Bigg Boss 19: Daily Discussion Thread - 17th Oct 2025
GREENE FLAG ⛳
What will Yuvraj do?
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai October 17, 2025 EDT
This is concerning.
i support farhana
KUJILI STARTED 18.10
Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai October 18, 2025 EDT
Kyunki Detailed Written episode Oct 16. Pics attached (Hindi captions)
Mental health club - Only Positivity allowed 🌟
Debate between Kareena-Ranbir fans about who's better?
Anupamaa 17 Oct 2025 Written Update & Daily Discussions Thread
Story- Tortoise to Rabbit😜
Alia channeling Gangubai in this scene from RRKPK!!!
Acha wala gunda
Alia and Ranbir to move to their new house - Krishna Raj
Deja vu ? Do you get Deja vu ?
Mera Armaan toh Green Flag Hai😌✅
Wanna see post leap trp ?????? Geetu vs Abhimaan romance who won??
Buddhiya Ka Naya Roop
| Review : What's Your Rashee? (Romance) Anupama Chopra, Consulting Editor, NDTV Friday, September 25, 2009 | ||||||
| ||||||
Twenty years ago, director Ketan Mehta turned Gujarati author Madhu Rye's novel Kimball Ravenswood into an engaging television serial. The story, about an eligible bachelor who, to save his family from calamity, must find a bride in 10 days and so decides to meet one girl from each horoscope, is episodic and therefore perfectly suited to TV. The same tale however, makes for absolutely excruciating cinema. Yogesh, played by Harman Baweja, is an MBA and part-time DJ living in Chicago. He is summoned home by his panicky parents and brother. The brother has borrowed over Rs four crore from various sources including some unsavory bhais and must pay it back or else, the bhais will starts severing his fingers. Yogesh's maternal grandfather is going to bequeath him some serious wealth on his marriage. So the family and eventually a reluctant Yogesh decide that he must marry, inherit the wealth and pay off the debts. Yogesh thinks he will find some semblance of love if he meets one girl from each of the 12 Rashis, because he tells us, there are only 12 kinds of girls in the world. Each girl of course, is played by Priyanka Chopra. Making riveting cinema out of 12 similar encounters is a Herculean task for any director. But perhaps even more so for Ashutosh Gowarikar whose strengths as a storyteller seem more suited to 70 mm epics than romantic comedy. For one, there is his talent for telling unhurried stories, which have a certain stillness and gravitas and frequently run into several hours. This epic length simply doesn't work for romance. At nearly four hours, What's Your Rashee, is a marathon watch. And the rewards for enduring it are slim. The series of dates with potential brides begins marvelously with Priyanka playing a small-town girl who pretends to smoke and drink because she thinks that the NRI boy will prefer it. But very quickly, the girls become clones, each one wearing a sexy, backless choli and one quirk. Priyanka is one of Bollywood's most compelling heroines but Rashee gives her 12 roles with very little meat. Her comparatively short turn in Kaminey left a greater impact than all of these girls put together. Also, there is little plot movement in What's Your Rashee. Only characters and interactions carry this story. When that becomes shaky, the pace, burdened with too many songs and some feeble comedy, goes into slow motion. And you are so exhausted that you can barely keep track of the girls or their sagas or why Yogesh does or doesn't like them. Moreover, this entire exercise swirls around Harman who seems sincere enough but simply doesn't have the screen presence or the acting chops to pull it off. Ashutosh Gowarikar is a fine filmmaker who has consistently strived to stretch the boundaries of mainstream Hindi cinema – recall the Oscar nominated Lagaan or the less successful but thought-provoking Swades. What's Your Rashee is a gargantuan misstep. See it if you must. http://movies.ndtv.com/movie_Review.aspx?id=437 |
| What's Your Raashee? Movie Review |
| September 25, 2009 11:53:34 AM IST By Martin D'Souza, Bollywood Trade News Network |
|
| |
| view WHATS YOUR RAASHEE videos |
|
| |
Originally posted by: friends_rock
Nandini wants to be a model. She hails from a conservative family and manages to convince her orthodox parents in only one short conversation. The nymphomaniac astrologer's track ends abruptly. Dancer Mallika rejects Harman because he refuses to lick an ice-candy because he is unsure about how clean the water is. Her reason is fickle and her reaction is exaggerated. It is also unexplained why Harman and his uncle are staying at a hotel in Mumbai. Harman's grandfather adores him and calls him un-selfish but there are hardly any instances to prove it. Many questions are left unanswered.
