who would you rather choose - Page 2

Originally posted by: Krishnapanchali

you have not read harry potter?? that blampsy how dare you ? 😆

ron ofcourse hermione loved that boy since 12 and he loved her

but still harry should have got the girl because he the "choosen one" even though the girl never gave a damn about his boy-who-lived status

No. I fell into a coma in the first chapter itself. I don’t like fantasy books unless it’s a hardcore romance novel. Personally speaking, I’d rather be single than choose any of the options (Harry vs Ron) lol. But generally speaking, of course I would choose option 2.

Originally posted by: FingerFetish

No. I fell into a coma in the first chapter itself. I don’t like fantasy books unless it’s a hardcore romance novel. Personally speaking, I’d rather be single than choose any of the options (Harry vs Ron) lol. But generally speaking, of course I would choose option 2.

😆 I knew the moment she brought up Harry Potter, it got you like --

Here we go again ....

Originally posted by: SmittenKitten

😆 I knew the moment she brought up Harry Potter, it got you like --

Here we go again ....

Brought back so much controversial memories. 😆

This comparison just doesn't work because canonically Harry-Hermione are just great pals and are never shown to harbor any romantic feelings towards eachother.

People think Harmony is better mainly because of David Yates, who seems to like the idea of Hermione being with the lead hero, and therefore added tons of non-canon one on one interactions between Daniel and Emma in the film series. While Ron is relegated to being the fumbling sidekick etc. Heck, film Ginny has it even worse with all her spunk and vibrance from the books being totally absent.

There are loads of video essays on this injustice on YT. So blind shippers should go and watch that before shoving their opinions on others like they are facts.

Ok rant over 😆

Originally posted by: Krishnapanchali

movies did horrible job on ron he is way better in the books and so was ginny plus she was the beautiful popular one and hermione the plaine jane who was "hard to love" but that s why i love hermione so much because i am like her shy find it hard to make friends bit of nerd so to speak

harry-hermione fans i had huge debate

i would pick ron anyday that guy begged begged bellarix to torture him instead he bllodied his hand while trying to break the prison cell to get to hermione eventually saved and her

above all hermione loved him and he loved her

i haven't read all the books but i have watched the movies so many times that i've lost count. I like Hermione too cuz she always saved the day with her tricks.

not sure why we're only left with harry and ron as our choices. if i had the option to choose Lily's love for Harry, I'd choose that.... cuz such is the power of unconditional love, it can literally shield you from bad energies even after the person is long gone and you can conjure up a patronus that can always come in handy during your darkest moments.

Actually, I don't mind Snape either. For someone who wasn't even with Lily the whole time, he really came through.

Originally posted by: FilmiDhun

This comparison just doesn't work because canonically Harry-Hermione are just great pals and are never shown to harbor any romantic feelings towards eachother.

People think Harmony is better mainly because of David Yates, who seems to like the idea of Hermione being with the lead hero, and therefore added tons of non-canon one on one interactions between Daniel and Emma in the film series. While Ron is relegated to being the fumbling sidekick etc. Heck, film Ginny has it even worse with all her spunk and vibrance from the books being totally absent.

There are loads of video essays on this injustice on YT. So blind shippers should go and watch that before shoving their opinions on others like they are facts.

Ok rant over 😆

thank you the harmony brigade who have only seen the movies is so widespred that i feel so happy to meet book readers 😆

not only david yates it started with poa with hermione taking up ron s moment of defend harry against sirius black

harty should have gotten hermione why? because he was the choose one as if she was some trophy

Originally posted by: SmittenKitten

i haven't read all the books but i have watched the movies so many times that i've lost count. I like Hermione too cuz she always saved the day with her tricks.

not sure why we're only left with harry and ron as our choices. if i had the option to choose Lily's love for Harry, I'd choose that.... cuz such is the power of unconditional love, it can literally shield you from bad energies even after the person is long gone and you can conjure up a patronus that can always come in handy during your darkest moments.

Actually, I don't mind Snape either. For someone who wasn't even with Lily the whole time, he really came through.

that s thing hermione didnt always saved the day in movies they gave hermione many a moments that was not hers that actually belonged to ron or harry they turned her to be so perfect that it actually took the nuances that hermione had

she is very lovable the way she is i adore her because of how i much i relate to her in books there was no need to give her ron or harry s moments specially rons to put her onto a pedestal

i had a huge debate with harmony shipper hence the question

i agree mother s love is one of the purest love out there and it saved harry twice

i am not much of snape fan honestly he has his own set of crimes

i like remus though i think he was great and mcgonall and dumbeldore though he is very infamous 😆

Originally posted by: FilmiDhun

This comparison just doesn't work because canonically Harry-Hermione are just great pals and are never shown to harbor any romantic feelings towards eachother.

People think Harmony is better mainly because of David Yates, who seems to like the idea of Hermione being with the lead hero, and therefore added tons of non-canon one on one interactions between Daniel and Emma in the film series. While Ron is relegated to being the fumbling sidekick etc. Heck, film Ginny has it even worse with all her spunk and vibrance from the books being totally absent.

There are loads of video essays on this injustice on YT. So blind shippers should go and watch that before shoving their opinions on others like they are facts.

Ok rant over 😆

did i see your claws come out here? 😆 since i haven't read the books much and my opinions rely mostly on movies, i should exit this discussion while i'm ahead.

Originally posted by: SmittenKitten

did i see your claws come out here? 😆 since i haven't read the books much and my opinions rely mostly on movies, i should exit this discussion while i'm ahead.

Lol, I am chill with all ships honestly. It's fine to enjoy movie interpretations that dont match books or to ship a non-canon/problematic pairing, since being part of a fandom is about feeling passionate about a story/character/pairing and just having fun.

However, unfortunately every fandom has got those loud and obnoxious fans who think they are somehow morally superior for their fandom choices and actively try to make fans of other ships/characters miserable. These fans do so by making toxic, morally preachy and often misinformed comments that simplify complexities of characters they hate or turn a blind eye to counter arguments.

Example 1: Ron is just some dumbo who is always scared as shit and needs saving from his superior best friends (Not true, he is equally chivalrous)

Example 2: Snape in an incel who was only after Lily because of lust (Not true, incels are people who blame women for their non-existent love life. Snape never blamed Lily for anything and left her alone when she cut off ties with him).

Schools need to stress on pupils using punctuation marks…