Analysis Corner (Mar 31st Yeh koi saas bahu serial nahi hai link p.64) - Page 11

Created

Last reply

Replies

504

Views

49.3k

Users

43

Likes

1.8k

Frequent Posters

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Minionite

Dec 9th - The Painful Trust

The empty trunk - Notice how the trunk only had the rope and the fencing sword in it. As she progresses through her plan, she will fill that trunk with spoils of the war. The problem is that right now this war is one-sided. Only she's fighting it. Her enemy is still trying to get his bearings. Thus, while the trunk may be filling up right now, it'll empty as well. The empty trunk is also significant because in a way it signifies Maya's life right now. It's empty. Void. As she gets her revenge, her life will also start to get "filled". Notice one more thing. The trunk is two-thirds Rudra, one-third Rishi. Maybe I'm reading too much into it, but in a way that signifies that Maya's life will be filled by both Rudra and Rishi, not just one. Rudra will have a stronger impact, but Rishi will also be there. I wonder if MJ will have the strongest impact though?

Fencing as an outlet - We can say all we want that Rudra wasn't affected by the fish selling, but in a way he was. He was affected because despite winning to Maya, he still lost. He had thought that making more money than Maya had expected would have shown her down, but it didn't. Instead, she turned the tables back on him instead. Then he tried to use fencing as an outlet to take out his anger and lost there as well. Fencing will be interesting going forward because it is all about duels and self-defense. Unlike regular sword-fighting which is all about attacking, fencing used to take place when it was about dueling against someone for personal harm or attacks on pride or for defending oneself against some type of accusation. In a way, that's what is happening here. Maya is repeatedly challenging Rudra to a duel to get through to MJ and he is fighting in self-defense. It's symbolic because with either the fencing match could be seen as the foreshadowing for the next task or as a follow-up to the previous task. In either case, if Maya wins the task, she wins the fencing match.

MJ's indirect plan - Why not just follow Rudra directly? But then again this might be MJ's way of gearing up for attack. In war, there is always strategy and strategy is done quietly, privately, indirectly. If MJ was to have Rudra followed directly, instead of via a tracker, Maya would know right away that her enemy is gearing up to fight back. In this way, Maya will never know when MJ will attack. (Of course that's what MJ thinks because Maya knew about the tracker and her hidden man destroyed the tracker and sent Aamir on a wild goose chase. But more on this later. Let's keep talking from MJ's perspective.) MJ is gathering intelligence, developing theories, testing those theories, and then, once he has enough information, he will strategize and attack back. I do have a complaint that MJ is not seen enough, but this may just be the calm before the storm. The CVs are deliberately holding MJ back to unleash him at the right time. Let the audience feel this is a one-sided battle and then they'll bring out the full force of MJ.

The test of trust and the painful trust - Credit to Shruthi for the title, but I added a bit of my own to it because it is an important aspect. But first let's talk about the test itself. Maya said "reach the top". She never said take the stairs to the top. Yet Rudra's first move was to run for the stairs. In a way, it's about behaviour ingrained in us from childhood. We're always taught about the ladder to success, never about a lift to success. I bet MJ consistently reminded Rudra and Rishi since they were little kids that he got to the top by climbing many "stairs", not by taking the "elevator/lift". This is an important distinction and one that Maya points out succinctly. We listen, but we don't actually listen. If Rudra had listened properly, he would have understood that all Maya said was to get to the top. But the problem isn't in not listening, it's also in our brains. Our brains run almost twice as fast as the words that can come out of our mouths. Thus, our brains are already filling in the words before we even hear them and also coming up with a solution before we even process the words. That's exactly what Rudra did. Nonetheless, Rudra also proved himself worthy. Despite having to take the long way up, Rudra still beat Maya. But once again, Maya made his win into a loss with her fake fall.

Now let's move onto this fake fall and Rudra's response. Despite hating Maya, Rudra's first instinct was to run out to save Maya and grab onto her. But in the process, he triggered her painful memories. This is where the painful trust part comes in. While Rudra proved himself worthy of trust today, it was painful for Maya and it will be going forward because Maya still has to move on from her past. In a way though, Rudra did more than prove himself trustworthy. The way he held onto her, promised that "tumhe kuch nahi hoga", and then held (ever so briefly) when he finally did pull her up, shows that he will be there every step of the way to help Maya move on. Her past will be painful and the trust she will place in Rudra will pain her, but it will also help her to move on, to build herself again, and to forget whatever happened to her in the past.

