Did Karishma dance better than Madhuri in the Dance of Envy (DTPH)? - Page 5

Originally posted by: chahat4u

It was because Madhuri was pregnant at time of Dola Re shooting in Saroj Khan's own words in Nachle ve with Saroj Khan.

Originally posted by: ponymo

Surely the meaning of stiff is different for person to person I guess because Aishwarya was extremely graceful and fluid in Dola Re. In fact Ash was given harder steps too, with more turns and bends, all of which she did flawlessly. Madhuri was equally great, just that she was given simpler steps and her relatively heavier physique made it difficult for her to do it as effortlessly.

Pinga in itself is an underwhelming song when compared to Dola Re where both the dancers don't even come across as real dancers. So nothing to say about that.

Originally posted by: flipfl0p

Aishwarya was anything but fluid in Dola Re. May be she was given difficult steps. But she did it as if it was a drill excercise. Just watch Madhuri in "baand ke mei ghumroo", then Aish in "pehenke mei payal". One looks fluid, other looks like drill. When both dance together on dola re (signature step), Madhuri's body seems to swing, Aish seems jumping.

I would repeat the same thing, what I mentioned about Karishma-Madhuri. Aish was younger, had better figure, more energy. But she was not good at dancing technique. Whether Aish or Deepika, they have just joined Bharat Natyam classes for the name sake. But few months of Bharat Natyam training cannot be equated to years of learning Kathak.

I would agree, Pinga was an underwhelming song compared to Dola Re.