If RK or RS had done Kabir Singh, would they had won an award? - Page 4

No, if the story remains the same. Filmfare isn't against Shahid, afterall he is part of BW family. The movie was misogynistic, violent and demeaning towards women, hence the snub. Also vanga had rubbed people the wrong way from his extremely objectionable attitude

They would . Infact even the critics might have been less harsh with the criticism

Originally posted by: mintyblue

No, they would not have.

The mindset pervasive among the jury probably was that they didn't want to award a film which glorified toxic masculinity. If they had given the award to the film, it would have invited a backlash among several sections of the media, and they were not willing to take the risk.

Everybody gotta be woke

But what value does this “filmfare” have if they just start ignoring films over these trivial matters. 😂

Originally posted by: 2RsFan

They would . Infact even the critics might have been less harsh with the criticism

Could that be why no questions Safeena and Murad in Gully Boy gettin back together even tho she nearly killed some girl 😆

Originally posted by: 2RsFan

They would . Infact even the critics might have been less harsh with the criticism

And why is that?

Is shahid some kind of "soutela" for media & critics ?

The same critics who praised shahid to skies whenever he performed good

The same critics and jury awarded him for films like kameenay u.p haider etc whenever he was worthy of award

the same industry gave him chances after chances in plum projects & main leads since last 18 long years despite him having just a very few hits in his entire career, very unlike other actors

Plz stop making shahid kapoor a victim for no reason.

Mazloom Shahid, my heart bleeds for him

Originally posted by: Doodh_Ki_Dhuli

Mazloom Shahid, my heart bleeds for him

😔 He must be so saaaaad like he was when asked about Kabir's problematic behaviour with Preeti. He was so sad that he said ' Teri behen ya gf lagti hain kya. Tune personally le lia' As if a woman only deserves respect when she is related to you. What a sad sad man.

Originally posted by: TeAmo_Messi

yes i am sure RS/Rk would have won it. If for once we consider that one actor is not allowed to win for a scene by scene remake, then Shahid should not have been nominated at the first place, considering there were controversies about the movie's plot and also it was not an original movie, then what was the point of nominating him?

Coming back to the best actor award, Shahid did not deserve it as much as Hrithik it, I believe he definitely deserved it for delivering two very successful and completely different movies one of which was also the highest grosser and also a very very popular one compared to Ranveer's gullyboy. And if Hrithik was not deserving, then Akshay was the most deserving, he delivered 4 superits and ofcourse just all four movies had different genres, he delivered a kesari, a housefull and a mission mangal in the same year and if that is not popularity then what is 'Best actor popular' meant for?

Anyways, let us move on to 83 and Shubh mangal zyada, next year RS and Ayushman will win again for these respective movies 👍🏼😵

I don't think there is any hard and fast rule for FF popular winners... If FF best actor popular is given to the most popular and highest grossing films Shahid would have never won for Haidar (an average grosser) over Aamir for PK and HR for BangBang. Salman should have won for Bajrangi Bhaijan over Ranveer for Bajirao.

Originally posted by: blue-ice.1

Isn't acting award for acting?? how does it matter what character he played?? Aise toh negative character play karne walo ko koi award mat doh fir....seriously all these people riding on their high horses need to come down...🤢

This!!!!

Shahid played a character called Kabir Singh that was the personification of toxic masculinity..

If the character has received so much backlash, it means that Shahid Kapoor has done a good job going to the skin of the character.

In short he justified himself as an A.C.T.O.R...

Sadly I think if Ranbir done the role, he could have got the award.

Although I think there would have been equal backlash.

I blame the director entirely, he came out in public TIME AND TIME AGAIN to pronounce the toxic behaviour in his film. If he didn't do that, perhaps the audiences would have been more forgiving, and the award shows less scared.

But it's a huge shame because Shahid Kapoor as Kabir Singh was the best performance of 2019 by a Male Actress.