Posted:
Originally posted by: .Tangled.
...
Slated to go on air from early next month on Colors, the show will be judged by choreographer-director Remo D'souza, actress Madhuri Dixit and filmmaker Karan Johar.
Remo, who is known for being critical in judging, said with more trained dancers on the show it becomes difficult for the panelists.
"It's tough. It makes the competition cut throat. We are also left speechless at times and this time we have contestants specialised in many dance forms," he told PTI.
Contestants like Shakti, Mouni are winners of a similar dance based reality show while Sophie has danced in music albums whereas VJ Andy choreographed many performances.
...
What a joke? I am not even laughing
None of the judges give fair scores. Performances worth 5 or 6 get 7 (rarely) or 8 (mostly) and performances worth 7 or 8 get 9 or 10.
Madhuri Dixit just sits there all dolled-up ready to hear any and every compliment. Karan Johar is there but he does sometimes bring in humour and can be critical of contestants performances who deserve it. At least he is much better than Sajid Khan from Nach Baliye. As far as Remo D'souza is concerned all he does is give 8, 9 or 10 for every performance and hardly ever judges performances critically, how he should.
I just wish all these judges do what they are PAID to do: judge a show and give comments which are helpful to contestants but are also honest and true i.e. constructive criticism. Also, they should be upfront with the channel and ask them to let them do their job and judge each performance for what it is, a good or a bad performance.
Also, if a contestant or choreographer says something about judges "judging" and scores they are not penalised for voicing their opinions (Thank God Saroj Khan is no longer a judge on any of the dancing shows).
24