MP-A History-Index, Doubts & Discussion#all here - Page 7

Pratap's son Rana Amar Singh fought 17 battles with Akbar. Then he dud sandhi

According to history Shakti & Sagar tow of Prataps brothers join Akbar s service. Shakti who is recently was shown leaving Chittod after realizing that his father Rana Udai Singh would never think of seeing him as his successor, will latter join Mughal camp to fulfill his long standing ambition of defeating Pratap & winning the throne of Mewad. But latter it is also written that Shakti helps Pratap in his latter wars with the Mughals.

Was Her Royal Highness Rani Dheerbai ji alive when her dear son Jagmal joined Akbar's camp?

I also want to know when and how did she die.

Originally posted by: Skepblun

Was Her Royal Highness Rani Dheerbai ji alive when her dear son Jagmal joined Akbar's camp?

I also want to know when and how did she die.

Why there is no such info about Pratap's childhood in net ?? Then how CV's came to know about Raghavendra ?? Is it written in history about him?

Originally posted by: debasree04

Why there is no such info about Pratap's childhood in net ?? Then how CV's came to know about Raghavendra ?? Is it written in history about him?

I find story hard to believe nowadays.

Was Pratap indeed sent out of Mewar? That too on Jaiwantabai's request?

Haven't heard of any such thing. I will check it though

Originally posted by: Nandiniraizaada

Sree there is text about Pratap. There are also a lot of folklores about him in Rajasthan

Also the Sisodia Royal Family of Udaipur who are direct descendants of Maharana Pratap woul also be having information

But of course this is a show. They do dramatise and falsify things

For example what they showed about humayun was fabricated. He did not join hands with Bahadur shah. But this is a signal that they will show Mugala in a bad light

This is because one way of making your lead a hero is to totally blacken the villan. Also they have completion from jodha akbar

I am not saying moguls were great people but that does not mean they were totally evil

Also they showed humayun betrayed karnavati. How about udai songhs own uncle who tried to kill baby udai. Why don't they show that?

thanx Nandini...

that means they r also going beyond history ?
another question- we know about Sagar Singh who joined Akbar later but who is his mother ?? Why its not mentioned ??

Is it true that Pratap was sent out of mewar ? Was there no investigation by US why the maharani is asking for such a rare request? Did US at any point in time in real life come to know of his third wife's scheming against Pratap in favour of Jagmal? What does the history say on these? can some one clarify?