Why is it okay for Jhansi ki Rani to dance and not okay for Rani Padma

Created

Last reply

Replies

36

Views

4.4k

Users

13

Likes

47

Frequent Posters

TotalBetty thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 6 years ago
#2
Why?

Link doesn't work
MainHeroineHoon thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#3
Director Krish Jagarlamudi is done with the bickering with Kangana Ranaut. "I've had my say. No more. If she (Ranaut) wants to believe she directed all of Manikarnika, so be it. Everyone knows the truth, asserts Krish and vows to not get into any more war of words with the film's aggressive leading lady and co-director.


However one major issue that needs to be addressed is that regarding the singing and dancing that Rani of Jhansi is seen indulging in with her subjects. In an elaborate song and dance sequence Rani Laxmibai embarrasses the hell out of her husband the King of Jhansi (played by Jisshu Sengupta) by dancing with the people of their State in a pregnant condition.

A source very close to the film says that the song and dance during times of raging battles was Kangana's idea. "Ek toh Rani opoopar se garvwati (a queen and then pregnant)...how can she be shown dancing in that unbecoming fashion? Krish was totally against the idea. The song-and-dance was added on by Kangana after Krish left, says the source.

Significantly when another Rani, Padmavati in a big epic film in January 2018, Sanjay Leela Bhansali's Padmaavat got up from her throne to take to the dancefloor with her ladies in waiting, all hell had broken loose. Deepika's Rani Padmavati was shown dancing to the Ghoomar' song in the most graceful and queenly manner in a closed environment with the women from her durbar.

Director Sanjay Bhansali had said to me, "We wanted the Ghoomar' song and dance to retain its purity since this was being performed by Rani Padmavati. Every step and every move in the dance form celebrates the royal grace of royalty. This is our dance tribute to the brave Rajput women of Rajasthan. I heard how little children performing the Ghoomar' dance at a school in India were stopped. I'd like to tell those disruptive elements that you can't stop something as beautiful and innocent as this from reaching out into the hearts of people across the world.

Sanjay Bhansali's heart swells with pride to see Ghoomar' reaching into the hearts and feet of American kids. Says the director, "What better illustration of our prime minster Narendra Modiji's Make In India' policy? I feel our culture is so rich and varied. We've so much to give the West. Why not take our culture and art forms to the West rather than continuously borrow their lifestyle and culture?

All hell had broken lose with fringe groups demanding that the song-and-dance from Bhansali's be removed or else they would cut off Deepika's nose. Says a source very close to the Padmaavat team, "When we showed Deepika dancing in the Queen's inner chambers, we had to digitally cover Deepika's midriff before the censor board allowed the Ghoomar' song. Now in Manikarnika , again about a royal Queen, Kangana's Rani Laxmibai jumps off her seat and breaks into a street-side jig with the commoners. That was okay? What is good enough for Rani Laxmbai is not befitting for Rani Padmavati? Please figure out that one.

When pressed for a response Krish said, "I don't know where the singing and dancing came from. It wasn't there when I was directing Manikarnika. The question remains. Why was it not right for Rani Padmavati to dance when everyone seems okay with Rani Of Jhansi shaking a leg? Midriff forgotten.

pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

LOL The Rani of Jhansi didnt know she was pregnant when she danced a little bit with the villagers. Its only while dancing that she almost passed out, the Raja arrived to blast her but then got the best news of his life when the village Dayima checked Manu and said she was pregnant. And its not as if the queen started dancing by herself, its only towards the end of the dance when her newfound friend Jhalkari Bai got into a josh and pulled the queen's hand to get up and dance, then the queen happily joined the villagers who were quite taken aback to see her dance but then Manu was always a free spirited girl who broke all rules and social norms like refusing to bow before that British general
Also there is a big difference is the historical time periods shown in the 2 movies compared. Queen Padmini of Chittor was from the 13th-14th century when women were not so progressive and married women were restricted to andarmahal mainly.
While Rani of Jhansi was from 19th century, she was brought up more modern and progressive, she was well read, knew archery, sword fighting and horse riding so her dancing with villagers was not out of character.

