There are no takers for Alia's 'stardom'! - Page 3

Originally posted by: cougarTown

it does..numbers are facts and they define stardom..it is all based on these numbers your brands are decided..your fee is decided..everything is based on them so we cannot ignore them when talking about stardom..if kangana demanded and got what she did it was only through the numbers Queen and TWMR made..

Ok if it does then Shraddha is a bigger star than Alu by that logic

Confirmed

You can argue she is the 2nd biggest thing to happen to Dharma since SRK.

The fact that you are comparing Alia's stardom to Deepika(who in ur mind is the biggest female superstar)....and you are trying to prove that Alia has less stardom than Deepu means that their stardoms are comparable atleast...even in ur mind😆.....the fact that u are downplaying Alia's stardom by giving excuses of Dharma and KJo and her being a starkid is proof enough that u consider it a challenge to Deepu's stardom...😆

IMO....even though I don't like Deepu...but still I consider her a bigger star than Alia...when it comes to the big female stars of BW of all times...Deepu will always be there....that doesn't mean that u dismiss off a younger star like Alia by saying that she is a success because of Dharma or KJo or her being a star kid.....why doesn't ur logic apply to other star kids like AB Jr or Esha Deol or Bobby Deol or Tanisha Mukherjee or Tushar Kapoor ...the list is endless....why didn't these kids who are the offsprings of much bigger superstars didn't survive....How about giving some credit to the audience who makes and breaks these stars...what are ur thoughts on Salman being a huge success and both his brother are not?..How about Alia being a really good actress ....infact she is 10 times the actress that Deepu can ever be.....how do u ignore that the audience wants to see her that is why they watch her movies? How about giving the credit where its due...

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

The fact that you are comparing Alia's stardom to Deepika(who in ur mind is the biggest female superstar)....and you are trying to prove that Alia has less stardom than Deepu means that their stardoms are comparable atleast...even in ur mind😆.....the fact that u are downplaying Alia's stardom by giving excuses of Dharma and KJo and her being a starkid is proof enough that u consider it a challenge to Deepu's stardom...😆

IMO....even though I don't like Deepu...but still I consider her a bigger star than Alia...when it comes to the big female stars of BW of all times...Deepu will always be there....that doesn't mean that u dismiss off a younger star like Alia by saying that she is a success because of Dharma or KJo or her being a star kid.....why doesn't ur logic apply to other star kids like AB Jr or Esha Deol or Bobby Deol or Tanisha Mukherjee or Tushar Kapoor ...the list is endless....why didn't these kids who are the offsprings of much bigger superstars didn't survive....How about giving some credit to the audience who makes and breaks these stars...what are ur thoughts on Salman being a huge success and both his brother are not?..How about Alia being a really good actress ....infact she is 10 times the actress that Deepu can ever be.....how do u ignore that the audience wants to see her that is why they watch her movies? How about giving the credit where its due...

First off, Alia is touted as a star as big as deepika in the industry. thats where the comparisons come from. Its not the audience, its the industry. Theres no downplaying she is doing. She is saying what her stardom is being percieved by the media/industry insiders and comparing that to reality.

Esha Deol, AB JR was not talented. Alia is talented to an extent hence she is accepted by not only the audience but more so by the industry...who overrates her to death and puts her in the same leage as actresses like Priyanka, Deepika who have went through sweat and tears to reach where they are. Do I think they are seen as conventioanl "stars" more by the audience? Yes, immensely. More so than Alia. You cant ever down play her opportunties, the amout of films she has recieved through help/lobbing.

give me a break. Her post is about stardom not whos the better actress. Theres a difference.

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

How about Alia being a really good actress ....infact she is 10 times the actress that Deepu can ever be....

Don't wanna contest on other parts.. but aisa kaunsa phenomenal acting Kari hai Aalia Bitiya ne..

Aur Deepika ki acting ki to baat hi na Karo.

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

IMO....even though I don't like Deepu...but still I consider her a bigger star than Alia...when it comes to the big female stars of BW of all times...

That’s historically speaking. But What about right now who is more effective box office and stardom wise ?

Originally posted by: Zeal17

Don't wanna contest on other parts.. but aisa kaunsa phenomenal acting Kari hai Aalia Bitiya ne..

Aur Deepika ki acting ki to baat hi na Karo.

You don't have to do phenomenal acting to be 10 times better than Deepika.....I was comparing her to Deepika.....not Priayanka or Vidya or Tabu😉

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

That’s historically speaking. But What about right now who is more effective box office and stardom wise ?

Deepika's peak still outshines Alias peak of BO success's put together. thats the problem. It may be in the past..but alia is desperately trying to outshine that 2013-2014 peak has which put DP into suprstardom. It may happen this year for her though with gangubai, sadak 2...

Originally posted by: vsbarry

Deepika's peak still outshines Alias peak of BO success's put together. thats the problem. It may be in the past..but alia is desperately trying to outshine that 2013-2014 peak has which put DP into suprstardom. It may happen this year for her though with gangubai, sadak 2...

yes but in 2020 Alia surely outshines Deepika.

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

yes but in 2020 Alia surely outshines Deepika.

Yes on the basis of current BO, I agree. But overall, no. and she may never meet her overall. She may just stay on top in the moment, then someone else will be there another year