Posted:
She got mixed reviews. No one said she was bad in her role. But that her role was under-developed or she didnt have much to do.
Which for Kareena is kinda like criticism coz Kareena normally gets exceptional reviews.
Of course, the reviews that didnt like Satyagraha, obviously liked very little about it. Those are the ones that criticized her role. But again, her role. Not her. Or that her makeup was too glamorous. Basically things that cant be credited to her.
Kareena Kapoor doesnt get bad reviews coz she acts well 99% of the time.
Kareena Kapoor is very good in the role of news reporter.
Kareena Kapoor is sincere in her attempt to play a TV reporter, but she looks a little too polished for the job. It would have been okay if she were in an air-conditioned studio or part of the PM's entourage, but in the backwaters of Ambikapur she stands out with her camera crew who seem to be on an extended holiday from their job.
While Kareena dazzles as usual, it is her character sketch, which is the most faulty. In fact, many filmmakers evidently seem to have no idea how the media offices work and Kareena's Yasmeen is miles away from that of a real-life journalist. Even when the whole of Ambikapur and at one point, the country gets involved in the Ambikapur revolution, Yasmeen seems to be the only journalist covering it and doing a bad job of it too.
Kapoor, Rampal and Rao come and go, as cricket commentators like to say, without troubling the scorers.
Kareena Kapoor Khan looks gorgeously pretty in a simple attire. She carries off the role of a passionate television reporter with elegance and sensibility
Kareena Kapoor works well as Yasmeen Ahmed, the journalist. She is somehow the voice of the film. Kareena is good and confident. This is her first time with Jha but she gives everyone an equally tough fight. She looks good, she speaks well and establishes a connect with the audience.
Kareena Kapoor is superb, though her character needed more screen-time.
Kareena Kapoor was shown as a talented journalist and she did justice to her role
Kareena Kapoor plays the role of Journalist. She looks very good and lighten ups the screen. Kareena was apt for the role.
Kareena Kapoor playing TV journalist Yasmin Ahmed shows her prowess in this genre too. She is stunningly pretty and plays a true Gandhian. Her romantic sequences with Ajay Devgn gel well to provide entertainment and real camaraderie in the greater cause.
Kareena Kapoor Khan apart from looking super gorgeous does her part very well
His lady love, Kareena Kapoor, who plays TV journalist Yasmin Ahmed, comes off as a natural even though she does not have much to work with.
Kareena is matchless in her role of a strong, fearless journalist.
Kareena Kapoor is extremely believable in her character
But the anchors of the show here are Ajay Devgn and Kareena Kapoor. Ajay shows you why he's considered a great actor. Here you have a club 100-crore member quietly doing justice to his character in a middle-of-the-road movie. We need more lead heroes like this.Kareena too brings intensity and charm to her role. She's a feisty journalist and Kareena has the right livewire energy.
The bad reviews are like these:
Kareena credited here as Kareena Kapoor Khan "" no wonder the liplock is from behind her head "" is saddled with the most confused character of the film. She is a TV news reporter but gets so involved with the movement that her picture is splashed on all the Jan Satyagraha billboards and posters. She cries too but is far down the bucket list headed by Amrita Rao who is the real Sobby LLB of the film.
Take Yasmin. Why does she park herself in Ambikapur? To support the andolan, or to sing love duets with her new-found boyfriend? We don't know. Also, I don't recall anything about her except that she was bizarrely fresh-faced, needlessly smug, and always remembered the number of missed calls she had left on another's cellphone.
What sticks out as the most unconvincing, though, is the treatment of Kareena's character, Yasmin. Other than being absolutely pretty all the time " fully made out, every hair in place " Yasmin is fairly unbelievable as a journalist. There is no way that she, supposedly an unbiased journalist, would be allowed to be the face of a political movement while still working for her news channel. Her job is established in the beginning, but somewhere down the line she suspends all other work just to be a part of this group " and a fairly big part, too, since her face is plastered all over their posters. To keep the journalist label intact, though, the script requires her to report from the frontline of the scene very often... except that it's difficult to understand how any media house would allow anyone to become so openly involved in a political movement while still reporting from the scene.
Chat Clubs
Members Lounge
12