Logic behind Muslim characters in ADHM ?

Page

Next Last

rimi2983

@rimi2983

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Hi All,

This post may have Spoilers.

I watched ADHM ( online, before you send me "Hypocrite alerts"😉). I don't want to get into any discussion about story or BO. I have just one question, that I have been asking since the movie was announced .

What is the logic behind having mostly Muslim characters, that too based in Pak ( which was cleverly changed later) for a KJO Diwali release movie?

The movie has no reference to characters' religion. They do not do anything related to their belief. In fact it was surprising that Anu never gave religious reasons to reject Ayaan. She could have mentioned it as one point of rejection.

A KJO movie is all about Pooja ki thaali, lamps and ~aa aa aa aa~ music in background. There is also a marriage sequence, that KJO turned into Muslim marriage. Lost opportunity for showing KJO marriage sequences.

I did not get logic of any character being Muslim, except Saba .

I also did not get logic behind the characters based in Pak. If it was so easily erasable, what was the point?

Quote

Frequent Posters

643898

Hibernated

Posted: 9 years ago

He initially wanted to cash on Fawad's popularity in Pakistan

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

rimi2983

@rimi2983

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: Jupiters_Cock
He initially wanted to cash on Fawad's popularity in Pakistan

At the cost of India business on Diwali?😕. Pak BO is barely 10 cr.

Quote

ponymo

@ponymo

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 9 years ago

That they are Muslims or Hindus did not really strike me until I came across this question.

I also did not get logic behind the characters based in Pak. If it was so easily erasable, what was the point?

Perhaps there was a greater message in the movie about Indo-Pak relations? That Bollywood brings us together (just like how well Indian and Pakistani members on the forum get along together on this very forum).

As to why they are muslims - such questions have no end, why did they meet in London and not New York, why did Saba live in Vienna, why Ali sports a beard, why Saba doesn't change her surname, etc etc.. this is the story - Karan's vision. And he brought the same to life onscreen.

Quote

Subha

@Life_Is_Dutiful

Stunner

+ 41

Comedy Crew

Posted: 9 years ago

ADHM is a khichdi of all his previous movies.Because of the Muslim names,the movie looked 0.01% different. For that 0.01% difference,he made his characters Pakistani Muslims.

My question is why were they playing holi before marriage. Is it some kind of a custom in Pakistan or he showed it aise hi?

Edited by .Subha. - 9 years ago

Quote

Aweeeecute

@Aweeeecute

Voyager

+ 3

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ponymo

That they are Muslims or Hindus did not really strike me until I came across this question.

Perhaps there was a greater message in the movie about Indo-Pak relations? That Bollywood brings us together (just like how well Indian and Pakistani members on the forum get along together on this very forum).

As to why they are muslims - such questions have no end, why did they meet in London and not New York, why did Saba live in Vienna, why Ali sports a beard, why Saba doesn't change her surname, etc etc.. this is the story - Karan's vision. And he brought the same to life onscreen.

agree with you
i have myself seen indian pakistan marriage but in same religion
i know they were liberal characters
but i am sure ek baar toh this discussion could have happen
i know marriage between pak muslim and indian muslim are common
i have even seen india hindu marrying pakistan hindu
but never seen hindu muslim
but they changed to lucknow so maybe they edited it

Edited by Aweeeecute - 9 years ago

Quote

sam

@mz.gigglez

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Exactly my thoughts, it was totally used out of no where, no reason behind it at all.

Quote

rimi2983

@rimi2983

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: ponymo
That they are Muslims or Hindus did not really strike me until I came across this question.

Perhaps there was a greater message in the movie about Indo-Pak relations? That Bollywood brings us together (just like how well Indian and Pakistani members on the forum get along together on this very forum).

As to why they are muslims - such questions have no end, why did they meet in London and not New York, why did Saba live in Vienna, why Ali sports a beard, why Saba doesn't change her surname, etc etc.. this is the story - Karan's vision. And he brought the same to life onscreen.

I agree with Bold part. It may be a reason.

I am not against them being Muslim, KJO was releasing movie on Diwali, so there must be some logic to sell the movie to majority Hindu audience on biggest Hindu festival. Isn't it?

On top of it he doesn't reference their religion at all !!

Quote

Zeal17

@Zeal17

Stunner

+ 10

Posted: 9 years ago

The only reason could be names are interesting Alizeh,Tahir, Saba..

Quote

1013440

Hibernated

Posted: 9 years ago

#10

KJo ko ye thode na pata tha ki Uri incident ho jayega...aur fir itni badi controversy apne aap ho jayegi ADHM ko leke...😳

wo to apni taraf se doosri hi controversy ki preparation kar ke rakha tha - Hindu Indian boy Vs Pakistani Muslim girl... 😛

KJO ne prepare kia tha kisi aur controversy ke liye aur ho koi aur gayi... isilye last moment pe kuch changes karne pade - like Pakistan changed to Lucknow 😆

Edited by NathuPyare - 9 years ago