions happen.

Originally posted by: pathaka

I wasn’t the one who didn’t properly the read the original post and made grand assumptions 😉

I made no assumptions when I called you out for playing victim of personal attacks when you've been the aggressor multiple times in many threads.

Originally posted by: AwaamKiJaan

Your argument was there is no fair and unfair in selecting actors for roles because acting is subjective (which is again wrong. Saying Salman is a better actor than Nawaz is not a subjective opinion. That's just you not knowing shit about acting).

And I proved you wrong by asking a simple question. Now you can keep on backtracking from your statements all you want. Acting is not subjective, and there's a lot of fair and unfair when casting decisions happen.

Fairness comes from standardisation

Where things can’t be standardised , there is no fairness ..

If someone thinks Salman is a better actor than nawaz, that’s a valid opinion …u are trying to impose a self created rule book of this is a good actor this is a bad actor …which someone else will not agree with

That right there, btw is called being on a high horse 😊…imposition of preferences as being a “fact”

Proved me wrong? when? Yeh galat faimi Kabse ho gayi?

U didn’t have a point to begin with because u ranted on a post that was not even trying to justify nepotism …moot is the word

There is nothing to prove

Originally posted by: AwaamKiJaan

I made no assumptions when I called you out for playing victim of personal attacks when you've been the aggressor multiple times in many threads.

u ranted on a post that wasn’t even justifying cronyism or whatever nonsense u assumed it was doing

Do with that what u will

Originally posted by: pathaka

Fairness comes from standardisation

Where things can’t be standardised , there is no fairness ..

If someone thinks Salman is a better actor than nawaz, that’s a valid opinion …u are trying to impose a self created rule book of this is a good actor this is a bad actor …which someone else will not agree with

That right there, btw is called being on a high horse 😊…imposition of preferences as being a “fact”

Proved me wrong? when? Yeh galat faimi Kabse ho gayi?

U didn’t have a point to begin with because u ranted on a post that was not even trying to justify nepotism …moot is the word

There is nothing to prove

Originally posted by: pathaka

u ranted on a post that wasn’t even justifying cronyism or whatever nonsense u assumed it was doing

Do with that what u will

Salman being a better actor than Nawaz is not a valid opinion. This itself shows how pathetic your whole argument is.🤣If he is then convince me how he is? If this is a valid opinion, then my opinion is it's okay to murder someone for your own personal benefit. I think it's okay to hire people based on their caste and religion. I think it's okay to take bribe. All this is my personal opinion. You think this is valid as well?😆

Acting books are already there. I don't need to self create it to convince you.

Prefering Salman is different than calling him a better actor than Nawaz. Don't play with words!

I proved you wrong when you didn't answer me the question of whether if a star kid is selected over 1000s of outsiders through audition, was the audition process 100% fair? That there tells what is fair and unfair in selection of roles. Your whole argument of "acting is subjective" is a completely different thing and doesn't justify how actors are selected.

And you weren't justifying cronyism either okay?😆Then why did you say you were talking about favoritism and not nepotism, and favouritism extends to non-nepos as well?

If your post wasn't justifying nepotism or cronyism then what was it about? What argument were you making and whom were trying to justify? What were you trying to say exactly?

That don't be hard on filmmakers if they make bad casting decisions because they're human and their opinion is subjective? Why should we do that? If we're watching a movie and we're not happy with the casting decision why shouldn't we call it out? And if nepotism is the reason behind it then why shouldn't we call that out either? Keep on retracing your steps.😆

I've seen you playing this argument before as well so I know what and whom you were trying to justify. But I understand ego is a big thing.😆 It didn't even had anything with this topic then what were you adding on? I didn't rant. You were ranting on this thread with multiple essays. I just merely called out your bullshit. 😆

Majnu Bhai is a better artist than Leonardo Da Vinci.😆

This

is better than this🤣

Art is subjective and this is my personal opinion so it's completely valid. Don't call it out otherwise you're sitting on a high horse.😆