WU for 3/8/13 Arrival of the daughter - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

88

Views

12.1k

Users

43

Likes

533

Frequent Posters

libsrocks thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: Sheetsden

Hope they say its a premature baby and need to be monitored in the hospital for few days..otherwise a heathy baby at 7th month is a big blooper. The baby girl does look too healthy for a premee😕

it says that both mother and baby needed one week observation...any premature baby would need under observation and the baby girl looks to big to even be called a newborn and even too clean 😕
KiranlovSriti thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#52
Thanks for WU. Truly enjoy the episode. Brilliant acting by Sriti Jha, Shashank Vyas you guys deserv 👏 👏 👏 the scen of Ganga's arrival lyk an angel was awsum. Ganga was nervous but also determind to save Gehnas lyf, her nervousness changed in to currouge, perfect body languge in that situation, Dr.Sab belived on her and she belived on him wat a cordination brilliant, Jagya was not there but it lukd lyk he feeling every second wat was going on the hospital...brilliant acting by othe Sriti and Shashank. And the actress playd Gehna was very good in a pregnent lady roll.
hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#53
@sidra, jaiya
🤗
dear, when did I say that they are never filmy? don't take it personally, its CVs problem, not ours. As khushi mentioned here choti anandi playing dandiya after few days of taking bullet, Anandi jumping from 2nd floor wearing ghagra😆, Shiv's entry, shiv chasing RAT , driving the car instead of police, these never happens, we laugh like anything and make fun of them in AT also, same way Ganga completeing 10th in 3 months who has studied only upto 3rd standard, khoon bhari maang, Jagya jumping like super man, becoming chapatti chor and now this one these are also filmy.
but we love this serial, even if they show this stuffs we criticize them but still we watch as the other soaps are showing more craps.
I did mentioned that I love the acting of everyone,
And Shivbabu?😉 he is now after his mission baby, he wont stop now till he succeeds, but we are loving this despo shiv.
earlier the story was to settle anandis life so shiv was shown kadak kadak collector, composed, active assertive and that time jagya was chapati chor.
now its time for jagya to settle down so he is being shown proactive, composed, and shiv is only nodding head. time will come for everyone. bn is like that . they will show everyone's track
Gehna's IVF trck is to show how mahan ganga is , and Shivs desponess is also going to lead somewhere which is going to prove how mahan anandi is. we do call them mr. and mrs. mahan.
soif some of us feel its filmy nothing wrong in it. we are biased fans, we enjoy even when our charactes are shown in this way
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#54
Thanks to all those who read that WU of mine.
I specially like to say thanks to all those who do updates on regular basis.Now I know how much trouble they all take to come up with written updates.My salutes to them.

My take on the episode

For me the problem was not about Ganga conducting the delivery with Jagya helping her through phone.This remote helping and getting things done via phone bit is vaguely familiar 😉

We do read news about a woman delivering while on a train journey some times delivering during a flight and women delivering in the fields.There the other women do help in with those deiveries.After all giving birth is a natural process.

Ganga conducting a delivery is not unrealistic but the way the CVs have come up with that scenario was unrealistic.

As for the three idiots scene even that was very filmy in my opinion.

But what was unrealistic is the way the hospital has been emptied off just because the CVs wanted to show Ganga conducting a delivery.

If only one nurse is around they could have shown her being occupied with some other emergency that came up just then instead of making that nurse sound nervous and unsure etc etc.

That nurse could have been shown to be handling an other emergency and could have come later to help Ganga.

It was very wrong on the part of the CVs to show a trained nurse being nervous about doing something she was trained to do while an untrained person shown to be going ahead and doing the same job.

I do know that just like medical students are taught to conduct deliveries even the nursing students are taught.In fact the nursing students and medical students are posted together in labour roooms While the medical students are taught how to deal with complicated pregnancies and deliveries nurses are taught how to conduct simple uncomplicated pregnancies and deliveries.In fact the students both medical and nursing are made to conduct the deliveries under supervision.
So if Jagya as an MBBS is expected to know how to conduct a delivery even a nurse is expected to conduct a delivery and should be able to assist the doctor while doing complicated cases.

--------------------
As for the performances yes Shanky Shriti Satayajith Sharma and Nivedita they were very good.In fact it is their performances which saved the day for the CVs who failed big time in the writing department for this episode.





