No point in bringing personal intellect: Sonakshi on critics - Page 7

Originally posted by: kabeeraspeaking

Well, don't you have an agenda against critics already too then, to see whatever they do in a certain (monetarily controlled) light? 😆 Everyone has an agenda and everyone has a perspective...neither can be left behind in watching movies and earning a living from writing movie reviews. But not everyone is lying, you know what I mean? Not every critic is writing with the money pouring in from some direction. There are those who do write without those influences and there are critics whose reviews you agree with too. Point is: Sonakshi brushed off critics in entirety with the argument that there is 'no point in bringing personal intellect' to the movies. Her reason for putting them down is because she believes more in $$$. Your reason for putting them down are because they take $$$ to write certain things. My criticism is about her reason (leaving brains behind) and not related to or addressing your reason for disbelief in critics. So what I see is you supporting Sonakshi's statement, not on the basis of her reason, but for your own...Sonakshi ke teer se apna shikar 😆 And I'm not here to argue about the credibility of critics, but about HER statements and the reason behind it.

By the way, you two...vssaras and Jake, don't play...you guys wouldn't even be in this thread if not for R...Rajkumar 😆

Originally posted by: kabeeraspeaking

Well, don't you have an agenda against critics already too then, to see whatever they do in a certain (monetarily controlled) light? 😆 Everyone has an agenda and everyone has a perspective...neither can be left behind in watching movies and earning a living from writing movie reviews. But not everyone is lying, you know what I mean? Not every critic is writing with the money pouring in from some direction. There are those who do write without those influences and there are critics whose reviews you agree with too. Point is: Sonakshi brushed off critics in entirety with the argument that there is 'no point in bringing personal intellect' to the movies. Her reason for putting them down is because she believes more in $$$. Your reason for putting them down are because they take $$$ to write certain things. My criticism is about her reason (leaving brains behind) and not related to or addressing your reason for disbelief in critics. So what I see is you supporting Sonakshi's statement, not on the basis of her reason, but for your own...Sonakshi ke teer se apna shikar 😆 And I'm not here to argue about the credibility of critics, but about HER statements and the reason behind it.

By the way, you two...vssaras and Jake, don't play...you guys wouldn't even be in this thread if not for R...Rajkumar 😆

Originally posted by: TheJake

I don't know about other Shahid fans ... but I never defended RR for its genre. I'm just happy as a fan that RR did good from audience's perspective. That they enjoyed him, loved him. He's not being written off. Actually I'm busy praying that Sasha doesn't turn into an other Masala hero, just cause this movie of his did good. There are some who did enjoy RR and some who didn't. My reasons for enjoying RR was action sequences and chemistry. Otherwise I hate PD's direction ... I never understood why people like it in the first place. Then again it's how audience's taste these days.

I don't have to defend Sasha ... his work, flop or hit, speaks for itself.

For me, it's all about Haider. 😆

Originally posted by: TheJake

But isn't that amazing ... And she is 5 years behind. 😆

Originally posted by: vssaras

What are you trying to say here..It is my wish to support whatever I want to..don't really need to justify it..If I happen to agree with Sona..I would say so or choose to keep quiet..If I don't..same thing..

Out of normal thing to say on the subject?..need you go personal?..😆

You neither can tell me when to speak up nor tell me shut up...😛

Originally posted by: chocolover89

Sure if you want to look at that side of things. 😆

Originally posted by: kabeeraspeaking

I didn't tell you to anywhere 😆 I argued about your argument. If you have something to say about what I said about your argument, then please do. But since you don't really need to justify anything you support, cools beans! Support away.

Originally posted by: vssaras

Well you questioned my reasons for supporting a statement..you were not arguing about what I said..you were making derivations as to why I said it..😛😆

Originally posted by: kabeeraspeaking

Arguing about what you said includes arguing about your reasons for it because reasons are a subset of support...i.e. they do not lie outside of the support but comprehensively within it by nature 😆 We established that your reason for supporting Sonakshi was not in tandem with Sonakshi's own reason for giving that statement, and neither that you cared it wasn't so as long as you support the agenda that you have, which summarizes this failure of an exchange between us.

Good day to you!