Main jeeon ya maaron, haaron yah jeeton, what the hell do you want - For me the dialogue of the day. Rudra is starting to question everything Maya does. In the process, he's also discovering himself. Maya said she wouldn't have let him or herself die, but that's not enough for Rudra. He knows this isn't a simple test just to see if he's worth working with. This is deeper than that. And he wants his answers. But more than that, he's being drawn towards Maya as well in a web that is intricately being closed around him. With the fish selling, for Rudra it was just a simple test. Probably to see if Rudra can even sell Maya's books. But this. This test was different. What does life and death have to do with publications? Nothing. Trust does, but who tests trust like this? No. This is important to Rudra to understand. Maya has become an enigma for him. And though he says he hates her, he's also being drawn towards her.

The discarded flowers - Those flowers are just like Rishi's "love". As long as everything was beautiful and lovely, the flowers were in his hands and ready to be Maya's. But the moment, it came on Rishi's own life, they became worthless and discarded. In fact, as long as they were in his hands or with him, Maya was on Rishi's mind. The moment he discarded them, he could only think about himself. That's what you expect from someone who is infatuated with another. Love is what Rudra did. Putting his own life at risk to save his love (of course, Maya isn't his love in this case, but you get the point). As the story progresses, this will be important because Rudra will be the type to step up and support Maya, while Rishi will hide to save his hide.

Precap - Not any specific comment, but curious. Maya hides her discomfort when Rishi touches her (again). And, on the other hand, we get the fight sequence from the promos.

Soooooo, I am in the mood to give a lot of comments I think😆

@red - The empty trunk resonated with me more like she gathering all the moves she has made against the RoyBros and marveling at how she is successfully manipulating both of them. And of course, I agree with you that it is for keeping the spoils of war, to remind the victory of all her moves.

@blue - It seems Maya has taken up a personal hobby to not just preach to herself but preach Gita to Rudra as well. Like Krishna is preaching to Arjun on the battlefield. And was that Rudra's attempt at flirting with Maya when he says - "Mujhse dur raha nahi ja raha". 😉

@purple - Rudra's resilience was tested tonight. His character was tested tonight. And he won, and Maya's trust in her intentions and on Rudra's character won. It is the strangest thing I have noticed. Whenever Rishi loses, it is Maya's victory, but whenever Rudra wins, it is Maya's victory as well. Is it the way she is playing it or the creatives are trying to play out who is going to be Maya's partner - truly? Well, we have to see.

@brown - Rudra always has very pertinent questions, because he uses his head more than his heart. So he is kind of a challenge for Maya also. Sometimes she too gets shaken up by Rudra, which I don't think she likes.

@orange - Rishi is still a 'bachcha'. He is not evolved the way Rudra is, so I don't really blame him for anything. He is too young to understand this I think. All this is just fun and games for him. This marriage proposal thing - also looks like a stunt pulled off in impulse. Maybe he plans to dump her also - but iss baar koi aur use dump karega. I don't know how well his ego will handle that.

@green- The precap, the only thing that intrigued me is Rishi questioning Rudra, as to why he avoids having girl conversations with his dad. Did he do something wrong? That is what had my attention.

Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

@libran90

@purple - Rudra's resilience was tested tonight. His character was tested tonight. And he won, and Maya's trust in her intentions and on Rudra's character won. It is the strangest thing I have noticed. Whenever Rishi loses, it is Maya's victory, but whenever Rudra wins, it is Maya's victory as well. Is it the way she is playing it or the creatives are trying to play out who is going to be Maya's partner - truly? Well, we have to see.


This so much!! I am very intrigued why the CVs are playing it out like that. Also with the precap, I hope we see some background with MJ. I think the cvs need to slowly focus on him coz he is crucial to the plot.

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

@libran90

@purple - Rudra's resilience was tested tonight. His character was tested tonight. And he won, and Maya's trust in her intentions and on Rudra's character won. It is the strangest thing I have noticed. Whenever Rishi loses, it is Maya's victory, but whenever Rudra wins, it is Maya's victory as well. Is it the way she is playing it or the creatives are trying to play out who is going to be Maya's partner - truly? Well, we have to see.


This so much!! I am very intrigued why the CVs are playing it out like that. Also with the precap, I hope we see some background with MJ. I think the cvs need to slowly focus on him coz he is crucial to the plot.

