What msg did u get from PK? - Page 11

Originally posted by: blue-ice

@ blue😆...lol..I will answer all ur question from MY PERSPECTIVE and remember when it comes to religion...its very personal and the tolerance level of everyone is different...😛

@ Red...I didn't see any of MY GODS insulted anywhere in PK and I am a staunch Hindu...infact I see it differently...i see PK as respecting my Gods by bringing out the flaws in our rituals...for example...None of MY GODS need my protection...I do not need a Godman or a Pujari to be the middleman between me and my God...and this is exactly the message PK is giving...waiting for u to watch the movie and we will continue with this debate..

Originally posted by: Gubbara.

Try asking some basic questions on other faiths.

PK :: It's a *CHSo4.

I felt like director has tons of sloppy and non-sensic work,..that I have ever seen in any movie,... and director remained confused about what he is trying to exact point out/portray/convey and what is his clear message,.. and at many occasion, director seemed like have lost the plot, and confused. Many a times, he triedto get into the plot ( holding the nerve ) and then again seemed to leave it, let loose !

To point out couple points, which I strongly felt,.. while I was watching the movie,..

1.

Ending discussion/debate / message should be veeery strong with any , clear message to the earth-livers ( Like any YRF movies ) and a little holding points from an alien pov, what you earth-vaasis are doing and what you should not,... Was's yr wrong concept about God / Shradhdha, Andh-shradhha and A-shradhdha,.. But here the end is garbage and is not holding any attention and more to it, director rather gets into Anushka's pvt love story matter,... leaving the plot aside ,... ( no mssg for terrorizm, religion, one God/No God, the difference in living style of the society - outer planet versus,... No nthg. " Gayi Bheins paani mein ! " - What non-sense ! Rather, look Kjo/Yash's movie ,. Be it,... Mohabbetien, Baghbaan, K3G, KKHH, DPH,... The end remains very holding ( a very good lecture message ) and final messages portrayed very clear. her, it's dull, dim and non-sense !

2.

A Thousand yrs tech advanced alien land da earth with just the remote and nthg else for any purpose he may have come to the earth, and does not land with any of its food, water. weapons, electronic saadhan-samagriis, practical experiment purpose,.. .. no nothing,.. What a joke ! And, still he has same hands, legs, eyes, blood and all those,... Gets used to our food and society system so fast, as he know steh Govt. system, human mentality,.. etc..

3.

Alien is not shown interacting / astonishing by any other animals such as cow, goat, birds, dogs, duck, crocodiles,...on earth or amazed/ making talk attempt to any ,... and knows automatically that Human is also the only most intelligent spice, here too !! etc.

4.

Alien has only one skill of holding the hands and grabbing the brain data emptied and nothing else,.. And, alien also magically knows,.. what had happened to the real case of church meeting chapter of Sarfarash and Jaggu,... but the same skill, he is not using ( seem to apply ) elsewhere in the movie, that Train is gonna explode,... or so ! Waah !

5.

Alien sends his Yan back, but rest he has no control to talk to his people, Yan,... after having that skills of traveling million miles from outer planets, and just hanging that freaking remote in his neck and nothing else,.. ! Bravo ! Director ,.. yr brain is too smart, like that Alien !

6.

Starting of the movie is garbage and that boring love story and unrelated shown between that Sarfarz and Anushka is pure yawning and waste of time, out of a short movie,... and director also ends the movie on the same non-topic garbage !

7.

Director should study and learn Yash and Kjo's movie to tell the final message very clearly in the end and with loud and lengthy speech and clear message to the Earth-vaasis,... whole here,..about what is going on wrong and it's hard for him to digest,... the moronic director here, even does not know what he is doing !

8.

Alien is shown with no other advanced physical skills of running ( catching / stopping the train ), or flying fast, or saving ppl' s life outta explosion,.. and in one way he is shown from the world, / gola / planet which is 10000s of yrs ahead in technology, and hence he traveled and came here,... and contrary to that, he is just a naaga fakir with no other skills, abilities, gun, or weapons or accessories he brought with him,.. ! Dimwit director !

9.

Alien is settled to the Earth's air, water, food and Gravity so fast,.. and he is also get used to the society system and customs very fast,..

10.

Director is not clearing out precisely, what he wanna say forcefully to Earth-residents, from an Alien's pov,... what he would had observed from a foreign planet eyes,... if he ever landed here, and the whole plot is lost. Movie loses its hold and precise throw of the message and gets into the garbage love-story of Sarfaraaz in the end, leaving the real plot aside about the almight's truth/assumptions,... falsified belief-system on earth,.. and so on,.. .

Not so impressed. It's a

*CHSo4 = Chu**yum Sulphate.

Originally posted by: altuphalu

@Truth10- i think the director has steered clear from giving a clear message because he does not want to prescribe 'his' truth. He wants us to draw our own conclusions.

Therein lies the beauty of the film. The way in which he went about holding a mirror to give us a glimpse of our beliefs about God as a human being. The alien was just a means to convey his msg. It was not a sci-fi movie.

Tell ya,... so far I have heard from many ppl,.. that it's copy of Koi mil gaya + OMG,..

but my opinion is,..

There had one Hollywood movie, 23+ yrs old,.. I think cocoon ( an alien from another planet ) or some name was there, I forgot,.. where a black guy ( alien from other planet comes on earth and he behaves strange, as he is not known to/used to, of Earth's society system its rules,.. etc..

He even takes off his one eyes,.. and at one road side store's outside had a planter,.. he hides his eye in that planter's mitti and then again comes back to grab it,.. etc.

Does anyone know, which movie, I am talking about ?

This is freaking poor copy of that, with religion innuendo added !