576281 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: pallavi25


LOL The Rani of Jhansi didnt know she was pregnant when she danced a little bit with the villagers. Its only while dancing that she almost passed out, the Raja arrived to blast her but then got the best news of his life when the village Dayima checked Manu and said she was pregnant. And its not as if the queen started dancing by herself, its only towards the end of the dance when her newfound friend Jhalkari Bai got into a josh and pulled the queen's hand to get up and dance, then the queen happily joined the villagers who were quite taken aback to see her dance but then Manu was always a free spirited girl who broke all rules and social norms like refusing to bow before that British general
Also there is a big difference is the historical time periods shown in the 2 movies compared. Queen Padmini of Chittor was from the 13th-14th century when women were not so progressive and married women were restricted to andarmahal mainly.
While Rani of Jhansi was from 19th century, she was brought up more modern and progressive, she was well read, knew archery, sword fighting and horse riding so her dancing with villagers was not out of character.


Women from 19th century danced showing off their midriff? 😆

My grandmother is even more modern than Manu, but she would be scandalized to dance in front of her family- let alone in front of so many people - that too showing off her midriff!

The fact of the matter is, both of them were a fictional depiction and we should leave it at that!


MoonOrchid thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6
Exactly.. this article is great..
So?? All those scandalised with Padma dancing.. was it okay for Manuka to dance?

I wanna see the excuses..😆

pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: cricketfan1


Women from 19th century danced showing off their midriff? 😆

My grandmother is even more modern than Manu, but she would be scandalized to dance in front of her family- let alone in front of so many people - that too showing off her midriff!

The fact of the matter is, both of them were a fictional depiction and we should leave it at that!



If u remember in the original Ghoomar, Padma's midriff was showing, then after those Karni Sena goons and other sanskari purists made a fuss, SLB did some editing and Padma's midriff was covered.
For Manikarnina, Kangu did not care to edit or cover up because there were no serious protests from any Sena except that one guy who made a video but didnt follow up
576281 thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: pallavi25


If u remember in the original Ghoomar, Padma's midriff was showing, then after those Karni Sena goons and other sanskari purists made a fuss, SLB did some editing and Padma's midriff was covered.
For Manikarnina, Kangu did not care to edit or cover up because there were no serious protests from any Sena except that one guy who made a video but didnt follow up


So if no one is bothered to ask, its okay to expose the midriff to that extent? Even in the beginning scene she wears a tiny mini blouse completely exposing her midriff...

SLB may have covered it later but I remember seeing it in some before video and thinking 'wow that looks problematic'!

Both are mere fictional depictions and should be taken with a pinch of salt, and be left at that...IMHO!


Edited by cricketfan1 - 6 years ago
angrybread thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
#9
Both of them danced and they are still dancing in our tvs so what is the issue here ?
Shaitan-Haiwan thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail 13th Anniversary Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 6 years ago
#10
Makes you think doesnt it? perhaps the whole Padmavat controversy was orchestrated...wake up people.

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 6 days ago

Rani discusses 8 hour shifts says she worked 5 hours Hicki https://x.com/ani/status/1973355966482751537?s=46 t=gmo_g396jwmtO4eUOAuljw

https://x.com/ani/status/1973355966482751537?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Rosyme · 10 days ago

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPHCAZSEzm_/?igsh=NHUxNWVlbG9jM2Rn

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPHCAZSEzm_/?igsh=NHUxNWVlbG9jM2Rn
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 15 days ago

Shah Rukh Khan, Rani Vikrant at the National film awards cersmony https://x.com/ani/status/1970437587610288548?s=46 t=gmo_g396jwmtO4eUOAuljw...

https://x.com/ani/status/1970437587610288548?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 10 days ago

Kajol and Rani hug at Durga Puja https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPHOpUhDOoR/?igsh=cDBhdjFqYjN3eHd2

https://www.instagram.com/reel/DPHOpUhDOoR/?igsh=cDBhdjFqYjN3eHd2
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: Sutapasima · 14 days ago

https://twitter.com/GossipsTv/status/1970481023491404050

https://twitter.com/GossipsTv/status/1970481023491404050
Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".