Originally posted by: mpc.sofar
This follows logically? There is another quite obvious possibility - material for roti is in excess at the moment and material for daal and sabzi is relatively limited. One person's eating only daal and sabzi means others will need to eat proportionately more roti material and rice because of limited total food material availability.
so why didn't Tiwari get any?, he was snubbed.
Originally posted by: mpc.sofar
Another possibility is that not material, but labour for making vegetables is in limited supply compared to labour for making rotis. This includes washing, cutting, sometimes pealing vegetables. There might be numerous other possibilities but these are quite obvious.
again, Tiwari was not given any rotis, Rahul was told to come back in 30mins after Tiwari had finished, it looked like they were giving him a treat.
Originally posted by: mpc.sofar
Rahul didn't ask for roti - but why are you assuming that he wants to eat roti? It follows logically? If you do not ask someone to punch you and still someone punches you, you would think that he/she wants to woo you? You didn't ask to be punched because you do not want to be punched. Rahul didn't ask for roti because he doesn't want roti (one obvious possibility that you ignored).
being given roti and being punched isn't analogous, they hold different connotations, the first is a kind gesture that is appreciated, the latter is an act of harm, and is not appreciated.
yeh it's a possibility... it's also possible that there aren't enough rotis to go around, and given the appetite of some of these contestants such as Tiwari and Kazmi, whom Rahul was especially close to, he may have been happy to give his share to others... just a possibility.
Originally posted by: mpc.sofar
I have a female colleague who has worked on the project I am now working on. I asked her for advice and she actually gave me advice. By your logic, it logically follows that she is trying to woo me, right?
Logic fail.
I neither said, nor implied such a thing.
I reiterate, my initial post was a light-hearted comment, with the intent to wind-up Shweta fans, it wasn't supposed to be taken seriously, but you didn't seem to have caught on.