Why it was so important of Ganga to call Anandi? - DT Note pg7 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

85

Views

6.5k

Users

28

Likes

348

Frequent Posters

sunflower52 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: tiny15

@sunflower i got wat u wanted 2 say but u misunderstood me. i m not saying she called now & not earlier as found all roads closed.

she'd earlier 2 faced such situtn in sanchi case but didn't ask anandi or any1. she herself can think such things.
if no1 is believing her then why 2 ask anandi. wat can she do?? make them beleive her?? no she only gave that advise which ganga can herself think.
its done only 2 make ganga sum stupid & anandi sum expert.& 2 intermingle tracks or 2 show that singhs & A r not disconnected.thats our prob.

@bold i agree thatswhy i wrote "Most PPL" & not "all ppl". and ganga cums in "most PPL" as per ckt portrayal like anandi.
CVs r even stupid 2 make her call anandi wen she herself is in probs. which acc. 2 ganga's ckt won't do ever?? shes not gauri who wen sees prob of oders but still wants her 2 listen but just 2 make anandi expert they made ganga 2 call on wen shes in prob herself.
can u think ganga or anandi can call or ask such things wen oder one is in trouble if go by their basic nature which is shown in the show??


Sanchi case is different, as she is Anandi's sister in law. How can Ganga seek advice against from Anandi about her SIL.

The thing is Sanchi was shown as a brat & immature, while Shayam Lal is a shrewed, manipulative & experienced man..

Ganga was to worried and her moves were not working so her mind went blank. This happens to intelligent people too when everything is going against them and are reaching a dead end.

I do not think Ganga would have called Anandi if she was not desperate as she was seeing how her hubby & family members were falling into deeper trap of Shayam Lal.

Even she apologized to Anandi but the only mistake cv's made was that they did not make Ganga say that if Anandi needed her help she would always be there.





tiny15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: sunflower52


Sanchi case is different, as she is Anandi's sister in law. How can Ganga seek advice against from Anandi about her SIL.

The thing is Sanchi was shown as a brat & immature, while Shayam Lal is a shrewed, manipulative & experienced man..

Ganga was to worried and her moves were not working so her mind went blank. This happens to intelligent people too when everything is going against them and are reaching a dead end.

I do not think Ganga would have called Anandi if she was not desperate as she was seeing how her hubby & family members were falling into deeper trap of Shayam Lal.

Even she apologized to Anandi but the only mistake cv's made was that they did not make Ganga say that if Anandi needed her help she would always be there.





i agree wid u on sanchi & shyamlal's nature.and also that she called in desperation & every intelligent prsn's mind goes blank like u said but all i m saying there was no need 2 call.Cvs shudn't'd make her call. and it shud b 2 -sided. why not anandi's mind go blank??😆
@red i agree bcoz i think ganga is not like this that 1st she"ll call 4 help from sum1 whos already in prob & then won't say that she will also help her if A needed.
actually calling A by ganga & jagya & singhs is happening 2 much & its every now & then thatswhy we want it separate. there r oder ways 2 show singhs connection wid A or vice-versa.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#43
Seeking advice does not make a person incompetent - it is sign of a person ready to try everything to overcome a problem. That is why, I do not find anything wrong in this phone call from Ganga to Anandi. They are not competitor to make it like why Anandi does not call Ganga for her own problems - the reason perhaps lies in the fact that creatives have made Anandi the central character.
tiny15 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: SPuja

Seeking advice does not make a person incompetent - it is sign of a person ready to try everything to overcome a problem. That is why, I do not find anything wrong in this phone call from Ganga to Anandi. They are not competitor to make it like why Anandi does not call Ganga for her own problems - the reason perhaps lies in the fact that creatives have made Anandi the central character.

i m not syaing shes incompetent but CVs r trying 2 show it like this bcoz they r making it quite frequent & that 2 one-sided.even tho its not wrong but it doesn't make happy either.
but i prefer that Cvs show it 2 minimal level.
and being a central ckt doesn't mean every prsn shud seek advise from her.i know it shes central ckt & don't've any prob in it but show her expert on every issue esply related 2 singhs.in many shows central ckts r not shown in oder's tracks forcibly wen not reqd.
sunflower52 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: tiny15

i agree wid u on sanchi & shyamlal's nature.and also that she called in desperation & every intelligent prsn's mind goes blank like u said but all i m saying there was no need 2 call.Cvs shudn't'd make her call. and it shud b 2 -sided. why not anandi's mind go blank??😆

@red i agree bcoz i think ganga is not like this that 1st she"ll call 4 help from sum1 whos already in prob & then won't say that she will also help her if A needed.
actually calling A by ganga & jagya & singhs is happening 2 much & its every now & then thatswhy we want it separate. there r oder ways 2 show singhs connection wid A or vice-versa.


I know would not mind Anandi seeking help from Ganga. Would be fun to see Anandi & Ganga tackling Rasika.

Anandi can not be separated from the Singhs, she is part of their family.

The only reason Anandi has no attachment from her own parents is because she was married off at age when we begin to understand , get to know and form a bond with our parents.

Anandi is way more experienced in these type of matters, Ganga has just begun to open her wings as she was caged in her former In laws place.

