Daily soap discussion - Page 108

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

59.9k

Users

46

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

ronitfan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: padmakka

Any thing and everything is romanticized....by soap watchers... I am amazed..no one asks any questions..no wonder Ekta rules the roost.



I knew someone would 'notice' tihs ..
Well, asking questions takes out the fun out of watching it !

Anyways, you are welcome to ask Qs too .. there are a LOT of sane people on the
forum too !
Micron thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: soap-critic



And finally, I am trying to relate the events with the help of some symbolism. In yesterday's episode when DM gets the ghee in the diya and passes it on to Santu with the mantra playing in the back ground they show their hands passing the diya with Hiten' face in the middle looking at them. The symbolism I see is that Hiten is DM's eldest son and hence the ghar ka chiraag. With DM giving the diya and Santu taking it is like he is giving it to her to look after/protect it. Hope I have made sense.

Hence, it will be Santu saving and protecting Hiten. Just how she does it remains to be seen.



thank u all for the wonderful analysis/discetion...i know i am late in the discussion but...

soap-critic ji i loved ur analogy....seems like that scene makes sense now with hiten coming in between santu and DM with diya being passed on 👏👏 ...hope all this emotional atyaachaar brings hiten,baa close to santu😊

looks like the creatives/writers are actually thinking 😉 and RR is an amazing director👏
padmakka thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
1.how can anyone talk so blatantly about caste..and get away with it..how can Ekta be allowed to be politically so incorrect. Bandini fans will argue It happens in India...If it happens...there are sane people who oppose it too... Ekta has a moral responsibility to show it as a social evil ...she should not be so casual about it.Here everybody talks so casually about neech jathi ki ladki...not one character even blinks..forget about opposing it. Even when hitesh sees santo for the first time.he asks if she is a new servant why lock her in?..motiben says neech jati ki hai na isliye..He could not careless..a normal reaction for any one in his place is to be appalled..instead he is a self centered rich kid..who whines that father has no time for him and his siblings...himself has no compassion for for fellow humans leave alone animals..wow what a character and we the viewers full of sympathy for him.

2.RR acts well. But DM is a feudal charater..again Ekta is not bothered about any kanoon...DM can impose a capital punishment.??? we all go ga ga about his display of emotions in that scene...
He started off as ruthless business man..who will do anything to protect his business and his family...for no apparent reason he transforms into a Mahan person..trying to do justice through a badly conducted trial

my aim is not to spoil you people's fun...but i am appalled that such badly written insensitive script...far fetched story line is appreciated and romanticized ..!?!?

Edited by padmakka - 16 years ago
139271 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
I had posted this in the thread Hamirabi's code- an eye for an eye.. i am posting it here also.
two possibilities i think is tht
when Hiten says tht what Mongi said was true but... and DM cuts him off, which later pissed off Hiten, and he remained silent when DM again gave him a chance to say something. I feel tht Hiten tried to use the cow and after maybe one or two tries he might have realized tht the cow was no help, so he might have released the cow and used other means to pull his car out of the ditch and drove away... and I guess when Hiten left the cow was very much alive... and a person might have witnessed the whole scene and recognized Hiten and might have assumed tht Mongi recognized Hiten (or they wud easily point a finger at DM or one of his family members as not many seems to have a car there except for DM and his family) so the time after Hiten left and the villagers came, he might have killed the cow and left knowing full well tht an investigation will follow and it might lead to Hiten or DM's family 'coz of the car.
or another possibility is tht the killing of the cow is not to create problems for DM or Hiten, but for Nanaji... remember how DM had bashed Jagmohan for threatening Nanaji, so Jagmohan might have killed the cow to take revenge on Nanaji or Santo knowing full well what manjari is to them.
i strongly feel the Nanaji angle is what had happened... wht do u guys feel?
~Wicked~ thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

I am one of the INSANE, IMPRACTICAL, ILLOGICAL and romantic members of this forum 😳 . I like it this way only 😳, cause, this serial is purely for my enjoyment. I don't want to ask questions, to poke and prode too much for answers. Its nothing to do with Ekta or any other producers, its simply me. Life for me, gives me enough questions to ask and enough answers to demand. For my entertainment I just expect pure bliss, in the form of ☺️. 🤣, yes I am quite insane 🤣.

pksanam thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
some good points padma.. and i am a bit saner than our Tabs ji.. lol..
well, what you are saying is quite true about the caste system.. but that is what the drama is based on.. not meant as a preaching but to tell a story about that difference.. and i don't know if you are aware or not, but it is based on a novel called 'ret pankhi'.. so it's hard to take too many cinematic liberties.. as you said, Hiten could have been appalled.. but that is not the essence of this particular show.. it is to show that how two people who are world apart, i.e. DM and Santo and thrown together in a situation, i.e. their marriage, and how they deal with it.. quite simple as that.. and just because we all love this show, doesn't automatically translate into that we love this caste difference or are not appalled by it.. but that is what the show is all about and with the story progressing, these differences will subside.. but if you expect it in couple weeks, well, that's wishful thinking.. lol.. and as Tabs ji said, we can't keep dissecting every single moment and social issues brought up.. but purpose is to show people that such things exist and to create awareness, the purpose is not for people to accept such things.. viewers are considered to be more intelligent than that..!
he whines this way because he has been brought up that way.. and to him, these are quite normal circumstances.. nothing that unusual.. so why would he react otherwise.. we as viewers have sympathy for him because he is innocent in the matter, because we don't think he is guilty.. not because we think it's okay to kill animals.. maybe you should read the entire thread and the discussions before making this conclusion.. sorry but i had to mention it..
DM runs the town and they have a panchaayat system.. as it happens in most of the villages.. they don't have the court systems and all that.. if it was based on a city and they showed these things, it would seem quite ridiculous.. but the settings are different altogether, so to expect something else is kinda foolish.. he has build the town and has done a lot for his people.. again, you should read the entire thread before jumping to the conclusion that all of us approve of his capital punishment.. because we had a whole discussion about that.. and again, i should remind you of the village setting..
[my aim is not to spoil you people's fun...but i am appalled that such badly written insensitive script...far fetched story line is appreciated and romanticized ..!?!?]
well, then.. perhaps this is not the show for you..? lol.. or you should have some patience.. i'm sure Ekta is not stupid to make the same mistakes she has done in the past.. so give her some time.. these issues are going to get touched upon, but not so soon, is my feeling..
btw, welcome to the forum.. i am sanam.. i try to be as sane as i can.. 😆
Edited by pksanam - 16 years ago
pksanam thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: kuku..

