REASONS WHY PHOOL IS NOT PRATAP'S FAVOURITE

Originally posted by: dashingpraja

THE SHOW HAS BEEN SHOWING PHOOL QUITE CLOSE TO PRATAP. BUT THE TRUTH IS THAT PRATAP'S FIRST LOVE WAS AND IS AJAB. WHETHER HE MARRIES ONE TIME OR TEN TIME.

THERE HAS BEEN CERTAIN MISUNDERSATANDING IN THE MINDS OF OUR READERS. LET ME CLEAR THAT TOO.

FACT-1

PHOOL AND AJABDE ARE NOT CHILDHOOD FRIENDS.

REASON- Ajabde was married when she was of 15 years and amar singh was born when she was 17 years. if sources and the show are to be believe pratap married phool when amar singh was 11 years(8 years chittor + 3 years in Udaipur). by that time ajab would have been 28 years. if phool and ajab were childhood friends, they would be of same age . a Rajput king will wait for his daughter to get married at an age of 28.They always arranged the marriages of their daughters when they would be in their teens. that means that phool was much younger than ajab and was not her childhood friend

we are well aware of this fact and thankful that she is not ajabde's friend. the ridiculous change in phool is currently making her look like she is a caricature... not our beloved phool kanwar... and we do not want phool to get something that ajabde sacrificed. she needs not rely on the bits and pieces that ajabde lets have.

FACT 2

PHOOL WAS PRATAP'S 5TH OR 6TH WIFE

REASON-the has been showing phool as pratap's second wife. but in reality she was his 5th or 6th wife. pratap married for politican alliance.

we are aware that phool was pratap's 5th wife.. but it doesn't matter right now.. because right now the show matters... not history. In the show they are showing her as his second wife... and that is what matters.

FACT 3

PHOOL WAS NOT ABDUCTED FROM HER WEDDING VENUE.

REASON- if at all that has occurred, either the akbarnama or any Rajput history book would have recorded it.the show has shown this false story to increase their TRP.

same reason as above. the cvs are showing her being abducted by pratap. he cared for her enough to abduct.. as per the show.. not as per history.

FACT 4

PHOOL WAS MOTHER TO PRATAP'S SECOND SON NOT SECOND CHILD.

REASON- In Rajput families girls were never given imporatance. there are chances of pratap's 2nd 3rd and 4th wives giving birth to girls but they were never given importance. But when phool conceived , she gave birth to a boy and thus he became pratap's second son. It is nowhere mentioned that phool gave birth to pratap's second child.

there is a lot of difference between second son and second child.

there are chances that pratap's second child being conceived by his 2nd 3rd of 4th wives too... but there are chances that one of the daughters came from phool as well... not necessary that she only gave birth to a son... and making her the second child's or second son's mother doesn't make her important. it means something else too... if we take human nature. we never brought up the fact.

FACT 5

PHOOL WAS NEVER A MAHARANI

REASON- Only Ajabde was maharani of pratap because she was his dharam patni or main wife.phool and rest of the queens were upapatnis or secondary wives and did not have the right of being the Maharani or to interfere in the political matters like ajabde did.

ajadbe married him first and become maharani.. it's the matter of who came first and who didn't. we didn't put up a fight for that fact.

FACT 6

AJABDE NEVER DIED AT AN EARLY AGE.

REASON- some readers and praphool fans state that ajabde died at an early age and phool was pratap's favourite afterwards. but the fact is wrong. after a lot of calculations, I conclude that Ajabde died in he early forties and pratap dies 8 years afterwards. After her death, pratap devoted his time to his motherland and spent time with his mother and amar sigh.

that's history... not what the serial shows us. and ajabde dying soon was something a spoiler raised rumour given at the start of the show. not what we read of history.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

sorry praphool fans but you need to agry. Pratap's favourite was ajabde. no matter he love phool or not he always dedicated his heart to ajabde. They indeed have a wonderful love story.

replied in bold to each of your facts.

regardless of what you write we are going to love our praphool... first love doesn't make it his true love... his true love was his love for his motherland... and you hadn't been there as a friend to the real maharana pratap to know what went on in his mind. what must have went on his mind is the battles and fight that he had with the mughal troops..and his heart was dedicated to his motherland first before anything...ajadbe or phool.. are secondary. we love pratap because of his love for his motherland not for him loving phool...

