History being distorted and still watching the show?? | DT note p.6 - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

44

Views

5.8k

Users

29

Likes

107

Frequent Posters

aryagr thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
Bang on Erika. I read each and evry word u said and i totally agree wid you. I too started watching MP after i heard about Rachu 's entry and i dont regret it. I havent come across the comments criticizing the viewers but if u r saying so than there must be some. I thought they ve bn criticizing only actors and i realy have been ignoring these criticism as i believe that changes r not easily accepted by people but guess we viewers r also not spared. Love u erika 4 this post.
roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#12
@Hiral_Halwa: I agree with your comment that there were misunderstandings between both fan groups and respect your POV as well. Thanks for the comment 😊
aryagr thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa

My 2 cents on whatever is happening in the forum right now...

Yes the history has been distorted for long in the show - to be precise since the bundi track started, probably since december-jan...and then the fake pratap-jalal friendship...and then the girls entered...and praja + phool (again phool's entry or contribution a total distortion) and a mahabhayankar pratap vs jalal war...which again untrue and mixed up to make it look like a mahabharat in MP...and the e384632984326952 times praja sacrificed...most of us were banging our heads with whats going on!
and YES there were complaints in the forum...on all the distortions...and there were many who left watching the show too, due to it...there were many who came back in regular intervals, there were many who dint watch but kept themselves updated with the tracks...through review posts here etc...
and in that period of preleap - even with all the fanwars between us and phool fans or between history lovers and jodi lovers- not once was any member of the forum accused of being a sour grape, or jealous, or immature, or wanting to watch the show to see kids making out...NOT EVEN ONCE! everyone was defending their fav character...but not fighting over actors...
and yes, most of us who watched, despite whatever, watched it for the kids, coz they were extremely talented...having said that, we dint start watching the show for a fav actor in the show, many did not even know about faisal or roshni or vishal before MP happened...maybe some knew about faisal as a dancer and most knew jannat coz she is popular child actor and acclaimed one too...
the characters grew on us first and then the actors...or simultaneously, along with our liking for characters, we grew fond of actors too...its pratap and ajabdeh who most started loving as a pair becoz of the characteristics and build up of the characters and then faisal and roshni were adored...and before praja too, there have been discussions in and around characters and history very actively on the forum...but as it is said, lovestory is spice of any show and forum, praja track attracted more members to the forum...
Its not a crime to watch shows for fav...ill do the same when either of the kids come back...coz all of them were incredible...and thats my opinion...we dint ask rachna fans or sharad fans to agree with it...but it seems, that if we praise faisal or roshni here for their past performance or any other child actor too...its taken in the view of putting down sharad and rachna, when thats not the idea at all...we cant even praise the kids anymore on the forum? why is everything taken in the light of comparisons? the other day, somebody said that we are crushing on faisal so we cant accept sharad- and how ridiculous is that - is that what the opinion is - that just because we liked a bunch of kids, probably all of us are kids too- and comments are passed on our age and what not...and immature phangurls as well - grown ups cannot be fans of kids😆...and what was that- immature fans have immature needs and wanted kids to have an SR...so wont accept the new leads...😆?? probably ul should read the past few pages for sure...we hated the SR shown between JB-US...kids toh bahot door ki baat hai🤢🤢 and there were posts made to vent the same as well...that we do not want CVs to show SRs on this show - not even with adults...and make it cheap...personally I hate SRs shown or the hype for SRs in our Indian shows and the discussions around it in IF...half the IF is contaminated with how the pairs should make out...and the beauty of praja lied in the contained romance! in their purity and essence
misunderstandings havent happened from one side only! its been going on even after we apologized for the misunderstood comments on rachna's attitude...and asked ul to drop the matter...but no...it continued...and what is with rachna fans taking offence even if sharad is criticized ?? 😕
not a single comment can be written here, without being bracketed as bashing...or labelled jealous...really...I expected better from the "mature" fans! and even on distortion - sweta was picked up on in the trp thread, just becoz she said that the show is distorted??!! infact I was so pleasantly surprised when rachna fans had contributed to roshni's birdie thread, or even when they were consoling us...and we had acknowledged and welcomed ul warmly here...but it seems things just had to go out of hand
when an actor is criticized, its solely on the acting skills...and we dont have any personal problems with the new ones?? so why is it that the fans react as if, we are criticizing them instead of the actors??😕...we loved pratap and ajabdeh for so long...so we give two cents on what we expect them to be...and most have even accepted rachna as ajabdeh...but even if one person doesnt agree with it, that person becomes a basher and the whole fandom is dragged into it...
sorry for the long post and if ul dont have the time to read...please avoid or ignore it! and this is probably the last time I write on this forum...but it had to be explained!

