Sharad Malhotra: The elder pratap- Thumbs down CVs! [DT NOTE P.6]

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Chitra

@Chitra89

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: BornCritical

I am not going personal just talking facts .if facts sound joke to u ,then so bit it.

Good that u laughed rather then cry ...LOL

Would say come out of ur biased world and see things critically .Faisal was not perfect in all his scenes but overall did a good job as a child artist.Sharad too is doing his best given to the limitations of directors and creatives.

That's it...you crossed your line buddy...DON'T YOU DARE POINT FINGER AT MY FAISAL. 😡 😡

It will be harder to accept SM as Pratap. But people are trying. Ppl will start to like him...but please don't say anything about Faisal. He is too good to compare with SM at this point.

That kid did an amazing job, "not just good job." If he...in your language, "wasn't perfect," CV's wouldn't have kept him in the show for one and half year. If he...in your language..."wasn't perfect," CV's wldn't took 500+ auditions to find the adult Pratap. So many ppl said, so many good things about him. He is only 15 and this was his first and biggest TV show ever! Did you even saw his acting as Pratap?

And you are in Faisal fans territory...if you say anything against Faisal...then you are doomed 😈

No one is perfect, not even Faisal. But for us, he is just perfect. And it's been two days he is been gone from the show, obviously it will take time for us to get over him who is been part of this show for one and a half year...so don't tell us to come out of our "biased," world. We will come out when we want.

And many of us comparing SM with real MP not with Faisal. But it's true tht Faisal did an amazing job as younger Pratap.

If you really wanna praise SM, why not create a AT on his name?? Go thr and praise him as much as you want...no one will say anything to you guys.

I am sry for being rude 😕...I am not a rude type person, seriously I am not. But you comment really made me mad 😭

Edited by Chitra89 - 10 years ago

Quote

1009044

Suspended

Posted: 10 years ago

#42

I've watched two episodes of this new guy. I'm not comparing with him Faisal or great Maharana Pratap. But this new guy Ssharad seriously lack acting prowess, he's expressionless! I'm very much disappointed, new MP choice could've been much much better.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

kaku17

@kaku17

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: AreYaar

Faisal was not perfect but the issue you've pointed out was definitely not one of his shortcomings...Pratap's fierceness regarding his love for his motherland, his hatred for the Mughals was one of his defining characteristics and anything short of stern in portraying that would have not looked correct...so Faisal portrayed that stern attitude very well.

Sharad currently is unable to get into the skin of the character...He seems to have zero knowledge about his character despite supposedly researching and training for many months to play this role...If he had spent more time imbibing the spirit of Pratap rather than growing a moustache and stubble, it might have been more helpful.

He is an utter letdown...they gave him ample scope to make an impact with the way they set up his entry...monologues, desert shoot, bg music...but none of it worked cuz Sharad himself is totally lacking the spirit of Pratap.

Ironically a CHILD Faisal appeared MORE mature than him while playing this role😆

I agree with what you said...Faisal was able to portray the fierceness so beautifully...not only that he was stellar in all his scenes, be it romance, grief, anger...he nailed all the scenes with aplomb...though he might have faltered in the beginning of the show which was understandable as it was his first show...

Regarding SM I think he's unable to get the essence of Pratap, the warrior...😡...I am most disappointed with his voice yaar...no power..WTH...and yest epi when he spoke about his hatred for Ajab...I kept on waiting for a reflection of the same in his eyes...but alas ...when you hate or love some1 with so much passion it should reflect in your gait, your body language and most importantly your eyes... 😡

boo hoo hoo 😭😭😭...what a waste...SM is not a bad actor...he has to understand the essence of pratap and then hopefully he will deliver...and his body language will become right...I just hope he gets there sooner...

I like the rest of the casting...Rachna as Ajab was tremendous in her entry shot...it was a seamless transition...😃...and kunwar Jagmal...well well he looks slimy and evil to say the least...perfect casting...😆😆

Edited by kaku17 - 10 years ago

Quote

deeptiya

@deeptiya

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: BornCritical

I am not going personal just talking facts .if facts sound joke to u ,then so bit it.

Good that u laughed rather then cry ...LOL

Would say come out of ur biased world and see things critically .Faisal was not perfect in all his scenes but overall did a good job as a child artist.Sharad too is doing his best given to the limitations of directors and creatives.

ok,,,,,,so u r not gonna understand,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, let me clear something,,,,,,,,,,,,

there r different groups of ppl here,,,,,,,,,,,

praja jan,,,,,,,,,, that means ROsalians

praphool fans,,,,,,,,,,,,, that means ,,,,,,faijan

and MPians ,,,,,,, that means faisalians

now

the common thing between all these groups is one and only,,,,,,,,,, FAISAL

and

u managed to piss every single one them,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,

if u r SM fan,,,,, to b happy with him,,,,,,,,, worship him,praise him,,,,,,,appreciate him ,,,, but trying to bash FAISAL,,,,,,,,,,,, no,,,,,,,,, there u have crossed ur line,,,,,,,,,,,,,

and u have asked a sage wala,,,,,,,,,,,,,, for MP na,,,,,,,,,,,,, we have a member from the great MP clan,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, u better watch ur words,,,,,,,,,,,,

u r way out of line by choosing inappropriate words for faisal,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, not done,,,,,,,, totally not done,,,,,,,

and combining stern and not perfect words with overall good performance by faisal is not gonna make this right whatever u have said about faisal,,,,,,,,,,,, don;t

Quote

Sadme-Me-Hu

@Sadme-Me-Hu

Stunner

+ 7

Posted: 10 years ago

#45

Hi,

Differences in opinions are bound to exist in a forum like India-forums.com. It is a place where we allow everyone to express their opinions freely within the COC and respectable limitations. However, this does not permit one to attack their fellow members for not sharing the same point of view.
Refrain from pointing fingers or taking direct/indirect or sarcastic digs at other members or fan-groups. Fans can be passionate towards their favorite celeb, but it does not mean they can be judgmental towards other members.

