Raja Sen's Report card for 2012 heroines - Page 18

Half the ladies listed should have gotten a D. 🤪

Originally posted by: blue-ice

Answer this one...anyone someone???

The fact is that Raja Sen is one confused soul...

Originally posted by: vedant123

On what basis the list is made??

Priyanka B! Seriously?

She gave 2 hunddred crore filsm

Criticially acclaimed performance as Jhilmil

and enlighten knowledge regarding autisticism and changed opinons of many regarding specially challenged people

She had her first feet in music industry

nd also won few acclodes for her performance in 7 Khoon Maaf!

And still she is given B - Like seriously?

And if BO + image + public perception - Why is Parneeti given an A?

Originally posted by: divine.dobrev

Haila, he gave Deepika an A 😲 Lol but ofcourse he included the "I don't agree" bit 😆

DP got a B, from hat I see in the list

If this list is based on BO numbers, how come Parineeti gets an A+?? This list is purely based on favourtism!!

Originally posted by: Micky_elle

DP got a B, from hat I see in the list

I really believe that critics shouldn't be bias...Raja is not a good critic because he's bias towards he's favorites like kat😆 he'll give her A and of course give others lower grades than her

He did gave Deepika an A which is surprising😆 Since he hates both dp and PC...both pc and dp are competitors to his favorite actresses

Originally posted by: divine.dobrev

The grades are written below the name and paragraph na...it says A under Deepika 😕 Or am I going crazy?😆

Ah yes..ur right 😊 For some reason I thot the grading was displayed above the actress name 😆

Originally posted by: -Maddy-

He clearly mentions BO, so that means it is a main criteria... That means she needs to have some kind of credible BO success to satisfy the box office criteria...

If it was 2011 i understand... She did have two big films last year... But this year overall her movies have been very very average at the BO... The only saving grace was Talaash and that was a semi-hit...Then how does she qualify for an A+? Just on the basis of her wedding? 😆

Then why did he have to mention box office if that wasn't going to be taken into consideration...

As a well known critic he needs to keep his bias aside when he comes up with lists like these. The other day I read his other list regarding best actress... He had skipped two standout performances of the year, PC and DP... There I understand its abt acting and its very subjective... I loved both PC's and DP's performance, maybe he did not like that... I am fine with that list since opinions does vary...

But here we are talking abt box office and the BO numbers are factual and its not an opinion... Atleast be fair here...

Exactlyyy! Out of all the top actresses, Kareena had the worst year BO wise. Her films are all averages or washouts. Talaash got her critical acclaim, but if it's about BO, then that's pointless. Unless he somehow counted Dabangg 2 as her film 😆

Raja Sen always has a hard time keeping his biases out, even in reviews. If you read them, it's easy to tell who he likes and who he doesn't. For example, he generally is quite nice to Katrina, Kareena, and Ranbir right now. SRK, depends on SRK...He dislikes Aamir quite a bit..if I'm not wrong, he hasn't given any Aamir film even a 3 star rating in the last few years...when Aamir is widely considered the messiah of quality cinema.

I understand opinions can vary, but really making your biases so obvious as a film critic is unprofessional IMHO.

Originally posted by: Micky_elle

If this list is based on BO numbers, how come Parineeti gets an A+?? This list is purely based on favourtism!!

Well technically, Parineeti delivered a hit this year inher only film release-- Ishaqzaade, so if the list really is based on BO, then she deserves her A...but I think she got a B. 😕 I agree, the list is purely favoritism. 😆