Honestly I feel game n relations are different, I heard him say Vip membership is top 5 thing. N he was actually honest Afsana is his sister but not someone he needs for his survival in the house for his mental sanity, she is a difficult person to handle and more of a liability who causes problems. He supported her when she played women card for real cause n ppl used it against him as a game. Even in this task Afsana breaks maximum rule n an easy loophole for biggboss to get them out. They dint take but it's not like they eliminated her or nominated her. Also Umar would have been questioned big time if he took Afsana n there would be questions if she was deserving but yes truth is even now he will be asked.
Well, I am never against Karan. I think he's got brilliant potential - some tapped, a lot still untapped. He is honest to the face when he needs to be, he strategizes when he needs to. His 'strategizing' of whom he wants to speak to, how much he wants to speak and how he wants to speak is often called out as 'mindgames' - when in reality it is not. I believe he reserves his energy and chooses his battles wisely, unlike a headless chicken like Pratik, who will jump into every mud puddle there is like a Swine. Swines do that.. I also don't believe that Afsana was worth going into Top 5 VIP membership club. Nah, she's not a gamer and nobody frankly would see her going into the Top 5 of this show anyway. She's got a fun factor to her, a drama factor, but she's not a gamer.
Nishant - was never deserving to get into Top 5. He's just a sidekick. It could've been Vishal.