What was so SPECIAL about BARFI!?!!!!!!! - Page 7

Originally posted by: -SalShah4eva-

So the ending was copy too. what abt the shoe scene was that copy too. Or even the wedding one.

Originally posted by: vedant123

Ending wasn't copy... That lying in bed together - don't couples lie together!

Nd neither wedding one was or shoe one :)

Originally posted by: -SalShah4eva-

Naa i am not saying it was copy😆

read it again..maybe u will understand😆

Originally posted by: Maroonporsche

The theme music was from Amelie


One scene of RK on the latter teetering back and forth

The conversation between illeana and her mom on love and norms of society

The needle on the street scene was from some oriental movie

The sliding door was from Chaplin I think



Again I loved Barfi and it even made me cry . Very good film


But right is right and wrong is wrong

a lot of scenes were also copied from the notebook

Originally posted by: vedant123

Ending wasn't copy... That lying in bed together - don't couples lie together!

Nd neither wedding one was or shoe one :)

the end scene was copied from the notebook

Originally posted by: Nkapoor3

a lot of scenes were also copied from the notebook

Really this just gets worse and worse


Still love the film tho


But they should ackonewledge or credit the films


If so called idiots like people who remake south films can do it the right way


Intellectuals like Anurag & Ranbir should've done it the correct way also

Only one scene was a direct copy from The Notebook, almost shot for shot. The other was inspired but actually works better in Barfi! because everything was communicated with expressions, no dialogue.

Originally posted by: Kal El

Only one scene was a direct copy from The Notebook, almost shot for shot. The other was inspired but actually works better in Barfi! because everything was communicated with expressions, no dialogue.

Also true and that is my other argument

That Barfi stole scenes but took it to another Level altogether and rocked it made it cool


I'm torn lol

Regardless BARFI has copied a lot

The performances .
Jhilmil touched my heart ! She nailed it !
Ranbir was great . Iliena did a decent job as well.

It was one of the best films of last year !

And yeah it is copied from some hollywood films I know that. Then again which film is not? Atleast it was way better than the south remakes 😛