Why is Kareena left out in the cold? - Page 15

Originally posted by: smartie_pants

lol...in kareenas defense for her JWM performance...i would like to point out the fact that which other contemporary working actress won soo much of of acclaim for a playing a maniac pixie dream girl???

PC did it in anjaaa anjaani

Rani did it in dil bole hadippa

Priety did it in several movies of hers

Aishwarya did it in Robot and Action replay(sort of)

Konkona sort of played it in Laaga chunri mein daag

Genelia did it in Jaane tu ya jaane na

Kangana did it in Tanu weds manu

But did any of them from the above list match the amount of critical acclaim, awards and fan following kareena got from playing that one character "geet"?

I truly believe geet is an iconic character because there have always been such madcap crazy roles...but did anyone ever excel in that role and establish the same kinda connect kareena did with geet?

Juhi did numerous bubbly roles and so did preity...but are any of them particularly as memorable? Is there that one character which remains in ur mind years after u saw the film?

Its very easy to play "different" roles...u have a set graph and a set of nuances for that particular role which u cannot go beyond...but whats more difficult is playing a cliched, done to death character with spunk and spontaneity...which is what i think kareena did perfectly in JWM...and which is exactly why i rank this performance of hers above all others like Omkara, dev, chameli and refugee...

Acting is not always about playing "difficult" or "different" roles...its also about playing an ordinary role differently...

Originally posted by: sheee

@dexter

lol You are not making any sense.

Originally posted by: liverach

fair enough..

the thing with the National Awards though, is that its not really regional based when it comes to Best Actor, Best Actress, Best film category

is liye I brought up Genelia

Originally posted by: Dexterphile

@Shee

lol You are making so much sense.

😲

Originally posted by: masakaliii

^ hey mysticgoryfilms i'm pretty sure a subtitled version in pretty good quality is available on youtube.

Originally posted by: Neetu_GirlPower

sorry but u live in dreams...JUHI's performance in hum hai rahi pyaar ke has been epic ...and she got numerous awards for it too...just becoz u like kareena so much and her 'critical acclaim' has been the superior in bollywood for 'geet'...a story like this is pretty much interesting but will not become true...other actresses have been good so far...u can count them in good actresses for sure...but if u say she is the best...it can be anything but believable...😆😆