Isn't it. It is so strange. And yes, Mrityunjay needs to come out in the fore more prominently. The focus is on Maya, Rudra, and Rishi. He actually wants to keep the "good dad" image intact, so he is not pushing it. Let something happen to any of the boys, then I guess Mrityunjay will come out in full form.

Grey-licious thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Hey Shreya ,

Loved reading your long essays


I agreed with the fact that Maya's life will be filled with both Rudra n rishi ,ok now like every coin has two sides this fact also have a two side ,first - (which I want that something like this happen) that both after knowing her truth will become part of her revenge against their own father ,more of Rudra means he will fight in front and rishi will help them both in the the back but I know that's not going to happen even though rudra hate his father but when the time would come he will choose his father over Maya and rishi he's already a daddy's boy and I think Maya ia hell bent on breaking that bond ,she wants to create a distance between MJ and rishi and somehow she has become successful in doing that


Ok the second side of coin is simple that she'll harm Rudra more and rishi less BUT she'll going to harm them both

Grey-licious thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Again agreed with the fact that he's affected with all the humiliation he faced while selling fishes ,but he tried his level best to hide his humiliated side ,which has now coming outside through anger ,


I thjnk he was also angry with the fact that because of his father's name it's all coming out ,IF he was not a Roy not MJ's son then no one would be interested in his fishy fish story and he'll not be publicly humiliated,so the main anger is on MJ only


And about Maya and fencing , fencing will be going to become THEIR game in future


I noticed that Maya's indirectly training him to become her weapon

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Grey-licious

Hey Shreya ,

Loved reading your long essays


I agreed with the fact that Maya's life will be filled with both Rudra n rishi ,ok now like every coin has two sides this fact also have a two side ,first - (which I want that something like this happen) that both after knowing her truth will become part of her revenge against their own father ,more of Rudra means he will fight in front and rishi will help them both in the the back but I know that's not going to happen even though rudra hate his father but when the time would come he will choose his father over Maya and rishi he's already a daddy's boy and I think Maya ia hell bent on breaking that bond ,she wants to create a distance between MJ and rishi and somehow she has become successful in doing that


Ok the second side of coin is simple that she'll harm Rudra more and rishi less BUT she'll going to harm them both

@bold - I also have a similar feeling about this @Grey-licious. There are chances this happens. We all can see that Mrityunjay is a doting dad bordering on obsessively controlling them. If he has any shades of Maya in S1, then there are chances Mrityunjay can even hurt his own people, to safeguard himself. Right now, Maya is the villain and Mrityunjay is the over-cautious dad. But when it will come to him, and his own people going against him, will he spare any of them? We have to see that.

parusmiley thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 5 years ago

Hi Shreya , i love to read ur analysis which will be so crystal clear 👍🏼


One point we have to notice that despite he hates maya he saved her HE Would have saved MJ too if he was in danger .. As per humanity bases so the tables will turn rishi will be her weapon he will turn full against to MJ and Rudra will be a wall for his dad until the truth comes out

Grey-licious thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Insaan ki fitrat jaanni ho toh use khatre Mai daldo,wo apni Jaan bachayega ya Apne andar k Insaan Ko

And this is what Maya did ,she threw both brothers in danger ....one saved the human inside him who thinks that every live matter ,even though if you don't like the person but you can't let that person die.


And rishi did the opposite for him ,his life only matters - the true son of MJ .....Rudra have every trait to become like MJ


All the love shit goes to the drain when it comes to saving his life that he didn't even able to notice Maya ascending the stairs when she didn't even tried to hide her face he was only into saving his own life

and it's like Maya knew their traits but just want to confirm it before she take her next step towards her revenge

Grey-licious thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: libran90

@bold - I also have a similar feeling about this @Grey-licious. There are chances this happens. We all can see that Mrityunjay is a doting dad bordering on obsessively controlling them. If he has any shades of Maya in S1, then there are chances Mrityunjay can even hurt his own people, to safeguard himself. Right now, Maya is the villain and Mrityunjay is the over-cautious dad. But when it will come to him, and his own people going against him, will he spare any of them? We have to see that.

Or maybe he'll drop all his weapon seeing his own sons standing against him ...

libran90 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 5 years ago

Originally posted by: Grey-licious

Or maybe he'll drop all his weapon seeing his own sons standing against him ...

I don't think so.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".