I had posted this in the thread Hamirabi's code- an eye for an eye.. i am posting it here also.
two possibilities i think is tht
when Hiten says tht what Mongi said was true but... and DM cuts him off, which later pissed off Hiten, and he remained silent when DM again gave him a chance to say something. I feel tht Hiten tried to use the cow and after maybe one or two tries he might have realized tht the cow was no help, so he might have released the cow and used other means to pull his car out of the ditch and drove away... and I guess when Hiten left the cow was very much alive... and a person might have witnessed the whole scene and recognized Hiten and might have assumed tht Mongi recognized Hiten (or they wud easily point a finger at DM or one of his family members as not many seems to have a car there except for DM and his family) so the time after Hiten left and the villagers came, he might have killed the cow and left knowing full well tht an investigation will follow and it might lead to Hiten or DM's family 'coz of the car.
or another possibility is tht the killing of the cow is not to create problems for DM or Hiten, but for Nanaji... remember how DM had bashed Jagmohan for threatening Nanaji, so Jagmohan might have killed the cow to take revenge on Nanaji or Santo knowing full well what manjari is to them.
i strongly feel the Nanaji angle is what had happened... wht do u guys feel?

yes kuku, as i had mentioned earlier even.. it was quite the clash of egos to say the least.. and i doubt Hiten is guilty.. he's too much of an egoist to say anything when he was given a chance because earlier he was cut off when he wanted to say something.. someone is definitely trying to take advantage of the situation and my strong feeling is that it's Jaggu.. he's mysteriously been missing in action lately.. so i'm sure he's definitely up to something.. he's not the one to sit quite after what happened with DM and Nanaji.. he's bound to come back for revenge..!
padmakka thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

I agree with you this show is not for me and also this forum




Originally posted by: pksanam

some good points padma.. and i am a bit saner than our Tabs ji.. lol..

well, what you are saying is quite true about the caste system.. but that is what the drama is based on.. not meant as a preaching but to tell a story about that difference.. and i don't know if you are aware or not, but it is based on a novel called 'ret pankhi'.. so it's hard to take too many cinematic liberties.. as you said, Hiten could have been appalled.. but that is not the essence of this particular show.. it is to show that how two people who are world apart, i.e. DM and Santo and thrown together in a situation, i.e. their marriage, and how they deal with it.. quite simple as that.. and just because we all love this show, doesn't automatically translate into that we love this caste difference or are not appalled by it.. but that is what the show is all about and with the story progressing, these differences will subside.. but if you expect it in couple weeks, well, that's wishful thinking.. lol.. and as Tabs ji said, we can't keep dissecting every single moment and social issues brought up.. but purpose is to show people that such things exist and to create awareness, the purpose is not for people to accept such things.. viewers are considered to be more intelligent than that..!


he whines this way because he has been brought up that way.. and to him, these are quite normal circumstances.. nothing that unusual.. so why would he react otherwise.. we as viewers have sympathy for him because he is innocent in the matter, because we don't think he is guilty.. not because we think it's okay to kill animals.. maybe you should read the entire thread and the discussions before making this conclusion.. sorry but i had to mention it..


DM runs the town and they have a panchaayat system.. as it happens in most of the villages.. they don't have the court systems and all that.. if it was based on a city and they showed these things, it would seem quite ridiculous.. but the settings are different altogether, so to expect something else is kinda foolish.. he has build the town and has done a lot for his people.. again, you should read the entire thread before jumping to the conclusion that all of us approve of his capital punishment.. because we had a whole discussion about that.. and again, i should remind you of the village setting..


[my aim is not to spoil you people's fun...but i am appalled that such badly written insensitive script...far fetched story line is appreciated and romanticized ..!?!?]


well, then.. perhaps this is not the show for you..? lol.. or you should have some patience.. i'm sure Ekta is not stupid to make the same mistakes she has done in the past.. so give her some time.. these issues are going to get touched upon, but not so soon, is my feeling..


btw, welcome to the forum.. i am sanam.. i try to be as sane as i can.. 😆

pksanam thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: padmakka

I agree with you this show is not for me and also this forum

i'm sorry.. looks like i have offended you.. 😭😭
feel free to discuss here.. not all of us have to gush over.. we need some change too and be brought back to our senses.. btw, there is a great post by Opti.. which touches upon many of the points you raised here.. 😳😳
padmakka thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
No no not at all..I am not at all offended by you sanam...we will never be able to agree with each other.
There is no point.. you all have fun...


Originally posted by: pksanam



i'm sorry.. looks like i have offended you.. 😭😭


feel free to discuss here.. not all of us have to gush over.. we need some change too and be brought back to our senses.. btw, there is a great post by Opti.. which touches upon many of the points you raised here.. 😳😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".