most of Rachana's fans have always praised all the bachha parties as they were awesome and we have not asked any1 to like Rachana. Its your choice and as for criticism, we ve ignored them but here TM is just keeping her POV on criticizing vieweres as well. Its ok to criticize the actors 4 their acting but y viewers. Its viewers choice whether they want to watch it or not. My POV - i dont mind members of this forum criticizing actors work as long as its not personal comments on her.
foram. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#14
agree with u dear...
history was distorted since start still ppl watched and still watching *criticise karne ke lie*
so we too watching for our fav actor aur hame bhi *criticise karne ka mauka do*
_zari_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa

My 2 cents on whatever is happening in the forum right now...

Yes the history has been distorted for long in the show - to be precise since the bundi track started, probably since december-jan...and then the fake pratap-jalal friendship...and then the girls entered...and praja + phool (again phool's entry or contribution a total distortion) and a mahabhayankar pratap vs jalal war...which again untrue and mixed up to make it look like a mahabharat in MP...and the e384632984326952 times praja sacrificed...most of us were banging our heads with whats going on!
and YES there were complaints in the forum...on all the distortions...and there were many who left watching the show too, due to it...there were many who came back in regular intervals, there were many who dint watch but kept themselves updated with the tracks...through review posts here etc...
and in that period of preleap - even with all the fanwars between us and phool fans or between history lovers and jodi lovers- not once was any member of the forum accused of being a sour grape, or jealous, or immature, or wanting to watch the show to see kids making out...NOT EVEN ONCE! everyone was defending their fav character...but not fighting over actors...
and yes, most of us who watched, despite whatever, watched it for the kids, coz they were extremely talented...having said that, we dint start watching the show for a fav actor in the show, many did not even know about faisal or roshni or vishal before MP happened...maybe some knew about faisal as a dancer and most knew jannat coz she is popular child actor and acclaimed one too...
the characters grew on us first and then the actors...or simultaneously, along with our liking for characters, we grew fond of actors too...its pratap and ajabdeh who most started loving as a pair becoz of the characteristics and build up of the characters and then faisal and roshni were adored...and before praja too, there have been discussions in and around characters and history very actively on the forum...but as it is said, lovestory is spice of any show and forum, praja track attracted more members to the forum...
Its not a crime to watch shows for fav...ill do the same when either of the kids come back...coz all of them were incredible...and thats my opinion...we dint ask rachna fans or sharad fans to agree with it...but it seems, that if we praise faisal or roshni here for their past performance or any other child actor too...its taken in the view of putting down sharad and rachna, when thats not the idea at all...we cant even praise the kids anymore on the forum? why is everything taken in the light of comparisons? the other day, somebody said that we are crushing on faisal so we cant accept sharad- and how ridiculous is that - is that what the opinion is - that just because we liked a bunch of kids, probably all of us are kids too- and comments are passed on our age and what not...and immature phangurls as well - grown ups cannot be fans of kids😆...and what was that- immature fans have immature needs and wanted kids to have an SR...so wont accept the new leads...😆?? probably ul should read the past few pages for sure...we hated the SR shown between JB-US...kids toh bahot door ki baat hai🤢🤢 and there were posts made to vent the same as well...that we do not want CVs to show SRs on this show - not even with adults...and make it cheap...personally I hate SRs shown or the hype for SRs in our Indian shows and the discussions around it in IF...half the IF is contaminated with how the pairs should make out...and the beauty of praja lied in the contained romance! in their purity and essence
misunderstandings havent happened from one side only! its been going on even after we apologized for the misunderstood comments on rachna's attitude...and asked ul to drop the matter...but no...it continued...and what is with rachna fans taking offence even if sharad is criticized ?? 😕
not a single comment can be written here, without being bracketed as bashing...or labelled jealous...really...I expected better from the "mature" fans! and even on distortion - sweta was picked up on in the trp thread, just becoz she said that the show is distorted??!! infact I was so pleasantly surprised when rachna fans had contributed to roshni's birdie thread, or even when they were consoling us...and we had acknowledged and welcomed ul warmly here...but it seems things just had to go out of hand
when an actor is criticized, its solely on the acting skills...and we dont have any personal problems with the new ones?? so why is it that the fans react as if, we are criticizing them instead of the actors??😕...we loved pratap and ajabdeh for so long...so we give two cents on what we expect them to be...and most have even accepted rachna as ajabdeh...but even if one person doesnt agree with it, that person becomes a basher and the whole fandom is dragged into it...
sorry for the long post and if ul dont have the time to read...please avoid or ignore it! and this is probably the last time I write on this forum...but it had to be explained!

