Shahid v Ranbir: the better actor? - Page 15

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

But all fandoms overhype their favorite actor right? Honestly i think Ranbir is a great actor but i have no issue with ppl thinking he sucks..Its also true that when a film is critically acclaimed/ does well, that particular actor becomes the flavor of the season..If BV does extremely well, i know the same will happen with Ranbir too..Almost all fandoms gush about their favorite actor's acting skills/ BO power..And no one is expected to agree tbh..Your opinion that he is overhyped is as valid as say my opinion that Ranbir deserves all the praise..So i don get why ppl feel his fans shove him down ppl's throat 😆 No offence..Am not contesting your opinion at all..Since i am a Ranbir fan, i thought i'l add my two cents anyway :)

"I can't imagine anyone else playing Haider other than Shahid".

I CANNOT IMAGINE ANYONE ELSE PLAYING BARFI , JORDAN , ROCKET SINGH or even RANBIR RAJ . There many characters Ranbir has done which no one will ever be to recreate. In that aspect, Ranbir is the better actor and the next big thing after the Khans. He is the best thing that happened to Bollywood in recent times. Watch out for Bombay Velvet, Jagga Jasoos, Tamaasha, etc. He will show everyone why he is known to have the best script sense and immense passion for his art which he portrays outstandingly through his characters.

Originally posted by: TheJake

Not because of his acting. Because he is overhyped.

Originally posted by: TheJake

Question. I'm reading Kaminey and JWM being Shahid's best performances in the past. What about Vivaah? I thought he was damn good in it ... Considering the time and age. #Curious

Ranbir is on the verge of being superstar. Shahid is struggling for a decade to be a star. Kya comparision hai yaar,

It seems even though people are supprting Ranbir verbally but they are still voting for Shahid 😆 . Not that i am complaining but really surprised bcoz he has always been trashed in this forum.
Anyways, its giving me immense satisfaction that he is back on track and has given an apt reply to all those who had declared him over.

Both are very good actors but Ranbir is more natural & effortless onscreen.
Shahid's acting looks rehearsed at times.

Neither! 😆 Shahid looks very rehearsed in his roles and Ranbir is trapped in d image of a boy man trying to find himself! 😆

Originally posted by: sammywammy

I don't agree with you about versatility. Shahid and ranbir are more versatile. However ranveer is relatively new so unfair comparison as other two have been around for longer. i do like all 3 actors. Offscreen ranveer is my fav, onscreen i enjoy shahid and ranbir's movies more.

😆 it doesn't matter, i am firm on my belief...
i know you will agree if i put Ranbir at top in all 3 catagories i mentioned above😆 and this is the reason why he gets overhyped. The fans think he is the best in everything, I DON'T THINK SO and from the votes, i am right. Of course, i know you don't accept the votes of your own poll either 😆

However ranveer is relatively new so unfair comparison as other two have been around for longer.----------------- this doesn't matter dude😆... the range of roles Ranveer has portrayed in 5 years has started to surpass the roles the others have done in their 7 and 10 yrs career. meaning, RS is comfortable and it is his strength. Forget RK doing any masala role for next 5 years😆. It didn't work out for him.
Ranveer has the range and looks to pull off real action to real romance and he is the best guy to choose extremely new role in terms of new character because he has method acting to help him get into the character and pull off the role.
So, it seems you agree Shahid is the best natural actor after all 😆 then why so much fuss with shahid fans before?

Originally posted by: KhanSinghTomar

😆 it doesn't matter, i am firm on my belief...
i know you will agree if i put Ranbir at top in all 3 catagories i mentioned above😆
and this is the reason why he gets overhyped. The fans think he is the
best in everything, I DON'T THINK SO and from the votes, i am right. Of
course, i know you don't accept the votes of your own poll either 😆

However ranveer is relatively new so unfair comparison as other two have been around for longer.----------------- this doesn't matter dude😆... the range of roles Ranveer has portrayed in 5 years has started to surpass the roles the others have done in their 7 and 10 yrs career. meaning, RS is comfortable and it is his strength. Forget RK doing any masala role for next 5 years😆. It didn't work out for him.
Ranveer has the range and looks to pull off real action to real romance and he is the best guy to choose extremely new role in terms of new character because he has method acting to help him get into the character and pull off the role.
So, it seems you agree Shahid is the best natural actor after all 😆 then why so much fuss with shahid fans before?

woah relax dude. Firstly I didn't argue with shahid fans over the results. They got a bit sensitive over my comment/ opinion. Secondly, I'm not a blind fan and don't think ranbir is better at every category as you have indicated . Thirdly, yes ranbir was awful In Besharam, so I've heard, I've not seen the movie so wouldn't know. Only in Bollywood does an actor have to be able to do every single genre to be considered good. Let's leave the masala films to the likes of Salman Khan and Ranveer Singh. Why would ranbir want to do masala when he can give is quality like Barfi, WUS, Rocket Singh. Thirdly, how is Ranveer versatile? The only versatility I've seen from him is his accents and physical appearance. He's roles are always loud and in your face barring Lootera. Theres nothing challenging or versatile in the roles his done. Most of his roles seem to be an extension of his real personality, loud and in your face. Ranveer litrally over acted and hammed in Gunday. Kill dill seems to be a carbon copy of Gunday. So how can you call an actor who has two back to back releases where the storyline appears to be similar, versatile? And finally, I'm a girl and not a dude. 😊