Ek Ladki Ko Dekha to Aisa Laga review thread - Page 29

Created

Last reply

Replies

335

Views

39.8k

Users

72

Likes

860

Frequent Posters

mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago

A Lesbian Bollywood Buff, I've Waited For Ek Ladki Ko Dekha To Aisa Laga' All My Life!

Someday, this Sonam Kapoor film will be a cult film in Bollywood's history.

  • Debolina Dey
SCREENSHOT FROM YOUTUBE

This is not a review, this is a love letter to a film I have now watched twice in two days. If I could rate Sonam Kapoor's Ek Ladki Ko Dekha To Aisa Laga as a cardholding lesbian, I'd give it 4.5/5.

Let me explain why. Firstly, because the film is a sign that there can be such a thing as lesbian drama', even in Bollywood.

The film's solidarity is not hinged on just one secret about who Sweety (Sonam Kapoor) loves, but how love brings out the best potential in you including Balbir Choudhary's (Anil Kapoor) hidden' talent for cooking. The spectrum of fear in the film ranges from homophobia, internal homophobia to Islamophobia.

Lesbian drama is not just a dysfunction, potentially, it is a tour de force that will challenge patriarchy. Ek Ladki Ko Dekha To Aisa Laga shows how understanding the film's lesbian character Sweety gives the other heterosexual characters the clarity to fight patriarchy. It's as if Sweety's coming out' to her father, gives the latter the courage to follow his dream of cooking. It also leads to Balbir and Chattro (played by Juhi Chawla) getting into a partnership'.

In the film, same sex love moves away from the epicentre of queer discourse which usually happens in Delhi and is set in the old world of a small town of Moga (how delightful!).

In the film, same sex love moves away from the epicentre of queer discourse which usually happens in Delhi and is set in the old world of a small town of Moga (how delightful!).

SUBSCRIBE AND FOLLOW ENTERTAINMENT

Get our top news delivered to your inbox every morning, Monday to Friday. Newsletters may offer personalized content or advertisements. Learn more

Newsletter

Where else will non normative love become transgressive? Who else will love empower?

Away from clever discourse of Delhi and other metro cities, the film's softness reminds you of a time when we called it "same sex love. Even if well intentioned queer discourses have intervened meaningfully in our ideas of sex and gender, have we forgotten what it means to love radically and fiercely when we are so caught up in the cleverness of labelling ourselves right through political correctness? Well then, if not political correctness then poetic licence in films like this brings back heart for a community that could do with some hope.

The film might touch a chord in all of us, but it's especially raw for the small-town lesbian.

The film might touch a chord in all of us, but it's especially raw for the small-town lesbian. At one point, Sweety (played by Sonam Kapoor) said she had just two options before her: run away or die. Growing up in Siliguri, a small hill town in West Bengal I remember being shamed and teased in school bullied even. The film shows Sonam's character Sweety being mocked, shunned by her classmates and her friend, a boy, being beaten up for being too effeminate'.

This film fuses head and heart, though it puts heart before logic at times. If you thought softness isn't politicalyou have to watch this film. This film touches the softest parts in youand celebrates love. Unlike other Punjabi, possibly fearful directors from Bollywood who only halfway dip their toes into same sex love through parody, wit and sarcasm, the makers of Ek Ladki Ko Dekha To Aisa Laga are here to warm the cockles of your heart.

SCREENSHOT FROM YOUTUBE

It is no secret that the straight world's hypocrisy of contrasts depends on how they have a public and private life while, for them, the queer world of same sex love has public, public and secret lives. If it is not sexuality, there is always some secret that is meant outed', as the film shows. The film underlines the ridiculousness of resorting to patriarchal ways of making meaning of a situation. When nearing the interval, Sweety shouts, "sabka dimaag ek hi direction mein kyu chalta hain (why do people's minds run in one direction you really feel her frustration.

The script of this film is the real protagonist, edited in a way that every scene sticks with the glue of emotion. Even the scenes where the onlookers and minor characters bet playfully is done with so much sweetness that it can only be a win-win. There is a luminosity and lightness in this film that is missing in portraying lesbians even in world cinema.