As Ganga will experience more and more then she won't need to get advice from anyone.
rohini55 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#46
@Alchemist
I faintly remember that Ganga once before called up Anandi with her problems when Anandi was herself in trouble.
Was it when Anandi was being targeted by KB folks for not taking Saanchi's side on the break up with Jagya?
Ira had served an ultimatum to Anandi to keep off BH, and Ganga self-talked herself into calling Anandi.
Am I right or was it some other occasion?
If I'm wrong about this, I'm sorry but somewhere something like this happened.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: tiny15

i m not syaing shes incompetent but CVs r trying 2 show it like this bcoz they r making it quite frequent & that 2 one-sided.even tho its not wrong but it doesn't make happy either.

but i prefer that Cvs show it 2 minimal level.
and being a central ckt doesn't mean every prsn shud seek advise from her.i know it shes central ckt & don't've any prob in it but show her expert on every issue esply related 2 singhs.in many shows central ckts r not shown in oder's tracks forcibly wen not reqd.


It is not about forcing in other's track - the writer does not think it like a Ganga's track or Anandi's track - forum people may think like this. For writer - every track is part of one story. Being central character means, the story revolves round her - that is why other characters contact her, as per my understanding (I admit that I have limited experience in serials).
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: rohini55

@Alchemist

I faintly remember that Ganga once before called up Anandi with her problems when Anandi was herself in trouble.
Was it when Anandi was being targeted by KB folks for not taking Saanchi's side on the break up with Jagya?
Ira had served an ultimatum to Anandi to keep off BH, and Ganga self-talked herself into calling Anandi.
Am I right or was it some other occasion?
If I'm wrong about this, I'm sorry but somewhere something like this happened.


Perhaps you are talking about when Jagya got arrested and Ganga called Anandi to know about him.
rohini55 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#49
@spuja
Thanks. Then she was perhaps justified. What made it awkward for Anandi was that there was a cold war between KB and BH and she had been told not to talk to BH -- which was a terrible punishment for a sin did not commit.
DrMCallgari thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#50
i call it weird of Ganga calling Anandi perhaps it will be more easy to understand if we understand what is relationship equation of Ganga and Anandi ? Ganga sees Anandi as what ? when she started to look up to Anandi as friend or guide ? Ganga never mentioned ever she sees Anandi as guide or friend ?When she was not married to Jagya she referred to Jagya as her guide till she is alive Whatever he did for her , his words will be her encouragement , strength till life time even if he is not there with her Anandi was no where in it ?As i see Anandi was kind to Ganga like she has always been to victims She helped Ganga in bringing her child back to her which was a blooper Because it was not a pre planned track They created a new flashback and gave the track to Anandi but lets go forward Ganga was extremely grateful to Anandi for it Anandi gave Ganga responsibility to take care of family as long as she is there but then there are no interactions between two ? Neither Anandi called Ganga asking her anything how is her studies , how she is progressing , howz family etc Neither Ganga called Anandi for anything Ganga called Anandi when she felt she is failing in her responsibility given to her by Anandi when Jagya was attacked by Ratan Singh but Anandi's words had no impact on Ganga it was Jagya who when assured her she should not blame herself Then Ganga got consoled a bit


In between there was scene which did not make any sense why would Ganga call Anandi to ask her about Jagya's likes and dislikes ? From where Ganga concluded Anandi knows his likes even more than his parents ? As a viewer i know but Ganga ? How she concluded that ? What was her point of asking from Anandi ? She could ask it from Jagya himself ? It was kind of surprising despite cooking food at home for everyone she was unaware of what Jagya likes to eat? I feel that scene was only to give Anandi a clue who is better life partner for Jagya between Sanchi and Ganga otherwise the scene did not make any sense There is no communication between both ladies when Ganga went to Mangalore If they were friends no one of them ever called each other ? Where was this friendship ? Ganga didn't need any guidance of Anandi then now that suddenly she needs so much ?


Another scene i did n't find sense when Ganga called Anandi to know about Jagya when Sanchi put false blame on him and he was jailed ? I didn't find sense in that scene because Bhairon was already there with Jagya so why Ganga will call Anandi leaving Bhairon ? How can Anandi help her and what help she really gave to Ganga there ? Ganga could call Bhairon ?


There is no scene not any moment where Ganga really shares her heart with Anandi duirng SaJaGan times because their relationship never grew to this level ever Ganga was lonely woman who used to frequently talk to her child , share her heart with him then came a man in her life Her benefactor , her friend , her guide , her supporter later love and life partner but this new friendship with Anandi and how cvs are showing it is going over my head First it is completely one sided There is never other way around Anandi called Ganga for anything to take any help , sharing her heart with her Never but Ganga keeps calling her without any need

Neither she felt better calling Anandi when she came to know she has complications in her pregnancy she was same sad neither she acted on Anandi's words so why she called her ?when it didn't help her in either way ? To me it was just a scene to let Anandi know about Ganga's complications otherwise how did it help Ganga?


Neither yesterday it made sense to me First i don't understand why Jagya does not look into this matter for once when he knows his wife has not gone mad she will not falsely blame anyone there is something that is bothering her and he understood and even promised her he will look into this matter so what was point in calling to Anandi ?Anandi is not the only intellectual person or sounding board exists near Ganga ?I find this abrupt i am not against Anandi neither i mind their interactions but i am not understanding as why cvs try to make Anandi's guidance is needed everywhere ?Other people are so immatures ?

I am happy that at least Jagya HAS moved on Now he does not ask any help from Anandi neither ask for her guidance in anything Its only our Anandi who is so habituated to give lectures to him still lectures him without understanding she needs to stop somewhere He does not need her lectures but it is strange as to why they make Ganga needing Anandi's lectures ?Even Shiv and Jagya are like friends but they have helped each other but never really called each other because they are so confused and need each others special advises ?so why cvs make Ganga ?
Edited by jermey1 - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".