you need not force your opinions on us and try to clear our misunderstandings sweetheart.. because it is not your job. because there is a high chance that you are under a misunderstanding as well...you are not aware what the real maharana pratap did with his wives or his children... his life history is accounted based on his wars... not his love for his wives. that would make him majnu not maharana pratap.

pratap may have never loved phool or ajadbe too.. maybe his fav was someone else... for he did have 9 others in his life other than phool or ajabde. did he give an autobiography of himself... that he loved this wife more than the other.. no.. what is given is history based on third person's account.

we need not fight over what they show us on tv. it is after all a show isn't it.. you intended this post to be offensive to us... by your last line that we need to get angry... we need not. just like you love your favourite couple... we love ours. regardless of your opinion that ajabde and pratap share a wonderful love story... it matters not to us.. because what matters is phool for us. we are waiting for their love story to happen.. and there's been rumours that they would show them romancing... do we do not really care what ajabde and pratap share.

what is offensive to us is that they are showing pratap accepting to do things based on ajabde's request. we have the right to speak on a public forum and we are doing it peacefully or ranting it in our own posts. if you do not wish to hear our words then you should keep away from reading those posts just like we tend to ignore posts on ajabde and pratap... rather than creating posts that end up starting a spat on the forum.

i am not asking you to get lost.. let me make that clear.. in case you misunderstand my words.. i meant to ask you to ignore our posts... which is meant for discussion among us praphool fans. we didn't speak out all these months when they were showing pratap and ajabde...and you guys were discussing on them. now when our favorite pair have come back we are discussing among ourselves. why are you trying to provoke us into fighting with you... why is there a need to get angry over what they show on a tv show.. and fight with people whom you do not know over a computer screen.

you please do not need to give us a reality check... because we are watching a fictional tv show only based on a real person...not his autobiography come to life...but a historical show. let's just watch what they show and discuss it in posts between ourselves. alright...

Originally posted by: NiVu-mjht1

replied in bold to each of your facts.

regardless of what you write we are going to love our praphool... first love doesn't make it his true love... his true love was his love for his motherland... and you hadn't been there as a friend to the real maharana pratap to know what went on in his mind. what must have went on his mind is the battles and fight that he had with the mughal troops..and his heart was dedicated to his motherland first before anything...ajadbe or phool.. are secondary. we love pratap because of his love for his motherland not for him loving phool...

you need not force your opinions on us and try to clear our misunderstandings sweetheart.. because it is not your job. because there is a high chance that you are under a misunderstanding as well...you are not aware what the real maharana pratap did with his wives or his children... his life history is accounted based on his wars... not his love for his wives. that would make him majnu not maharana pratap.

pratap may have never loved phool or ajadbe too.. maybe his fav was someone else... for he did have 9 others in his life other than phool or ajabde. did he give an autobiography of himself... that he loved this wife more than the other.. no.. what is given is history based on third person's account.

we need not fight over what they show us on tv. it is after all a show isn't it.. you intended this post to be offensive to us... by your last line that we need to get angry... we need not. just like you love your favourite couple... we love ours. regardless of your opinion that ajabde and pratap share a wonderful love story... it matters not to us.. because what matters is phool for us. we are waiting for their love story to happen.. and there's been rumours that they would show them romancing... do we do not really care what ajabde and pratap share.

what is offensive to us is that they are showing pratap accepting to do things based on ajabde's request. we have the right to speak on a public forum and we are doing it peacefully or ranting it in our own posts. if you do not wish to hear our words then you should keep away from reading those posts just like we tend to ignore posts on ajabde and pratap... rather than creating posts that end up starting a spat on the forum.

i am not asking you to get lost.. let me make that clear.. in case you misunderstand my words.. i meant to ask you to ignore our posts... which is meant for discussion among us praphool fans. we didn't speak out all these months when they were showing pratap and ajabde...and you guys were discussing on them. now when our favorite pair have come back we are discussing among ourselves. why are you trying to provoke us into fighting with you... why is there a need to get angry over what they show on a tv show.. and fight with people whom you do not know over a computer screen.

you please do not need to give us a reality check... because we are watching a fictional tv show only based on a real person...not his autobiography come to life...but a historical show. let's just watch what they show and discuss it in posts between ourselves. alright...