You: How is What's Your Raashee?
Me: Wrong question.
You: How long?
Me: Now you're talking.
Mr Yogi, Mr Yogi, remember that catchy refrain we would wait to hear on our Doordarshan-friendly television sets every single week? Now imagine those 13-episodes of Ketan Mehta's [ Images ] popular sitcom clubbed together for one single viewing. Well, that's how long What's Your Raashee? feels like.
It's the only goddamn obstacle in what could have been a socio-comic gem. What's Your Raashee? could have been at least one and a half hours shorter. Those thirteen songs could have been reduced to five. That ridiculous sub-plot about a marriage agent's illicit affair could have been done away with. There are just so many sequences that could have done with a snip here and a cut there.
As much as I appreciate his trademark idealism and eye for detail, filmmaker Ashutosh Gowariker's weakness for lengthy cinema has always sparked debate. Personally, I had no issues with the running time of either Lagaan [ Images ] or Swades [ Images ] but Jodhaa Akbar [ Images ] did contribute in aggravating my spondylitis. What's Your Raashee? was never going to be a short film, considering its premise, inspired by Madhu Rye's Gujarati novel, Kimball Ravenswood, about an NRI guy coming to Mumbai [ Images ] to pick a perfect bride from 12 different astrological signs in ten days. What's the hurry, you ask?
Basically, the eligible bachelor in question, namely Chicago boy Yogesh Patel (Harman Baweja), is tricked into flying back home by his astrology-blind folks (an utterly believable Anjan Shrivastava and Manju Singh) to bail them out from monetary woes after their elder son (Dilip Joshi stumps you with yet another poker-faced winner) loses a fortune in gambling and owes an underworld don, among many others. The only thing that can save them now is his grandfather's inheritance, which Yogesh will procure only after he ties the knot.
Meanwhile, there's no overlooking a serious effort to shoot Mumbai as uniquely as possible. While there's no escaping a drive around Marine Drive [ Images ] and Fort, it's good to catch up with good ol' Kamla Nehru Park, the claustrophobic spaces of Bhuleshwar, lush greens of Powai while receiving a good glimpse of the upcoming neighbourhoods around Navi Mumbai lending the somewhat far-fetched set-up a much-welcome stroke of realism
The anticipation of watching Priyanka Chopra unleash her 12 conflicting avatars -- all Gujarati, however, keeps the optimism going. Establishing lot in less is still one of Gowariker's greatest limitations and hence the aforementioned scenario takes a little more than it should to unfold.
Also, if you have ever been (still are) into Linda Goodman's Sun Signs or Love Signs, spotting popular zodiac traits is one guilty pleasure you can never have enough of. Too bad most of the signs as projected in the movie are nothing like I expected them to be.
Anjali
What's her raashee? Aries. A small-town girl, Anjali is nothing like the famously fiery and capricious Arians you've heard of. She's diffident and tacky but good-naturedly so. She laughs with a snort, speaks with an accent (Mun-dates, Toos-dates) aims to please and tries a tad too hard.
What's my verdict? It's a sweet and awkward 'kind-of' first-date like episode. The pace is just right except for the last few seconds of forced sentimentality. Plus, the man who plays Anjali's father cracks you up with his 'Myself Kachda bhai' exuberance.
Sanjana [ Images ]
What's her raashee? Aquarius. Kampala-bred Sanjana is easy on the eyes and attitude. Hard luck Yogesh bhai, she's already taken.
What's my verdict? Of all the 12 meetings, this one rates the most uneventful. Girl and boy meet at a wedding, take off on a long drive, play the guitar, hum a song, nothing happens.
Kajal
What's her raashee? Gemini. She's all about chewing gum and playing romance-romance. She's still in college. Ah!
What's my verdict? Surely there's more to Kajal than a piece of gum. Unfortunately, you never find out.
Hansa
What's her raashee? Cancer. With her long, open tresses, dull pink sari and an expression so grave, she's almost spooky Why so serious? You got to hear it from Hansa's mouth.
