Some questions - Page 14

Created

Last reply

Replies

171

Views

8.1k

Users

24

Likes

484

Frequent Posters

kate-nic thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
Yes MLA sahab has another way of income too From his hospital It has been shown in serial seeing the standard of hospital ,rich people at least who are familiar with Jagya get their patients treated from the hospital Mostly ministers Jagya was telling Ganga about some minister wanting to get his wife operated from their hospital Of course minister ji is going to pay not going to treat his wife on charity The hospital is free for only poor not rich
Too bad some winking people before cracking jokes on Jagya did not think before leaping 😆
Edited by kate-nic - 9 years ago
tiny15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: saba113

People don't have time to worry about a pathetic character like Anandi People have much more things to worry and care about in their real lives but this is a public forum where we come to share our opinions about an entertainment It is too much to defend a flawed fictional character some fans start attacking the real persons 🥱

saba agree that ppl like us don't've time 2 worry a pathetic & disgusting ckt like A bcoz we've more things 2 worry & care abt in real life. but few ppl hav time 2 worry abt a pathetic ckt like A thatshwy in her defense they wrote long essays even if sum1'd only posted 1 or 2 or few lines of critiicsm.
Edited by tiny15 - 9 years ago
fast trak thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: saba113

People don't have time to worry about a pathetic character like Anandi People have much more things to worry and care about in their real lives but this is a public forum where we come to share our opinions about an Entertainment Program It is too much to defend a flawed fictional character some fans start attacking the real persons 🥱


It's sad that sometimes people can't differentiate between real and reel.
But it's utterly wrong to say that people don't have time to write about Anandi. Not just her supporters there are so many posts criticising her as well. What does that mean?😆

It's not just Anandi or anything people enjoy the show and it's turning points and hence so many posts on likes and dislikes of character. If someone says they don't enjoy the show then there's not much point in just coming to criticise anyone here. It's a free forum but in order to raise points there needs to be some supporting statements
leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
Kuch to log kahenge. Logonka kaam hai kehna.

And there is a famous Aesop's fable about father and son and their donkey. And how they had to carry their donkey and then also they were not spared.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
The question is on whose money ShivNiketan is being run.
Shiv Niketan - is obviously running on donations made probably Singhs and Shekhars initially and after that Anandi spent 11 years building up the place.

Anandi is the principal of the school - that title is clear enough.

Projects - Anandi and Jagya seem to be collaborating on some project which they did not name that too because he is an MLA and she is social worker - more because of their professional association.

Dsa doesn't take decisions and it is clear that Anandi takes the decisions regarding running the place.That's what has been shown. Anandi and Dsa work as a team. They discuss things .Dsa is part of SN because she wanted to be part of Anandi's work and not because she put in money in that.After all she put in money in Basant Niketan and Hospital too.But was she involved in running those things?


Anandi did go to meet the education minister/hrd minister with her child bride rehabilitation project.That's the time Shivam fell and hurt himself.

Shiv Niketan cannot be run on anyone's personal funds indefinitely.So it is obvious that she is generating funds through donations from society.

As for Anandi's finances -It can very logically concluded that she is living off the investments made from Shekhar property considering the money that real estate generates. She knows the value of financial independence and how important it is to know how to manage one's finances.When she could teach Bhaili women how is it being assumed that she doesn't know how to manage her own finances?


Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: saba113




I am not making issue of she is taking help from DS and Jagya . The people who have issue is that Anandi so far has not earned anything on her own ts only her rich relatives supporting her financially so far so Anandi is not a strong single independent woman the way cvs claim This is the issue of some people here as much as I have understood


Well said Saba. That's precisely the issue, that Anandi has not earned any inch for herself, but instead reduced the pools of her rich relatives.
Whether SN runs with Shekhars money or Singhs or a combination, it is definitely not Anandi's self-earned contribution. Neither can she can generate any funds out of her work at SN, which is an important and basic necessity of a Single mother who has two school-going kids to raise.

Makers have failed to show that Anandi can stand on her own.

Running an NGO is a great attribute, but it is meaningless, if one does charity without ensuring of their day-to-day income or financial future. Even if she gets donations for her school, it's not like, she got all the funds / donations on the first day itself. So how did SN arise?

If makers could show how SN came to existence, what Anandi did with KB or Far house, how she intends to secure Shivam - Nandini's future financially, it would have been great. Because generating and maintaining finances is an equal priority of single mothers, which makers failed to show through Anandi.



Edited by Missesha - 9 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
There are many full time social workers who run NGOs.
Running NGO involves designing projects which are aimed at meeting the goals they have set Implementing them evaluating them generating funds those projects meeting sponsors.It is atime consuming work.
They are supported by their families and spouses.
I know someone who runs NGO which he started.His wife is teacher in govt aided school. The expenses of running the household are borne by her.