without any doubt pratap first love was his motherland but deary you have to get ur facts very clear I know ur pra...phool fan but plzzz stop being in denial coz even in real ajabde was his true love infact he made a special palace for his dearly wife but I feel loving his motherland is so different beside wat we are talking here is totally different and the post made for phool and it's a truth whatever she posted here so plzzz don't misunderstood the perspective ! nobody here judging here anyone it's just a freedom of speech and if you don't like simply ignore rather infuriating urself and rest wait and watch letz see whose ship will rise or fall😆so chill and have a glass of cold water and enjoy the show rather fighting here😆

Don't fight friends...after all we will get to see only that what Cvs wants to show us...and everybody here knows about our poojniy CV's self made history... .there are so many important things we can discuss about..we need to raise our voice against cv's distorted history😡...In front of those...this Praphool vs. PraJa fight is just senseless.....after all we all are MPians...right???😳

I agree with Rashi! Let's not get into all this silly fights on the forum!
They are two different television jodis both loved...and both different in their own ways!
Let's not make ANY bashing post or any comparison post between Phool and Ajabde (now onwards)
let's please not fight and make this forum a war zone!

exactly what i said as well.. we praphool fans do not want a fight. you please ignore our posts on phool.. like we ignore yours about ajadbe.. who was raising their voice or infuriating themselves. i certainly didn't. i just defended my opinion and i did so in a calm and composed manner as well. people just assumed that i had been angry.. when i wasn't. i had mentioned that we are just watching the show and we praphool fans are discussing things ourselves. someone brought out that he made a special palace for ajabde... i didn't say he didn't. but that's history. we are watching a show and we are entertaining ourselves with is and discussing things. there is no need for us to get our facts right...

infact the reply next to my previous post has what had annoyed me rather than what the topic maker had written.. as it had been addressed directly to me.. and asking me to get my facts right. i need not get my facts right because i am just watching a show and when topics are made about my favourite character i would obviously wish to discuss it it. i need not know the truth... fact is that..the cvs are going to show what they like and i wished for the rest who are a not a fan of phool to ignore our posts. keep to discussing about your favourite rather than making hate posts and why she is not this.. why she is not that... kind of posts..if you people talk about our favourite characters we would obviously come here to speak.


to the person who replied to mine..aditi.. isn't it... i am not fighting with anyone in here.. i need not take a glass of cold water to calm myself and neither am i being in denial.. please read my post and then reply to me... rather than assuming that i am angry or fighting with anyone. i know i am watching a show and that's what i have written about in my post as well. i had asked the topic makers to not force their opinions on us... with facts about history.. we know those things as well. we are watching a show and they are showing certain things.. which we want to see. i asked them to refrain from making topics on facts rather than what they show on the tv.

if there is sentence that says that we are offended about something, it was against the character of pratap that they shown on the coronation episode. anyone would get offended if they show someone treating a person as a doll that they use when they want and throw it away. pratap's actions with phool is for us similar to that. he likes this toy.. but doesn't have any use for it for years and when someone else wanted to take it away he made such a hue and cry about it and landed himself in trouble to retrieve it... and when they permanently made the doll his he is ignoring it. we wished for phool to be treated as a person with feelings.. if he didn't wish to wear it.. he could have said to phool that i would wear it on some other day... rather than getting permission from ajabde to wear the dress that phool chose.. or that he chose to wear it because ajabde told him to... that would be like rubbing in her face that you do not matter here anymore. is not asking to do that, too much to ask for..

there was a line in the post that the topic maker made stating that we need to get angry.. and i replied to that. if you need to advise someone, i hope you understand who you are supposed to speak to rather than asking me to take a chill pill.. your post had annoyed me when you asked me to stop being in denial, not the topic maker's.

i hope you read this post as well, completely before commenting or replying to me.

Wonderful and 'enlightening; post. Thanks as my knowledge of History of MP is 0 !!!! I needed the info. But its amazing how the simple facts of the MP History has 'riled ' some readers! please be cool and enjoy the show and laugh over it not create any unhappiness. CHILL , Friends !

It will be better if we don't get into fight for the silly reason
it will also be better if we follow who we want to
but the facts are true
it is a really nice post

Thank u for all this informtaion