If Mahima Chaudary was a Star-Daughter.. - Page 2

Originally posted by: Resident_Evil

Mahima was nothing special and she debuted when she was 24 years old. And that too in the 90s. Where does that leave her in terms of a career? 6 years? She had a string of flop films and thus her career ended. Plus her constant controversies didn't help her career either.

And what guarantees does a star daughter hold? Tanisha was a star sister AND a daughter, whatever happened to her?

Originally posted by: pyaari_puja

Controversies?! What was she involved in?

Originally posted by: Resident_Evil

Well firstly the whole Subhash Ghai thing. Apparently the word was that she slept with him for the debut and then they had a falling out. Then there was the fallout with Ramgopal Varma and fight with Urmila over Satya. Then she was linked to a number of people,has an affair with Leander Pears and producers were reluctant to sign her. She also had an affair with Ajay Devgan. She was notorious for being difficult on the sets and for picking fights. Her career was over in a span of 3 years.

Originally posted by: Nikhil718

I always hear these same stuff about many chances these starkids get but nothing guarantees success no matter how many opportunities are given. In the 90s, Mahima got so many chances but in between those lines, she had fall out with fallout with Subhash Ghai hence her contract being withdrawn. Poor choices of films were part of the downfall of her career.

Amisha Patel was an outsider who was given several chances despite of her bad acting. Again poor choices of films barring Gadar, Kaho Na Pyaar Hai, Humraaz and so and so.

Originally posted by: grumpydwarf

Mahima was a stunner.. She was suppose to be in Taal.. But Aish bagged that due to the Mahima Subash Ghai fallout

Originally posted by: cougarTown

fall out with Subhash really affected her career

heard there was also some issue over her payment for Pardes..she claimed he didn't pay her what she was promised and threatened to take him to court after which not only he withdrew from the contract he signed her for..but also asked other producers etc to not sign her

btw was taal a success?

Originally posted by: cougarTown

So Mahima had a dream launch and won filmfare best debut over the likes of rani and Aish but totally went from that to C grade movies and eventually disappearing without a trace

so my Q is

would the present situation be any different if she was a star daughter?

would she have been still given A list work or it would have more or less been the same

personally..Mahima not making it big remains a big shock for me

imo she was the ultimate package who could act..dance..looked amazing..had a great dialogue delivery..she just had no one to guide her

but some may feel just the opposite and would think she would have fizzled sooner or later regardless like esha..udya..tushar etc

what do you guys think?