Why ganga is hated by many?? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

3.9k

Users

17

Likes

137

Frequent Posters

Picasso9 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#11
I don't know about others, but I love the way Ganga is portrayed, IMPERFECTIONS and all.

I love that she is not one dimensional like say for instance SHIV.

Cv's have shown us her SPIRIT, her MELANCHOLY, her despair, her HOPE, her LOVE, her FOCUS and her ASPIRATIONS. She has so many shades to her.

Why should she suddenly become all happy just because Rat is caught and she is divorced. She has been repeatedly raped physically, mentally and emotionally since childhood. The fact that she is moving on us a miracle and testimony in itself of her undying spirit.

Nobody in try to save her and rehabilitate her has thought of her psychological needs. Anand selfishly burdened her with taking care of Singhs. Anandi and Shiv are quick to want to save the world (read disadvantaged mahila's) but they go about it in a half asses way. What about counseling for these abused women?

Crying in front of Mannu is not going to damage him but make him a better man who is more empathetic towards women. He is going to learn that it is ok for a man to cry and it is better to let out feelings than bottle them up.

Ganga has never retorted back to Sumitra because she has more class and love for her benefactors. Thus same quality will stand her in good stead when Sumitrmas entire family will eventually give her the 'I told you so' speech.


I love Ganga, imperfections and all.
NehArabella thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#12
Yeah ppl hate her coz she stayed in badi haveli for such a long time without having any relation with them, especially with Jagya...
Coz as per them "ehsaan ek hadd tak ho toh accha hota hai"
libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#13
I like Ganga...at least she didn't cried for her good for nothing husband for so long to kill the crap out of us...she brought quiet some life in BH too...and i applaud her for her smartness and bravery 👏...she is indeed very strong...ganga did not stay in BH more than she was needed or told to...she was stopped and given responsibilities to take care of Haveli like she is the bahu...she kept her self respect and left the Haveli the moment she is now not needed...CV's have shown just one flaw in Ganga and that's her total dependence on Jagya...one can see she does not need Jagya or anyone else now as much as she needed before...Ganga could have been used as a perfect character to bring back BV essence in BV...she could ahve shown Anandi and Ganga bonding over their past as Anandi hepls her in her studies adn then Ganga becoming nurse and trying to make adjsut herself to her new lfe as single mother...but in the end CV's have an habit of showing women like some weak person who cannot survived without marriage more than an year...Anandi lost her indentity and is now nothing more than a bahu who is being used as communication tool and punch bag by her in-laws and same will happen with Ganga...i never thought i would say this but many other shows are giving better progressive message (even Ekta's)...in Jee Le Zara there was an awesome dialogue by Granny to main lead that ''we did not educated Prachi (some girl in the shw) to make her lose her sense in love'' 👏...i mean look how wonderful the dialogue is...can't someone in BV see and use sense
Edited by libsrocks - 12 years ago
Jan50 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#14
Bv is not giving any progressive messages. In real life people are lot more progressive.
Singh family is too contrived. On the one and they are using all the modern gadgets, have
Access to the outside world. Rich. Such people do change in real life and . They are not ordiary
Peasants who are backward. Ok they have come up a little. But still the most important
Message should be about parenting. It is not only child marriage that is bad but parents not
Giving any importance to the feelings of their children and keep expecting them to do what
Pleases them. Most of the problems are because of that. I find all Serials whether rural or urban
Accepting and promoting male chauvinism. Very often they use the heroins as mouth piece
For that. Ganga and Anandi are no eceptions. Why should they show how Ganga is molested?
Do the cvs think people love that. Probably rapists love such scenes. Instead they could have
Shown Ganga making good friends and learning Kannada. Becoming an expert in her field.
While doing that they may show some fun and comical side.cvs have no inagiation. That is all.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#15
I don't think Ganga is hated by many in forum or in serial. In serial Sumi is against her and Sanchi obviously (because she wanted to marry J and sees Ganga as a threat), otherwise no one in serial hates her. Forum people perhaps are disappointed with the way her character progressed - everybody liked her when she left her husband and fought for her child but some like myself feel disappointed when she was living off Singhs instead of trying to take up whatever employment she could get and try to become self dependent. Even in Singh household, she bonded mainly with J and fell in love too soon. Even the choice of profession was not hers - Jagya suggested to become a nurse and she agreed, without even thinking what she wants. And now they are showing that a woman cannot live alone and she must marry to become safe - I hate this message.
redapple1 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#16
I don't think people in the forum hate her. I am just disappointed with writers for showing a woman can't stay alone. Hello not everyone who are widowed or divorced remarry. There are lot of women who raise the kids by themselves and live a better life without getting molested or raped. Yes, they do face lot of challenges just like any other woman. In yesterdays episode when Jagya told her that this all happened because she didn't take up the job in Jaipur, I was like 😲. Does it mean if she is in Jaipur she is safe. Creeps are everywhere.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#17
Ganga was not even living all alone. Her child and an old servant was living with her, but they want to show that a woman must marry to be safe. Are all married woman safe - no molestation, rape etc. can happen to married women? Ganga fought bravely and I thought what they were showing with demonstration through Anandi-Shiv, was again shown in practical through Ganga, only to discover the message that Ganga has to marry to be safe😲 .
BB6_fan thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: koolsadhu1000


