nirmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Friends i have sent this complaint to IBM regarding distortion about the serial. The letter is as follows:-

Date: 08/03/2014

Sub.: Tempering with historical facts and showing in the form of serial which gives

bad impression to younger generation.

Honorable Minister of Information and Broadcasting,

There is lot of tempering with Indian History related to episodes shown in the Historical serial and no one is seriously taking into consideration in condemning the fact wrongly shown. If the historical facts are tempered and wrongly shown then it should be considered as serious matter and against law. Moreover, the Director, Producer and Writer of the serial should be warned and the serial should be stopped showing in air as it gives bad impression to younger generation.

In the serial, Bharat Ka Veer Putra Maharana Pratap which comes on Sony, the Director and Writer is showing triangle between Rana Pratap, Ajabdeh and Phool Kuwar and in history, I have never heard about Phool Kuwar. This is being shown only to increase TRP of the serial. The first wife of Marana Pratap was Ajabdeh which supported him. If there is an access to the website http://www.india-forums.com/ , we can see that many viewers have abused such type of tempering of the historical facts.

Muslim says that Maharana Pratap was coward and ran away from HaldiGhati war which is not true to my knowledge as he was requested by his brother Shakti Singh to leave the war as Maharana Pratap was badly injured and his horse passed away while saving him. The war was draw and no one won it.

I hope you will intervene in this matter and would make it proper as I come from the same clan.

Regards,

Nirmita Srivastava

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.5k

Users

10

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

nirmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: nirmita

Friends i have sent this complaint to IBM regarding distortion about the serial. The letter is as follows:-

Date: 08/03/2014

Sub.: Tempering with historical facts and showing in the form of serial which gives

bad impression to younger generation.

Honorable Minister of Information and Broadcasting,

There is lot of tempering with Indian History related to episodes shown in the Historical serial and no one is seriously taking into consideration in condemning the fact wrongly shown. If the historical facts are tempered and wrongly shown then it should be considered as serious matter and against law. Moreover, the Director, Producer and Writer of the serial should be warned and the serial should be stopped showing in air as it gives bad impression to younger generation.

In the serial, Bharat Ka Veer Putra Maharana Pratap which comes on Sony, the Director and Writer is showing triangle between Rana Pratap, Ajabdeh and Phool Kuwar and in history, I have never heard about Phool Kuwar. This is being shown only to increase TRP of the serial. The first wife of Marana Pratap was Ajabdeh which supported him. If there is an access to the website http://www.india-forums.com/ , we can see that many viewers have abused such type of tempering of the historical facts.

Muslim says that Maharana Pratap was coward and ran away from HaldiGhati war which is not true to my knowledge as he was requested by his brother Shakti Singh to leave the war as Maharana Pratap was badly injured and his horse passed away while saving him. The war was draw and no one won it.

I hope you will intervene in this matter and would make it proper as I come from the same clan.

Regards,

Nirmita Srivastava

Please do tell me whether i did right or wrong .
nirmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
so many views and no comment whether i did right or wrong about this matter .come on praja fans please tell me .😕
kedar575 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
such a letter is must needed i'm with you.
Ohhh thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Nirmita I am with you dear .You did right but the question is do IBM take it seriously ? Hope they will .But I don't think dear .
_aashi_ thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
U r all right di...but wish the IBM looks into the matter. We also r angry with the distortion of history of one of the greatest warrior of Indian history.
_Rini_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
I don't know why people are making a mountain out of a molehill. People will always find faults, no matter how hard CVs and actors try. No historical (and even mythological) shows are devoid of distortion. But people should understand that these shows are merely meant for entertainment. God knows what perception you have of Jodha Akbar then. That show...arghhh...i dont want to use bad words. That show I dont think is better in anyway than Maharana Pratap. And yeah, Mahabharat on Star Plus, too. People rather than criticizing what shows are showing, should find a better show to watch which suits their interest. *confused* -Just my POV, no offence intended-
Ohhh thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: RiniRocks

I don't know why people are making a mountain out of a molehill. People will always find faults, no matter how hard CVs and actors try. No historical (and even mythological) shows are devoid of distortion. But people should understand that these shows are merely meant for entertainment. God knows what perception you have of Jodha Akbar then. That show...arghhh...i dont want to use bad words. That show I dont think is better in anyway than Maharana Pratap. And yeah, Mahabharat on Star Plus, too. People rather than criticizing what shows are showing, should find a better show to watch which suits their interest. *confused* -Just my POV, no offence intended-


If distortion is happening with history its not only our right but also our duty to voice out against it as this can lead to confusion or mislead the audience about our own history .Now a days people dont care what CVS are doing with the history they all are just concern with the so called entertainment .I wish a good number of people have supported nirmita .No cvs are afraid to show misleading tracks and people also don't care I am glad at least nirmita came up with this letter .I don't know what effect it will have but good she took the initiative .

On a side note we do support and appreciated the actors and CVS thats the reason we watch it and give trp to their show .But we don't want such entertainment which will distort our history .🤢
_Rini_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: nirmita

Friends i have sent this complaint to IBM regarding distortion about the serial. The letter is as follows:-

Date: 08/03/2014


</b>


<b>Sub.: Tempering with historical facts
and showing in the form of serial which gives



bad impression to younger generation.


<u></u>


Honorable Minister of Information
and Broadcasting,


</p>

There is lot of tempering with
Indian History related to episodes shown in the Historical serial and no one is
seriously taking into consideration in condemning the fact wrongly shown. If
the historical facts are tempered and wrongly shown then it should be
considered as serious matter and against law. Moreover, the Director, Producer
and Writer of the serial should be warned and the serial should be stopped
showing in air as it gives bad impression to younger generation.



In the serial, Bharat Ka Veer
Putra Maharana Pratap which comes on Sony, the Director and Writer is showing
triangle between Rana Pratap, Ajabdeh and Phool Kuwar and in history, I have
never heard about Phool Kuwar. This is being shown only to increase TRP of the
serial. The first wife of Marana Pratap was Ajabdeh which supported him. If there
is an access to the website http://www.india-forums.com/
, we can see that many viewers have abused such type of tempering of the
historical facts.



Muslim says that Maharana Pratap
was coward and ran away from HaldiGhati war which is not true to my knowledge
as he was requested by his brother Shakti Singh to leave the war as Maharana
Pratap was badly injured and his horse passed away while saving him. The war
was draw and no one won it.



I hope you will intervene in this
matter and would make it proper as I come from the same clan.




Regards,



<p>

Nirmita Srivastava





Muslims say that? Really? 😕 I'm a half Muslim and I don't have that perception at all. 😕
Edited by RiniRocks - 11 years ago
ruhi22 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
I request to India forums to Delete this post..your not suppose to use strong words like " Muslims beleives that"...Being a Muslim I don't beleive that..stop making those acquisitions!!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".