Kabir Khan - joins the overrated list - Page 2

He is a decent director...

He is decent director. Baas he should ask someone else to write the story. 😆

When was he not overrated?

Even BB was such a 'in your face' movie in terms of trying to wring out the emotions from its audience...

The really GREAT directors of Hindi Cinema in no particular order - GURU DUTT, BIMAL ROY, K ASIF, HRISHIKESH MUKHERJEE, RAJ KAPOOR, RAJU HIRANI .. Other than that all others are somewhat overrated .. Would have add Ashutosh if he hadn't made any film after Jodha Akber ..

Even BB was inspired from THEO ANGELOPOULOS film "Eternity ana A Day" and had VJ Prasad as scriptwriter

yes overrated n nothing great director, just limited n avg.

Hmmm his best work till date for me is still New York. I know exactly how the film ends but have still watched it multiple times because the thriller element never erases even after multiple viewings. The way the story unravels, the bond between Katrina, Neil and John, the beautiful songs and the perfect placement of them, the strong impact that the scenes leave (especially that scene with Nawazuddin and Katrina) and the emotions they elicit, the way the ending still hits so hard, the tight editing...I could go on. Everything flowed so beautifully in the film.

Originally posted by: anonymous39

^Tubelight is a very transparent attempt at replicating Bajrangi success. In the other movie, it was Pakistan. Here, it's China. Add in a cute kid and silly sentimental crying and melodrama. It worked with Bajragi because it was authentic. Here it was cynical.

But yeah, anyone's fault but Salman's.

He is a documentary maker 😲. I did not know that . No wonder that s what tube light looks like 😡. Do not release this kind of movie on eid .