What's my verdict? While you may find Hansa's melancholy a bit too intense to understand, Gowariker spoils any chances of knowing her better by swapping conversation with another song.
Rajni
What's her raashee? Libra. Forget all that talk about the legendary Libran charm, this one, here, borderlines on a hard-nosed vamp. And it's not just because she demands a prenuptial agreement. Right, Thakkar?
What's my verdict? Priyanka Chopra [ Images ] pays a tribute to The Devil Wears Prada in her own sleek style. But just when you are about to conclude, engaging and funny, another song follows.
Chandrika
What's her raashee? Pisces. Chandrika appears to have watched too many reincarnation dramas. Now she believes she's a part of one.
What's my verdict? Unless you have Chandrika's memory, all you'll come out remembering is her dad reiterate 'Humari koi shaakha nahi hai" and one really long, dreary song.
Mallika
What's her raashee? Leo. A terribly moody dancer. Want to rub her the wrong way? Say no to ice golas.
What's my verdict? Post-interval, What's Your Raashee? has begun trying your patience. And that this section begins with a dance number, however intricate, does not help. Plus, Mallika's meeting with Yogesh ends rather abruptly. Did she really have to get this worked up? There's no time to muse, another raashee awaits.
Nandini
What's her raashee? Scorpio. Sexy siren in the garb of plain Jane, Nandini sees Yogesh as her green card ticket to model on the runways of America.
What's my verdict? Quite amusing, despite a song. That's saying a lot.
Bhavna
What's her raashee? Sagittarius. This hot, bespectacled astrologer has stunning predictions in store for a dumbstruck Yogesh.
What's my verdict? The foolhardiness is too laboured and the presence of a seduction number most unprovoked but Priyanka's convictions and Harman's naivete makes it work.
Pooja
What's her raashee? Virgo. Easygoing and warm, Pooja is a doctor wanting to make a difference to the underprivileged lot.
What's my verdict? Mini Swades, anyone? There's an endearing air about Pooja and Yogesh's chemistry and you can't help but root for her.
Vishaka
What's her raashee? Taurus. Rich heiress plays crazy to dissuade money-minded suitors.
What's my verdict? It's unfortunate that the best track, Su chhe of What's Your Raashee? has to make its entry so late into the movie. Also, you never understand why Gowariker shrouds her character in mystery.
Jhankhana
What's her raashee? Capricorn. A Ballika Vadhu inspired kiddo who understandably bawls at the mention of marriage.
What's my verdict? In a genre like What's Your Raashee, the last thing you expect is to raise social issues. The well-meaning ploy only confuses the viewer as to how to perceive this constantly mood-shifting caper.
Then again, idealism has always been a coherent streak in almost all Gowariker features. Here too it voices itself through Yogesh and his experiences. Be it his non-dowry stance or disgust for child-marriage.
While it's all good, the script often contradicts itself. At one point it treats infidelity and running into mafia with cheek, at others it acquires a critical tone. Loopy screenplay (by Gowariker and Naushil Mehta) aside, the humour is often subtle and refreshing; Gowariker shows a flair for light scenes and creating atmospheric nuances. And while Sohail Sen's soundtrack, on its own, is lilting, A R Rahman's [ Images ] presence is sorely missed. He complements Gowariker's emotionality to perfection.
Even then, What's Your Raashee? is ultimately a performance-oriented film. A terrific ensemble cast from the world of television and theatre collaborate to its feel-good believability which lasts as long as their screen time. As for the man behind Yogesh, Harman Baweja [ Images ] is sincere in his endeavours but not so fascinating a presence to resist getting overshadowed by his leading lady.
And boy, what a lady! Priyanka Chopra transforms into 12 new skins with astonishing distinction, voice and spirit. The actress reinvents herself into this unique individual every single time ranging from batty, bashful and boisterous. This is simply her show. If only it weren't three and a half hours long.
P.S: Guess who inspired the length of this review? :-)
Rediff Rating:
https://x.com/filmibeat/status/1968397140549345682
https://x.com/varindersingh24/status/1955662282345808161 https://x.com/aavishhkar/status/1967618349535518917
Too much Kajol Twinkle- episode discussion / review...
Movie has released worldwide 12th September and will release in India too...
https://x.com/vivekagnihotri/status/1946940660067803443...
Udne Ki Aasha
Kumkum Bhagya
270