Lesbian films are usually about dark intimacies and squashed desires without happy endings.

Lesbian films are usually about dark intimacies and squashed desires without happy endings. But intimacies can be playful, light and hopeful, as this film shows. The movie never for once misses its mark and gets derailed into a moral high ground of preaching or proving a point. Yes I could have asked for moremore romance in the Hauz Khas ruins of Delhi between Sweety and Kuhu (fingers crossed for a sequel), but this will do for the time being.

The climax of the film is clever. It revolves around Rajkummar Rao's character Sahil staging a play in Moga about two women in love. As the play in the film progresses, members of the audience are shown leaving in anger and disgust. A play within a play is, therefore, a classic way of showing self-awareness. The audience of the play in the movie in Moga anticipates the audience reaction to the film in big cities already

A scene in the climax shows Sweety, emotionally wounded from being rejected, trapped in a glass box (in a play within the film) and calling out desperately to her father to free' her. That scene made me shudder and touched a raw nerve in me. I wish my mother watches this film and gives me a call. Did I say lesbians love drama already?

I wish my mother watches this film and gives me a call. Did I say lesbians love drama already?

As a gender fluid person who fit herself into Bollywood's songs and stereotypes as and when she pleased, I don't know which part of my intersectional identity feels the most vindicated by this hug of a film. It's as if, Ek Ladki Ko Dekha To Aisa Laga touched multiple aspects of my personality and existence queer small-town Bollywood buff, '90s fan, survivor of bullying, member of an often-Islamophonic family, wannabe chef, diary keeper, a someone tired of being badgered to get married. It's as if every piece of me sighed been there' throughout the film.

Ek Ladki Ko Dekha To Aisa Laga represents how love should be. Be it Balbir's love for cooking, Kuhu's love for Sweety, Sahil's love for his art, his mother's love for him, Chhatro's love for acting and the matriarch Beeji's love for her family the film paints a staggering panorama of how love should look like. And how, when allowed to take over, love makes the most understanding, empathetic human beings.

ALSO READ

LifeOLicious thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
Going to see it today...I haven't read any of the reviews...can't wait to watch, read and discuss...hope I like the film!
Edited by LifeOLicious - 6 years ago
LifeOLicious thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique


BO collection is an indicator of whether mainstream audience has taken to a film or not or simply if it has reached those markets and infiltrated them. If this movie was made for making lgbtq content for mainstream audience then its important to know whether it has been successful or not. Only posting good reviews mean nothing. Intent or content has its own space and box office its own and both are equally important. Period.


True. I think this hasn't reached the desired audience as much as the movie makers would have liked through the theater. The 2nd Friday numbers are a little disappointing. I think they have to do more to reach that audience. Have screenings in smaller towns and promote it through the local newspapers. It won't be easy but I hope they at least try!

It has done more for the lgbtq community though. Can't deny that.
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago
They literally left the promotion till the last week. For a good few weeks before there was no hype around it because they probably wanted to keep it under wraps.

Even after the film released they didn't mention the word lesbian, it's like they avoided using the word completely.
mintyblue thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 6 years ago
The movie is light and it's strength lies in that, as the above review points out. There are no dark scenes or any steamy scenes and is not meant to titillate. I like the fact that the lesbian story is woven within a sanctified family entertainer framework, and I think that's what makes it special.it makes sense to make a movie that is digestible because it comes with plenty of teachable moments and healthy doses of melodrama. It does a good job on those moments too, without becoming overly preachy.Also, I found the scenes between the 2 lead actresses adequate enough, and did not wish for more, unlike what some feel. The main aim was to sensitise, and not stigmatise.
Edited by mintyblue - 6 years ago
AllThatCritique thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: LifeOLicious


True. I think this hasn't reached the desired audience as much as the movie makers would have liked through the theater. The 2nd Friday numbers are a little disappointing. I think they have to do more to reach that audience. Have screenings in smaller towns and promote it through the local newspapers. It won't be easy but I hope they at least try!

