kurbaan promised to be watever MNIK was

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

desigal90

@desigal90

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#11

Zareena, there was no need to open this topic. NO one said Kurbaan promised to be anything MNIK was. THe only thing they had in common was the producer. Kurbaan is rensil's vision, MNIK is Karan's.

Not ONCE did the makers claim anything of the like.

Normally I woudlnt jump to this conclusion Zareena, but this member has been trashing Kurbaan in every single topic since its release.

Infact, when anyone praised the movie, it would break out into a debate about WHY are you praising Kurbaan.

THey have nothing in comon wtih each other, so I dont even see the POINT of this topic?

Mind you, I'm looking forward to catching MNIK as well, but this in my eyes was uncalled for. Just coz one movie didnt work doesnt mean you open a topic and say, yeah, this si what it shoudl ahve been.

Not realy. They're totally different.

Its liek me opening a topic tomorrow about a random movie and then saying, Yeah this OTHER movie shoudl have been liek this, but wasnt.

Makes no sense, right?

Quote

4492

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: zainab25

Ya, I am presented with no choice, so I have to. 😆 My mother and cousins want to see it sometime, but then I have exams constantly for the next 2 weeks, so it will probably be happening sometime after 10 days.

good luck for the exams😃 dun stress and then to celebrate go out wid frinds and defo watch MNIK

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

desigal90

@desigal90

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: nkapoor

geez relax y r u tking it personal?? both movies can be compared so i opened up this topic, kurbaan was a bad movie which promised to be what MNIK was thats the topic u either discuss it or leave it, stop showing people that u r a victim

There we go.

As I said, topic's purpose, trash one movie, put up another.

Whether a movie is GOOD or BAD are OPINIONS. I know plenty of ppl that liked Kurbaan, me included, so kindly dont generalize for everyone.

Edited by desigal90 - 15 years ago

Quote

4492

Suspended

Posted: 15 years ago

#14

yes it makes sense

kurbaan-is primarily a love story, its about the muslim perception etc. etc.

Quote

Nadaanmasakalli

@naadanmasakalli

Master

+ 11

Posted: 15 years ago

#15

i dunno why but after watch KHAN i m seriously thinking why did i even liked KURBAAN. not putting it down when it released i liked it & bebo did a FANTASTIC job but hell why did even karan bothered to make that film when he was making such a Fabolous movie that's beyond my understanding anyways for me khan was khan is and khan will remain a very very very special movie not because it has my most fav people in it but because karan did a fantastic job even my dad who hardly ever likes a film loved MNIK and wants to watch it again because it was very very good.

Quote

llll

@-Aleeza-

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#16

What was the point of bringing in Kurbaan? MNIK isnt much about terrorism and it didnt show anything negative if you know what I mean.

Quote

llll

@-Aleeza-

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#17

Originally posted by: fizzilicious
i dunno why but after watch KHAN i m seriously thinking why did i even liked KURBAAN. not putting it down when it released i liked it & bebo did a FANTASTIC job but hell why did even karan bothered to make that film when he was making such a Fabolous movie that's beyond my understanding anyways for me khan was khan is and khan will remain a very very very special movie not because it has my most fav people in it but because karan did a fantastic job even my dad who hardly ever likes a film loved MNIK and wants to watch it again because it was very very good.

MNIK is Kjos direction. Kurbaan was Rensils. Major difference there.