This is real life.The said couple are as middle class as the middle class can be.

Anandi and her children are supported by Shekharfamily funds and what ever Shiv had left for her and their children.Anandi had been shown to be aware of managing finances through Bhaili.Why it is being assumed that she doesn't know how to invest money and make it grow to meet her personal expenses?






Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago

Originally posted by: aparnauma

There are many full time social workers who run NGOs.

Running NGO involves designing projects which are aimed at meeting the goals they have set Implementing them evaluating them generating funds those projects meeting sponsors.It is atime consuming work.
They are supported by their families and spouses.
I know someone who runs NGO which he started.His wife is teacher in govt aided school. The expenses of running the household are borne by her.

This is real life.The said couple are as middle class as the middle class can be.

Anandi and her children are supported by Shekharfamily funds and what ever Shiv had left for her and their children.Anandi had been shown to be aware of managing finances through Bhaili.Why it is being assumed that she doesn't know how to invest money and make it grow to meet her personal expenses?



@ bold:
From the way I perceive the show and understand Anandi's character / life style / background, I don't really think she knows how to set priorities in life (including financial priorities).

She lives a happy-go- lucky (unlucky) kind of a life, and is quite blessed to live among rich families which covers up for her flaws. Therefore I do not trust her abilities.

Makers really haven't shown well thought logical decisions taken by Anandi, especially post AnSh marriage.

I would like to see a sensible and meaningful track for Anandi, where in it's her decision and her credits.

This Anandi here is a poor example of "strong independent women". Both emotionally and financially

My conclusions for Anandi are based on my perceptions of what a Single Independent Woman/ Mother does; and we can agree to disagree here. I don't see much point in answering the same questions over and over again.

Edited by Missesha - 9 years ago
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
Did someone decide that she should get educated?
She made her own decision to resume het education irrespective of what Dsa or J thought.She did it for herself.

If she can others help earn money she is very well capable of doing it for herself if necessary.
Here her husband and his family have made provision for Anandi and the Shekhar heirs.

The show is focusing on social evils and how backward thinking members can be a source of continuing with barbaric traditions like child marriage and subjugation of girlchild and her rights.
It was told at the beginning of the leap that Anandi is now a human rights activist..Itis obvious that the CVs want to focus on social causes and Anandi fighting against them.

That is the story they want to tell a story ofa woman who will continue to fight againstthe atrocities against girl child and women a woman who doesn't let her personal losses like losing her husband losing a child stop her from standing up for justice. Sh may feel at loss in her life but will not stop doing what she believes in.

They have already shown through Harki and Mangala how having no education and having no knowledge of managing their finances make them dependent on others.

Anandi and her family has come a long way from all that.Anandi's family provided for her and her children and Anandi has the knowledge that will help her manage her funds.







Edited by aparnauma - 9 years ago
hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago

In our posts it is very clearly told in which episode she has told that she is going to meet the minister. That time Shivam got hurt when she went to meet the minister. When people claims they watches selectively how will they see it.

And definitely I am watching the actual version of BV and I dont watch selectively, even when I didnt like Sanchi, DB and when I hated J. I watched all the episodes religiiously.

If its about commo0n sense then common sense has to be applied for every case. When it is no where shown she is taking financial help from Singhs why do I assume that. People can also stay in their fantasy world just they way they preach others.

Thru Bhaili she has arranged earnings for those ladies. She is working in Bhaili too, So she must be taking salary. She can even take salary as a principal of SN, If she is not there as principal then she have to appoint someone as principal and that person would have taken salary. She is eligible to be the principal so she is working as a principal and must be getting some salary.who knows?She must be generating funds from Government. When those cant be assumed why should we assume that she is taking financial help from Singhs?

If DS is administrative head , does that mean she is financing N?

Yes she came to J with project file. She would have met any other MLA if its not J . Here she has an advantage that J is like family to her . NGO 's work like this only. But that does not mean she is taking financial help from him.

Even Shekhars used to contribute in Ananthashram, so Singhs can also do so. Many does that , to save tax apart from having good intention.

Her family supports her because they think she is doing something good for others, not because she asked any financial help or needs that. Atleast it has not shown in any version of BV.

When those things were not shown in details, why just to bash Anandi only negative things will be assumed?

And as an independent single mother, it is still easy to manage and generate money for herself and her kids but very few can help others/society apart from managing their own finances.


Why her husband's money cant be used.? And if that is the case, what great has J done.? He got bani banayi hospital which was already running by Lal Singh .

He got elected because he was DS's pota and in Jaitsar there is no one royal family like Singhs. So he is continuing being MLA.

We are very much in reality and understand the story very well


Edited by hisusmita - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".