Mass murder on 'Balika Vadhu' for 15-year time leap - Page 5

Originally posted by: Nandini30

The writer is lying it would s his story to kill shiv make anandi stay at her ex s house it is all his wish to force anandi in Jagya s life on a single chance. Jhalra story is his own creation Anant s love story is his brain child. He went for promo in 2000 epuside. Since his story failed he was shown doors natural if you cannot perform your company ask you to move on.
Eight years is a long time to smash your creativity.
I am happy dadisa is dying I cannot tolerate that charecter she has full list of crime she deserves it. Anandi is charecter who is a very bad example of divorced woman she was good till her second marriage after that her principles were rotten.
If the old writer and director continued then probably we would have seen anandi have some few men coming in her journey with her constant ex husband giving him company.
Party time for me 👏 ds no more.

Even before the leap few news articles had mentioned that the story isn't going according to Pushkar Shekhar's demand! The unnecessary twists and turns were not something he wanted in his story!
I can only say that Gajra Kottary is far from innocent! She may say that the story isn't going according to her demand but the fact remains that she was one of the writers to spoil the story! Wasn't she the one who tried to justify Ganga's less screen and story time by saying that they need to give screen time to side characters too? Wasn't she the same writer who, at first, justified Shiv's death as the only way for Anandi's empowerment but then changed her statement by tweeting that if it was in her hands Shiv would have never died?

Originally posted by: libsrocks

Even before the leap few news articles had mentioned that the story isn't going according to Pushkar Shekhar's demand! The unnecessary twists and turns were not something he wanted in his story!
I can only say that Gajra Kottary is far from innocent! She may say that the story isn't going according to her demand but the fact remains that she was one of the writers to spoil the story! Wasn't she the one who tried to justify Ganga's less screen and story time by saying that they need to give screen time to side characters too? Wasn't she the same writer who, at first, justified Shiv's death as the only way for Anandi's empowerment but then changed her statement by tweeting that if it was in her hands Shiv would have never died?

Yes I agree that gajra is also part of this she is also responsible.
Problem with mr Sekhar is as a creative he loves Jagya n anandi n dadisa. So he always wanted to have Jagan reunion. Marraige to shiv is forced on his wish which is not according to his script. He always wanted anandi at bh so he forced anandi in all bh tracks. Post leap they had full plan of anandi n Jagya reunion and Ganga s Jalan which did not happen then they brought Anant which also did not happen.
So these were the causes of creative diff between two writers and director.

Originally posted by: libsrocks

Even before the leap few news articles had mentioned that the story isn't going according to Pushkar Shekhar's demand! The unnecessary twists and turns were not something he wanted in his story!
I can only say that Gajra Kottary is far from innocent! She may say that the story isn't going according to her demand but the fact remains that she was one of the writers to spoil the story! Wasn't she the one who tried to justify Ganga's less screen and story time by saying that they need to give screen time to side characters too? Wasn't she the same writer who, at first, justified Shiv's death as the only way for Anandi's empowerment but then changed her statement by tweeting that if it was in her hands Shiv would have never died?

libs i equally hold Mr PS responsible 4 this alongwid madam KK.

Originally posted by: tiny15

libs i equally hold Mr PS responsible 4 this alongwid madam KK.

he'd said in one of his IV that hes obsessed wid anandi's ckt in BV.thatswhy he always concentrated on anandi & also made her involved in all BH tracks whether it was needed or not.and i m sure he wanted JaAn reunion but bcoz of viewers bashing abt glorifying bal vivah he'd 2 abandon that & introduce shiv.

and abt madam KK i agree wid u.

Yes i do remember someone in forum said that PS never wanted AnSh's marriage because the person on whom Anandi's character is based on, had never re-married anyone! Personally i feel it was collective fault of whole team of writers! They all seemed to have their own obsession with some or the other character when a show only becomes successful when we are obsessed with good story and not characters! While PS's old-school thoughts would have not made BV work after knowing Anandi had an option like Shiv to choose, other writers should have handled the story after AnSh's marriage little more wisely! Someone in writers' room seemed to have got obsessed with Saanchi!

Even I was never happy with the way they showed anandi's second marriage.

Originally posted by: Shinya

Even I was never happy with the way they showed anandi's second marriage.

A woman who was dumped by her husband should not have been forced into second marriage or even into divorce when she was clearly not over with the first marriage.

Even the day before her marriage, she said she loved jagya and that love only happens once. On her first night, she was shown thinking of jagya.

Her second marriage was a wrong social message... The message was like women do not have their own mind. Marriage is the only ultimate thing for them and whether they are ready or not, they must be forced into it by other family members.

Just hated that track.

It was mr Sekhar n Kothary s mili Bhagat they wanted anandi to love Jagya and marry shiv but they wanted to keep it open to come back to him. Mr Sekhar said that a woman always remembe her first love next were compromises.
Shiv was too good for an woman like anandi. Anandi is a vey bad example of divorced woman no divorced woman runs to her ex hubby after marraige. Basically the writers make her cheap making her stay at bh. Given a choice they would have made anandi Anants wife as well as j s girl friend.
May be they would have shown Shivam n Nandini is out of one. Night stand of Jagya anandi

So, there are different writers, different director, a whole new cast, and the lead is someone else, but other than that it's still the same old show?

Originally posted by: Shinya

when dadisa wanted to marry off anandi, her argument was will anandi live forever in BH? (kya woh yaha puri zindagi padi rahegi? - I remember this dialogue clearly)

But by forcing her into second marriage what did she achieve?

In the end anandi was thrown back into her first sasural and she is now supposed to be living there till her end.

Better would have been if anandi had listened to dadisa and got remarried to jagya... as it is she was not in love with shiv at that time.

The story that ran for 8 years had to have disgraceful end?? 🤢

Sorry @Shinya but nothing makes me wish that Anandi has chosen Jagya over Shiv! Dadisa was wrong in her ways and AnSh's way towards re-marriage was far from ideal but Anandi had genuinely loved Shiv! She loved him and still does!

There is no point to compare AnSh with real couples or make their story an inspiration for real divorcees because men like Shiv are extremely rare and so are divorcees like Anandi. In real life, no two people as a couple can fit so well with each other. There are bound to be few differences in their outlook towards some issues or whole life. In AnSh's remarriage, Anandi could make Shiv lose his practical side and bow down to her emotional thinking with her lame reasons like she did in DB's case. In reality, a person like Shiv would not have bow down to his wife's wishes if he considers the old lady a danger to his household. In my opinion, everything seemed to immediately click between Shiv and Anandi. They agreed with all ideas of each other! In real life, it takes few misunderstanding and quiet some time for couples to know each other as well as AnSh did.
Like pretty much everything about Anandi, her second marriage was far more ideal to look realistic or something one can apply in real life. It was simply a beautiful fairy tale that connected with viewers! Nothing less, nothing more!
This reminds me that once Anandi had told her mother that every girl's dooli comes to her in-laws' house and only her aarthi goes from there! Now let's see where does Anandi choose to go from? BH or KB? Technically, she should chose KB as she would die as Shiv's widow but CVs will make her exit from BH as 'kacchi Umar ke Pakke Rishte' is their theme!