Originally posted by: sogazelle
That's why I don't understand why the author is saying that Kareena wins because of her charisma. If someone has to win for charisma, it's certainly Katrina. Just as you said, she draws the masses to the theater regardless of her talent. If that's not charisma, then I don't know what it is.
Kareena has the family name that gives her an edge but PC and Katrina's success should be weigh more because of the struggle they've put in to get where they are. It was a due for Kareena.
I'm not saying that she does not deserve to be where she is today, but for PC and Kat with their non filmi background certainly deserve my respect more regardless of their talent.
I'm a fan of Kat by far. The girl is a FIGHTER. She's been put down repeatedly because of her accent and talent, but she just keeps proving people wrong and keeps climbing that ladder.
And people who said her hits are because of the A list actors... pu leeze... She's the only one who has not yet work with the 3 khans. All actors are fighting to have her in their films because SHE draws the masses. They are willing to take her despite her lack of acting, whereas Kareena even with her family name RELIES on A list actors for box office success.
Kareena's latest blockbusters are not due to her, she just happened to be there. Think 3idiots, Golmal etc...This writer obviously has a penchant for Kareena, but I'll stick with my Kat anytime. she has more charisma than Kareena anyday because she has that mysterious yet approachable air about her and her number of hits is a testament to that. Kareena might have talent, but I always feel that she knows it and that comes across through the screen which is a big turn off for me. If a director can get pass her family name and tampered her "look at me, I'm a good actress" on screen, I might enjoy her more.
7