It has done more for the lgbtq community though. Can't deny that.


The movie has represented the community in a mainstream space. But script-wise it falls ridiculously short. Its an important film for its intent but content wise its nothing to write home about. The other day my friend and I,both of us part of the community, were talking about how more importance should have been given to the young part of the protagonist who was struggling. Thats never been shown in movies. And how more conversations between Sweety and Kuhu needed to be shown.


A movie like this will obviously connect with the community and allies but it needed to connect with the masses so their approach at subtlety and not really promoting the movie as it should have been played a huge role its failure. I said this once in another thread but Indian audience really dont care about subtlety. So either go all out with the subject or dont. In this age of the internet and SM if one really thinks they can full the audience with that approach its never gonna work.
AllThatCritique thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

They literally left the promotion till the last week. For a good few weeks before there was no hype around it because they probably wanted to keep it under wraps.

Even after the film released they didn't mention the word lesbian, it's like they avoided using the word completely.


This! It was almost like they wanted to make the movie on the subject but without the responsibility that comes with it.
*Reemz* thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 6 years ago

Originally posted by: AllThatCritique



The movie has represented the community in a mainstream space. But script-wise it falls ridiculously short. Its an important film for its intent but content wise its nothing to write home about. The other day my friend and I,both of us part of the community, were talking about how more importance should have been given to the young part of the protagonist who was struggling. Thats never been shown in movies. And how more conversations between Sweety and Kuhu needed to be shown.


A movie like this will obviously connect with the community and allies but it needed to connect with the masses so their approach at subtlety and not really promoting the movie as it should have been played a huge role its failure. I said this once in another thread but Indian audience really dont care about subtlety. So either go all out with the subject or dont. In this age of the internet and SM if one really thinks they can full the audience with that approach its never gonna work.




I think they wanted to tick the Bollywood boxes. The family should be able to see it, the length should be short, there should be a hetero male so they can keep the message under wraps and of course, they felt like they had to add unnecessary comical sequences which didn't add to the main storyline.

I haven't seen Veere di wedding but didn't that open at 10cr? All women bonding, no male lead, apparently had a mast***tion scene? ELKDTAL was so chaste but they were too scared to say what it was, to give us more conversations. It felt like they were constantly going back on what they were trying to go forward with.
Nabakov_Musings thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 6 years ago
all the best wishes for this movie.
return_to_hades thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 6 years ago
Box Office collections do not indicate whether a movie is good or bad. They do not indicate the relevance or importance of content either. Nevertheless, they are one very important aspect of evaluating films. It shows how well the film has been embraced by the mainstream audience. It shows the willingness of people to pay for the content and its stars. As much as I love and support this film, the fact is the box office numbers are abysmal. If the makers wanted this film to receive mainstream acceptance, they have failed.
----------

I personally love the film. I can't wait for the opportunity to watch it again and again.

However, I can see where a lot of criticism of the script comes from. The makers were clearly unsure of the direction. Is this for mainstream or LGBTQ folks and their allies? Is this a love story or a tale of acceptance? Do we promote the lesbian aspect or do we keep it wraps for a surprise twist? Due to the lack of clarity in answering these questions, the film falters in its narrative quality.

I am completely fine with the faltering. Your average film does not have to answer these questions. Some movies out there are shit despite a clear direction. But for many people, they would rather have a film with clarity rather than try to straddle too many expectations and miss on all.

Related Topics

Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 6 months ago

https://news24online.com/entertainment/shefali-jariwalas-iconic-track-kaanta-laga-retired-forever-by-makers-after-her-sudden-demise/600019/

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

Gustaakh Ishq review and box office...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 1 months ago

T-series released the trailer in Hindi Review praises rashmika...

Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: priya185 · 4 months ago

Param Sundari review and box office https://x.com/umairsandu/status/1960372607494115457?s=46 t=gmo_g396jwmtO4eUOAuljw

https://x.com/umairsandu/status/1960372607494115457?s=46
Expand ▼
Bollywood thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood · 1 months ago

...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".