i must say hiral u write so well, u have expressed most of the old viewers views so well, ab toh kuch bhi bolo it becomes bashing, i am a big fan of ur writings.
criticisms has been here before also infact from the very beginning, but it used to be fun reading all that history distortions, praja love, praphool vs praja, pralal everything, i have been mostly a slilent member and a stalker as well of rosal at😉but i loved this forum bcoz of all this, crazy discussions on the at, everything was great, but now toh i better not say anything, it seems it has become a new place now, nothing is the same.
roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#16
I can understand that there have been misunderstandings between all the members and only want to say that we should respect everyone's opinion and this I am telling all the fan groups including RP fans. Anyone can criticize the story line, the acting of the actors, the CVs as they have a right to do so but only I am making this post to avoid criticizing the viewers for watching the show. I hope we can peace out here and there are no more misunderstandings from now on.
Edited by erikalui - 10 years ago
_aashi_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: azloo_l

i must say hiral u write so well, u have expressed most of the old viewers views so well, ab toh kuch bhi bolo it becomes bashing, i am a big fan of ur writings.
criticisms has been here before also infact from the very beginning, but it used to be fun reading all that history distortions, praja love, praphool vs praja, pralal everything, i have been mostly a slilent member and a stalker as well of rosal at😉but i loved this forum bcoz of all this, crazy discussions on the at, everything was great, but now toh i better not say anything, it seems it has become a new place now, nothing is the same.

wahi toh...leap has changed everything...
JShiv thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
Erika totally agreed, history has been distorted from the beginning and will continue to be distorted till the end. But when people starts picking on every single thing post leap without mentioning that this has been happening from a long time... or saying that the story was always off track but they watched for the kids and is now watching for history, fully well knowing that there was hardly any history to start with... then of course that come's across as hypocritical. (when we are blamed for watching for actors only )
And fan wars will obviously break out cause the constant comparing and what not will always lead to fan groups defending their fave.

And not all of Rachana fans gets offended when Ssharad is criticized or bashed
I for one (speaking for my self here only) am totally fed up of the constant bashing or more so *criticizing* of Ssharad cause its the same thing day in day out... like a broken record... hence starts to irritate me.

And when generalized statements like people like watching saas bahu saga are made (even though no saas bahu nothing has been shown thus far) then that is also gonna get reactions.

My pov strictly 😳



roni_berna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago
#19
I have made it very clear in my post to avoid bashing but it's continuing. I have reported your post @Paytonlee

No more arguments from my end.
Edited by erikalui - 10 years ago
Haisisterz thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: aryagr

name calling ? Bhashans ? There is no namecalling in this post. Its just hr POV. If not interested. Just ignore. But plz dont blame.

Absolutely 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".