Shahid v Ranbir: the better actor? - Page 16

Originally posted by: sammywammy

woah relax dude. Firstly I didn't argue with shahid fans over the results. They got a bit sensitive over my comment/ opinion. Secondly, I'm not a blind fan and don't think ranbir is better at every category as you have indicated . Thirdly, yes ranbir was awful In Besharam, so I've heard, I've not seen the movie so wouldn't know. Only in Bollywood does an actor have to be able to do every single genre to be considered good. Let's leave the masala films to the likes of Salman Khan and Ranveer Singh. Why would ranbir want to do masala when he can give is quality like Barfi, WUS, Rocket Singh. Thirdly, how is Ranveer versatile? The only versatility I've seen from him is his accents and physical appearance. He's roles are always loud and in your face barring Lootera. Theres nothing challenging or versatile in the roles his done. Most of his roles seem to be an extension of his real personality, loud and in your face. Ranveer litrally over acted and hammed in Gunday. Kill dill seems to be a carbon copy of Gunday. So how can you call an actor who has two back to back releases where the storyline appears to be similar, versatile? And finally, I'm a girl and not a dude. 😊

Don't have the time to write in detail but
They got a bit sensitive over my comment/ opinion ---- which Shahid fan wouldn't?😆 first, you open a poll and bash the results once it went the opposite way of what you had imagined! This is wrong on your part because your mindset made you believe the whole world loves Ranbir and he is the greatest actor. So, you couldn't digest the crystal clear result of the votes.

Secondly, I'm not a blind fan and don't think ranbir is better at every category as you have indicated -- doesn't look like so from your comments

Only in Bollywood does an actor have to be able to do every single genre to be considered good. ---------- yes, because we are talking about bollywood and we are proud of its views and style. One should go to hollywood forum if you want others to agree to your hollywood-ishque views.

Let's leave the masala films to the likes of Salman Khan and Ranveer Singh--- here you are trashing masala genre just because your fav's movie didn't do well. This shows how you think your views are superior to everyone else.

Why would ranbir want to do masala when he can give is quality like Barfi, WUS, Rocket Singh.---- the quality for you can be trash for millions of indians and the trash for you can be quality for them. Don't overimpose your hollywoodisque view in INDIAforum

Finally, i realize we disagree by margin over analysis. So, let's not argue in future because you are a RK fan and i am a RS fan. But it would be nice if you don't start trashing other members who comment on your thread when you yourself open the thread. The purpose of opening thread is to gain insight into how others feel about it. It's not to argue with those who don't agree to your view, esp. not in a poll, labelling them as sensitive😆

RK Anyday :)

Rabir by miles. I don't understand the Shahid hype in this forum. I find him pretty average as an actor.

Originally posted by: KhanSinghTomar

Don't have the time to write in detail but
They got a bit sensitive over my comment/ opinion ---- which Shahid fan wouldn't?😆 first, you open a poll and bash the results once it went the opposite way of what you had imagined! This is wrong on your part because your mindset made you believe the whole world loves Ranbir and he is the greatest actor. So, you couldn't digest the crystal clear result of the votes.

Secondly, I'm not a blind fan and don't think ranbir is better at every category as you have indicated -- doesn't look like so from your comments

Only in Bollywood does an actor have to be able to do every single genre to be considered good. ---------- yes, because we are talking about bollywood and we are proud of its views and style. One should go to hollywood forum if you want others to agree to your hollywood-ishque views.

Let's leave the masala films to the likes of Salman Khan and Ranveer Singh--- here you are trashing masala genre just because your fav's movie didn't do well. This shows how you think your views are superior to everyone else.

Why would ranbir want to do masala when he can give is quality like Barfi, WUS, Rocket Singh.---- the quality for you can be trash for millions of indians and the trash for you can be quality for them. Don't overimpose your hollywoodisque view in INDIAforum

Finally, i realize we disagree by margin over analysis. So, let's not argue in future because you are a RK fan and i am a RS fan. But it would be nice if you don't start trashing other members who comment on your thread when you yourself open the thread. The purpose of opening thread is to gain insight into how others feel about it. It's not to argue with those who don't agree to your view, esp. not in a poll, labelling them as sensitive😆

😆 That's How You Reply.

@khansingh I didn't once say how can people vote for shahid or anything like that so I don't see how I bashed shahid or his fans. I simply made an observation, one which many on this forum would agree with. Same thing happened with ranbir himself. I created a poll and gave my opinion what's the big freaking deal?? Your behaving as though this poll is an official experiment and the results have become fact. I can bet you that when BOMBAY VELVET AND PK release and if anushka receives immense praise then she will be winning every poll. It always happens, last year it was Deepika who was winning them all.

P.S I like masala films but your going on like if an actor can't pull of masala they are not good actors.

Originally posted by: sammywammy

@khansingh I didn't once say how can people vote for shahid or anything like that so I don't see how I bashed shahid or his fans. I simply made an observation, one which many on this forum would agree with. Same thing happened with ranbir himself. I created a poll and gave my opinion what's the big freaking deal?? Your behaving as though this poll is an official experiment and the results have become fact. I can bet you that when BOMBAY VELVET AND PK release and if anushka receives immense praise then she will be winning every poll. It always happens, last year it was Deepika who was winning them all.

P.S I like masala films but your going on like if an actor can't pull of masala they are not good actors.

I love both.. but Ranbir has a slight edge over Shahid

acting wise definitely shahid...his worst performance is still watchable and passable...but ranbirs worst performance is cringeworthy, esp when he attempts comedy...

Shahid Kapoor is also a better !!!