Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.5k

Users

10

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#11
TM
You should have used "certain Muslim historians" instead of Muslims in general.

Letter is not going to accomplish anything. Certain Rajput community sites protested against this show and tampering with history. But CVs or channel did not budge. They mauled both Akbar and MP side in this one.

They should just give disclaimer like other show. Stop pretending to be history.
nirmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: ruhi22

I request to India forums to Delete this post..your not suppose to use strong words like " Muslims beleives that"...Being a Muslim I don't beleive that..stop making those acquisitions!!

don't tell me this though iam staying in canada there are pakistani muslism and afgani plus gujrati muslism who are staying near my house and they everyday accuse my kids for being a hindu making fun of our gods and religion and i did not point any particular Muslim in general but only the historians and what about those who always target our clan saying that we are fanatics but let me tell you that we were the one who are called guardian of Hinduism and i am very much against jodha akbar too just to gain Trp they show something if these shows are only for mere entertainment than let them say that its not from history .viewers will believe that what they are showing is true history and get wrong Interpretation about their traditions and culture too.let me tell u friends Iam not school going girl but a 45yrs old lady and a historian and plus Maharana pratap is my great great ...great grandpa .and raja mansing was grand pa of my M.I.L
Edited by nirmita - 11 years ago
bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: nirmita

Friends i have sent this complaint to IBM regarding distortion about the serial.

Muslim says that Maharana Pratap was coward and ran away from HaldiGhati war which is not true to my knowledge as he was requested by his brother Shakti Singh to leave the war as Maharana Pratap was badly injured and his horse passed away while saving him. The war was draw and no one won it.


Regards,

Nirmita Srivastava


if anyone says MP was coward during haldighati war then they have not read history. what we knew about MP before this serial just think... his great fight against akbar hadighati war and his white horse chetak. this is what we learn from our history book and i have not heard any coward words in it. they did damage akbar army very badly. war is won only if other side king is dead or capture at that time MP needed to be alive so that he can fight back. his army was still fighting but once mugal knew they can not capture MP for them it was no point.

whoever say he was coward during haldighati war they need to hit internet enough information is available for this war.

i am more curious about chittor war US decides not to fight and pratap reaction as he is not king yet so he can not go against US.


ruhi22 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: nirmita

don't tell me this though iam staying in canada there are pakistani muslism and afgani plus gujrati muslism who are staying near my house and they everyday accuse my kids for being a hindu making fun of our gods and religion and i did not point any particular Muslim in general but only the historians and what about those who always target our clan saying that we are fanatics but let me tell you that we were the one who are called guardian of Hinduism and i am very much against jodha akbar too just to gain Trp they show something if these shows are only for mere entertainment than let them say that its not from history .viewers will believe that what they are showing is true history and get wrong Interpretation about their traditions and culture too.let me tell u friends Iam not school going girl but a 45yrs old lady and a historian and plus Maharana pratap is my great great ...great grandpa .and raja mansing was grand pa of my M.I.L




Your getting too much Personal Mam...I don't care what's happening in your life...I can write chapters on how hindu's accuses Muslims ...So please grow up!!...My Family is a big Fan of MP and we think that he was a great king and warrior..If you call yourself a historian...be careful to make strong statements about people...Being a great great grand daughter please don't spoil his image..Learn some morals from him..

I request again to India forum to delete this post...
nirmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: ruhi22




Your getting too much Personal Mam...I don't care what's happening in your life...I can write chapters on how hindu's accuses Muslims ...So please grow up!!...My Family is a big Fan of MP and we think that he was a great king and warrior..If you call yourself a historian...be careful to make strong statements about people...Being a great great grand daughter please don't spoil his image..Learn some morals from him..to correct you chetak was black horse not white horse

I request again to India forum to delete this post...

I am not being personal and hurting I can understand things and to tell you the truth when i see people fighting i just pray to almighty that its high time for blood shed why can't people just stay peaceful even here i did go and speak to those kids parents that they shd not abuse but play peacefully and happily .because i believe in unity and i think you are getting more personal for getting this post deleted other only commented and asked me to rectify it or encouraged it .
Edited by nirmita - 11 years ago
ruhi22 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: nirmita

I am not being personal and hurting I can understand things and to tell you the truth when i see people fighting i just pray to almighty that its high time for blood shed why can't people just stay peaceful even here i did go and speak to those kids parents that they shd not abuse but play peacefully and happily .because i believe in unity and i think you are getting more personal for getting this post deleted other only commented and asked me to rectify it or encouraged it .



Your Post Hurted my feelings..It shocked me!!..Being a big fan of MP I couldn't stop myself...So I thought it's better to get it deleted rather than getting it rectified by you..It wasn't a Normal post it was a letter to IBM!!!...
nirmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: ruhi22



Your Post Hurted my feelings..It shocked me!!..Being a big fan of MP I couldn't stop myself...So I thought it's better to get it deleted rather than getting it rectified by you..It wasn't a Normal post it was a letter to IBM!!!...

If you are hurt i very sorry about it but please don't take this too personal and more over the letter is to IBM why they are manipulating all the characters of the serial they are trying to prove that Akbar was tyrant which he was not and he never tried to kill MP instead always wanted MP to be his army chief and Pratap as Romeo and phool never had any importance .I only want that these cvs should understand that if they do distortions than the impact on our young generation will be wrong and the hatered will grow more.
Gewels thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#18
my pov: MIB will not even c that letter; still good try even tho i feel misdirected. send 2 Zee n PH. those r the guys who need 2 c it. tbh not comfortable with ANY govt interference.
ruhi22 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: nirmita

If you are hurt i very sorry about it but please don't take this too personal and more over the letter is to IBM why they are manipulating all the characters of the serial they are trying to prove that Akbar was tyrant which he was not and he never tried to kill MP instead always wanted MP to be his army chief and Pratap as Romeo and phool never had any importance .I only want that these cvs should understand that if they do distortions than the impact on our young generation will be wrong and the hatered will grow more.



I accept your apology..No hard feelings..Even I strongly beleive they are manipulating all the characters of the serial..My only concern was the second paragraph of yours...Anyways doesn't matter anymore..
kaku17 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#20

Hi...its very commendable on your part to take the initiative to protest with the distortion of history which happens in the name of entertainment...hope they do take some action... 👏😊

in my opinion if you would have also protested regarding the character assassination of pratap in the recent mahayudh, it would have made more impact...as laying down one's arms and exhorting your army to do so in the middle of war is sacrilege...😲(not only in those days but in today;s times as well)...it means accepting defeat or surrendering..!!!...and by that simple logic marwar should have won the war!!! 😕

Wars are won in battlefield and not in some akhadas...pratap laying down his arms and US following suit along with his army is just not acceptable ...which goes against their principles...warriors who have been conditioned to do fight until death can never never lay down their arms..!!! 😡

agreed cvs have distorted a lot and have taken a lot of liberties ..but wrt pratap, ajabdeh and phool, even after to such of khichdi, they have been steadfast in maintaining the fact that pratap loves only ajabdeh who's his soulmate... 😛

I sincerely apologize beforehand if my ramblings have somehow hurt your sentiments..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".