Well i , for one like her as she is shown .
i would hate it if she is shown strong , confident , unemotional at this stage .
I don't want her to do the Naari is devi talks .
What is being shown is perfect . Strenght is not in not crying and bold dialogues but in actions and each action she has taken is strong

she ran away from abuse ...strong
she filed for divorce inspite of a rural mindset ...strong
she went to school ...strong
she went to Mangalore for nursing and is stepping in a new life ...strong as hell .

Now the objection is she cries and she should not do that
i say why

she has no one to talk to or share her feelings
so why should she not emote in private
does her crying affect ANY of her decisions

no

her crying makes her exactly the character CVs have in mind , someone trying to make a life , falling badly privately in love with her helper , not letting him know a thing and focussing on the goal as taught by him , vulnerable as a woman .

Simply love it and would hate it if she is turned into another Anandi coz then this story would lose its charm .


Oh WELL said and put succinctly kools!
Nice to see you here rather than @PR
I wish Dabs and the rest of the gang would migrate too!

PS= @ TM--WomaN
Edited by BB6_fan - 12 years ago
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
Jagya never meant in that direction What fault cvs shown of Ganga here decision taken in haste Haste makes waste She did not even bother to think properly about the job she got in Mangalore despite many warnings to her she rushed A person should keep his eyes , ears and brain open everywhere Ganga made a decision flowing in emotions rather than sense Jagya 's Jaipur job offer for her was secure she could take that or at least if she could not she could be careful Ganga has one big problem she is emotionally very vulnerable she ends up taking many decisions flowing in emotions This was present in her from the start Every person has a weakness Ganga has this weakness and women like Ganga always live alone in the world if cvs are showing her getting married and falling in love I don't know what crime they are doing These women also need companions as much as any other woman

Ganga 's character never left the her scope The character is going as much expected Perhaps people's thinking for her was too high She is suppose to be a goddess for them can't cry . can't love . can't think of anything else just do my career my career my career thats it which she cannot She never fell in love too soon She stayed with Singhs because they accepted her otherwise she was leaving and this is so out of serial point she only bonded with J she bonded with everyone Gehna , DS and all Falling in love was natural for her and how can she decide career on her own ? She is woman forced to grow up early than her age Her talents ,were crushed by again and again abuses of her in laws calling her useless She has been unaware of her own talents and abilities Jagya did not force her to be a nurse He appreciated her talent and showed her the path Did this make her so low and it became a sin? Don't think so

anyways for me Ganga 's character is superb Better than many female leads She is not too mahan fictional woman but a very humanistic character with her own strengths and weakness Over all she is good example for such women


ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
o please where cvs are showing Ganga has to marry for being safe ?Are we talking about Balika Vadhu serial airing on colors or some other serial ????

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".