I dont want another anandi

leavesandwaves thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
One anandi is enough.

Dont make Nimboli another anandi.


Created

Last reply

Replies

31

Views

3.6k

Users

12

Likes

93

Frequent Posters

1013962 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#2
Do you have a choice watch it or leave it.
But what is the use of showing bad effects of balika vadhu ultimately nandini will become beti of akhere singh and she will return to them as a widow.
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#3
We don't want another Anandi nor we do we want Nandini's life to end up the same way as Anandi's
But the CVs and teh channel seem to be INCAPABLE OF coming up with anything different😛🤢🥱


Hoping that viewers teach the channel CVs of BV as well as the PH some lessons which they will never forget😈
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#4
Repetition of story can never be interesting. Anandi is the only Anandi - her daughter can never be Anandi - if her life, her situation and her behaviour is exactly like Anandi - it will be unbelievable. Looks like they cannot think anything else. Why not we give them some ideas?
If they wanted Nandini kidnap - it would have been easy if she was kidnapped in some realistic situation - like Anandi or any other family member taking her to hospital/market/walking her in stroller etc. and someone snatches the baby suddenly and disappear taking advantage of crowd. If they wanted child marriage of Nandini - they could show the Akhera Singh kidnapped the girl but they got scared that they will be caught because people know that they have kidnapped the child. They abandon the baby at some desolate place to get rid of her. Some childless couple passing through the place (but not living there) spot her (too much coincidence, but still better than what they did show) and take her home like their own daughter. Police succeed catching Akhera Singh, but cannot trace the baby because he only knows where he abandoned the baby - those who found her cannot be traced because they do not live in vicinity. That couple believe in age old child marriage custom - they do marriage of Nandini, but brought up her with love and care. Her in-laws are also normal family and the child marriage is like any other child marriage - like Bhago and Khajan, like Bhairo and Sumitra like Lal Singh and his wife. (bal-vivah is not always like child labour and torture - but it does stall education of child bride, early pregnancy and undernourishment of mother and child. Creatives never show real face of bal-vivah - not all in-laws are monstrous.)

This way even if it is bal-vivah, Anandi's story is not repeated. Let Anandi find her girl at age 11. Naturally, the girl would want to remain with the only parents she knew all along. Kacchi Umar ke pakke rishte. Show the struggle of Anandi to get her child back - more importantly to give her education.

Other members can also think of different ideas - all of them will be better than the story we will get to see. Who knows, some of the ideas get incorporated in the serial - like they did not show Anandi bal-vivah flash-back.

Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#5
@Spuja
They will follow our ideas only if its suits them and doesn't affect their grand plans ahead. Otherwise the forum gives loads of good ideas better than the CVs for sure.
Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Nandini30

Do you have a choice watch it or leave it.

But what is the use of showing bad effects of balika vadhu ultimately nandini will become beti of akhere singh and she will return to them as a widow.

Oh this is so not fair to the CVs
You leaked the serial story for the next 6 years

Chahat_A_Doshi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: SPuja

Repetition of story can never be interesting. Anandi is the only Anandi - her daughter can never be Anandi - if her life, her situation and her behaviour is exactly like Anandi - it will be unbelievable. Looks like they cannot think anything else. Why not we give them some ideas?

If they wanted Nandini kidnap - it would have been easy if she was kidnapped in some realistic situation - like Anandi or any other family member taking her to hospital/market/walking her in stroller etc. and someone snatches the baby suddenly and disappear taking advantage of crowd. If they wanted child marriage of Nandini - they could show the Akhera Singh kidnapped the girl but they got scared that they will be caught because people know that they have kidnapped the child. They abandon the baby at some desolate place to get rid of her. Some childless couple passing through the place (but not living there) spot her (too much coincidence, but still better than what they did show) and take her home like their own daughter. Police succeed catching Akhera Singh, but cannot trace the baby because he only knows where he abandoned the baby - those who found her cannot be traced because they do not live in vicinity. That couple believe in age old child marriage custom - they do marriage of Nandini, but brought up her with love and care. Her in-laws are also normal family and the child marriage is like any other child marriage - like Bhago and Khajan, like Bhairo and Sumitra like Lal Singh and his wife. (bal-vivah is not always like child labour and torture - but it does stall education of child bride, early pregnancy and undernourishment of mother and child. Creatives never show real face of bal-vivah - not all in-laws are monstrous.)

This way even if it is bal-vivah, Anandi's story is not repeated. Let Anandi find her girl at age 11. Naturally, the girl would want to remain with the only parents she knew all along. Kacchi Umar ke pakke rishte. Show the struggle of Anandi to get her child back - more importantly to give her education.

Other members can also think of different ideas - all of them will be better than the story we will get to see. Who knows, some of the ideas get incorporated in the serial - like they did not show Anandi bal-vivah flash-back.

But the show is about how bad Bal Vivah is
So they will have to show all the ill effects of it

Nandini can never be Anandi and the makers should not sell us the old story in a new packet
but the makers will sell us the old story in a new packet

Sunna_Deewani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Chahanya

[

But the show is about how bad Bal Vivah is
So they will have to show all the ill effects of it

Nandini can never be Anandi and the makers should not sell us the old story in a new packet
but the makers will sell us the old story in a new packet

Does that mean CVs think Bal vivah is bad only if saasre wale are bad? Say if BH of earlier times had only Bhairon and sumitra like ppl & Jagya also without any flaw then Bal vivah is best😕
jayshree1942 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#9
Agree with Sunna
Actually bv people say if anything goes wrong then balvivah is wrong.

otherwise no problem in balvivah.

Basically the balvivah effect they shown with Sugana was fantastic and realistic .

Even with anandi they show another problem that husband may like other woman.

But they should have stop when anandi got her soul mate and jagya got her wife.

I think BV covered all Balvivah problem with all female leads.

Now there was not need to introduce Nimobli.

They should have ended on happy note. That balikavadhu anandi is happy with her husband doing some professional course and Jagya ganga is also happy.

And where is anandi empowerment over here. She is again shown helpless and rest of life she will spend under the protection of dadisa , where is her development?

Now what she will do , she will cook for badi haveli thats sit.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Chahanya

But the show is about how bad Bal Vivah is
So they will have to show all the ill effects of it

Nandini can never be Anandi and the makers should not sell us the old story in a new packet
but the makers will sell us the old story in a new packet


Bal-vivah is bad even if sasre wale are not bad. Of the numerous ill-effects of bal-vivah, creatives want to concentrate only on early widowhood and physical-mental torture. Does this mean if the girl does not become widow or did not suffer torture - then bal-vivah is good? In Nandini's case - she has to be nurtured for years before they can show any torture. At present - she can't even eat food independently - so unless they show wife of Akhera Singh caring for her - the story cannot be believed. And the girl will develop affection towards the woman she sees as her mother and will imbibe her mother-in-law's values. Otherwise, it will be better if they show that they hired a dhay ma to care for Anandi and from her she learns good values and she is not like her parents-in-law.

Personally, I do want somewhat role-reversal of Anandi-Jagya. Nimboli may not be the pampered brat, but get upper hand like Jagya used to made Anandi do her homework etc.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".