Members like or dislike the new actor is YOUR OPINION and that's it! You are not allowed to attack the members who like/dislike the other actor. Moreover, members are reminded that under no circumstances can you pass derogatory comments or mock the physical appearance of the actor concerned.
The thread is under-watch and any rule offensive post after this note shall lead to the thread's closure. Offensive comments have been moved to the PUS/or edited. Kindly do not Quote this note and bring all your concerns via PM to me.

MP DT.

Edited by BubblyR - 10 years ago

Quote

keshav

@VS-Cool

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#46

So all i can say that MP was the reason for which i joined India Forums & was desperately waiting to watch Post leap story but now I am totally blank & sad to see this situation. Period.

Quote

MaxMayfield

@MaxMayfield

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: VS-Cool
So all i can say that MP was the reason for which i joined India Forums & was desperately waiting to watch Post leap story but now I am totally blank & sad to see this situation. Period.

IKR😔 its just not the same anymore

forget the new actors, the storyline is in terrible mess! I cant see this MP...where its all about nafrat-pyaar bakwaas🤢 praja's essence is gone...this is so unlike pratap to not trust ajab at all...and blame her for being JB's reason for going away...this is not like JB to just go away forever, for such a dumb issue, knowing what DB is capable off...

the two central characters are ruined completely...akbar ka ataa pataa nahi hai...

only ajab''s essence is retained in character...but at what cost.,..? "sacchey deshbhakto ki fake gatha bana di! why are they showing praja on two ends, when they could easily show praja at one end and the whole world at another...and both together to support each other...but NO CVs just want to waste more time! and more time! and by the time they decide to show history...we all will most prbably will be done with the show completely...

Quote

AroraTanya

@AroraTanya

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#48

CVs have supposedly auditioned 700 people for grown up MP and they came up with Sharad! Seriously?! 😲😕

Quote

keshav

@VS-Cool

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 10 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa

</div>IKR😔its just not the same anymore
<div>

forget the new actors, the storyline is in terrible mess! I cant see this MP...where its all about nafrat-pyaar bakwaas🤢praja's essence is gone...this is so unlike pratap to not trust ajab at all...and blame her for being JB's reason for going away...this is not like JB to just go away forever, for such a dumb issue, knowing what DB is capable off...

the two central characters are ruined completely...akbar ka ataa pataa nahi hai...

only ajab''s essence is retained in character...but at what cost.,..? "sacchey deshbhakto ki fake gatha bana di! why are they showing praja on two ends, when they could easily show praja at one end and the whole world at another...and both together to support each other...but NO CVs just want to waste more time! and more time! and by the time they decide to show history...we all will most prbably will be done with the show completely...

yes Hiral, its almost impossible to think about this seperation track. Mewar was surrounded with so many danger circumstances, that Udai & Pratap can't even think about such silly issues? I mean blaming Daughter in law for wife's vanvas ainveyii ? Thats a horrible manipulation that even Amar Singh is not borned yet. They made mockery of our history, this channel is champion in doing that, & rahi sahi kasar creatives aur Casting walo ne puri kardiya :(

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 10 years ago

#50

Originally posted by: Hiral_Halwa

lol anu, I so agree! Amongst the entire new cast! I actually only liked older jagmal...coz the actor is really doing good enuf in the negative role!

LOL Hiral, I was really surprised...yes it's a negative OTT role but the actor they've cast for Jagmal is surprisingly apt for his role and is justifying it...Ironically most of the new cast has better screen presence than the "hero" of the show Sharad😕😕😆

And I don't know how to explain it...but there is something REALLY weird about the way he's trying to do a "royal" walking style😆😆...the way he walks in and out of a room/scene...He looks like he's trying too hard to LOOK "royal" but he only ends up looking comical in trying to show some kind of royal style😆😆

Chakrapani is also ok enough...doesn't seem like the new princess Chand Kanwar will have much of a role...

Rachna is doing a decent job...atleast I can't accuse her of being artificial the way Sharad is being...she is looking pretty but still the very storyline is so maha stupid...each time they show the flashbacks of Pratap lashing out at Ajabde with the whole GHRINA crap, the disconnect widens...

Also dunno if it was just me but seeing an adult Ajabde remembering child Pratap was making me😆😆...anyways she atleast has gotten the regal mannerisms down better than Sharad if the precap was anything to go by.

Quote

1 ... 3 4 5 6 7 ... 13

Sharad Malhotra

Sharad Malhotra: The elder pratap- Thumbs down CVs! [DT NOTE P.6] - Page 5

Related Topics

Explore Topics