Edited by aparnauma - 12 years ago
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#55

@sushmita... i didn't take anything personally you see i am using funny emoticons so is Jaiya 😆i never become serious on such small things 😛 if you see i am crying for MBBS doctors thats a personal matter because i am doing MBBS too unhain faltu samjhna mera dil ko chot dai ga😭😆I said in my post this whole show is filmy Everything is filmy here but close to reality thats why we love this show Child marriage of two children i knew it happens but had only seen in films before this show for me even this was filmy but I cannot call it unreal

My objections are only to those people some people not all who are fans of AnSh They call everything related to JaGan as filmy nothing close to reality but same don't call to their couple They are always WOW but JaGan are boooh filmy so some facts i showed to them too how much filmy their couple too is and My question to them why you say so ? What happened yesterday it happens in real can happen in real Women who are not even Dais , nurses , doctors , do deliveries of other women in trains, buses and i personally know an 8 pass not a dai , not a nurse , not a doctor , nothing only a mother herself she did delivery of a woman she got even shabashi from the doctor of the woman cause she became late and case couldn't hold on more so Ganga doing this yesterday that too on instructions of a doctor He guided her otherwise how she would be doing it people are calling it unreal They are literally calling it Ott , filmy , bloopery , nonsense Hadh ho gaye why this is nonsense and OTT? and some new theories came here who say an MBBS doctor cannot handle pregnant women and deliveries What ? are we kidding here😆 Jagaya is MBBS so ?He must have studied Gynaecology in MBBS and is trained to do deliveries in emergency cases He knows the process and in hospitals the great Gynaecologists usually push the practitioners the MBBS doctors to handle cases when such cases arrive MBBS doctors know what to do in such cases so what is OTT here ?

Calling yesterday's episode filmy is not my issue as films are sometimes nonsense but many a times reality but calling it OTT , unreal , cinematic liberty is my issue because nothing like that happened The 3 idiots scene was nonsense because using the power of a vacuum cleaner to pull out a baby it will suck all the blood of mother too and shake all her organs Vacuum cleaner part was so insensitive there The mother will die but yesterday's was reality even if you call it filmy yet it was close to reality in emergency cases it can happen Ganga is a grade 10 pass so what ? She is a trainee nurse and on instructions of doctor she did Here complete untrained women , uneducated women can do this then why not Ganga ? she can do it

yes we are biased fans we enjoy everything related to our couple criticize everything related to other's couple😆but here the issue is of sense and believe me had it been some other couple not JaGan i would have said same because it was a fairly sensible , realistic episode not some OTT bloopery filmy stuff
Edited by sidra08 - 12 years ago
sectoreight thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#56
For those criticising jagya for attempting a delivery when he is only MBBS...
Jagya is definitely MBBS but he has also studied two and a half years of M.S. in Mumbai. Unfortunately, he lost focus due to emotional and mental unhappiness of his personal situation and did not complete his M.S. degree and finish the last semester. He was always good at his work, but he failed his exams because he was not a good exam taker, and also in the first semester, he had Gauri's car accident to deal with (when she miscarried her first baby)... so he could not give his exams properly.
However, all doctors (male and female) are taught how to deliver a baby in MBBS course ... and also for those who remember, Jagya has delivered his neighbour's baby through C-section in Mumbai all by himself. There were heavy rains in Mumbai, and the neighbour went into early labour. At that time because of flooding, nobody could get a rickshaw or pull a car out. The neighbours in desperation came banging on the door hoping gauri was there, but only Jagya was in the home. He asked "are you particular about lady doctor only, or can I do the delivery"... they said "any doctor is okay, male or female we don't care"... then Jagya only delivered the baby and he too was massaging the mother's stomach, and then he also did C-section all by himself, with his small medical kit on hand.
ButterflyOnRose thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: aparnauma




But what was unrealistic is the way the hospital has been emptied off just because the CVs wanted to show Ganga conducting a delivery.

If only one nurse is around they could have shown her being occupied with some other emergency that came up just then instead of making that nurse sound nervous and unsure etc etc.

That nurse could have been shown to be handling an other emergency and could have come later to help Ganga.

It was very wrong on the part of the CVs to show a trained nurse being nervous about doing something she was trained to do while an untrained person shown to be going ahead and doing the same job.

I do know that just like medical students are taught to conduct deliveries even the nursing students are taught.In fact the nursing students and medical students are posted together in labour roooms While the medical students are taught how to deal with complicated pregnancies and deliveries nurses are taught how to conduct simple uncomplicated pregnancies and deliveries.In fact the students both medical and nursing are made to conduct the deliveries under supervision.
So if Jagya as an MBBS is expected to know how to conduct a delivery even a nurse is expected to conduct a delivery and should be able to assist the doctor while doing complicated cases.

--------------------
As for the performances yes Shanky Shriti Satayajith Sharma and Nivedita they were very good.In fact it is their performances which saved the day for the CVs who failed big time in the writing department for this episode.





i agree with you because initially i thought that Two emergency cases will appear simultaneously The nurse will get busy in other Ganga will be doing delivery That would have been perfect scenario The hospital was not without staff a nurse was there if you read in my post on last update i said same Two emergencies would have appeared simultaneously The nurse got busy in one and Ganga had to deal with it I agree this would have been perfect

But one fact is there There are some people who become nervous under pressure some are very confident same happened with Ganga and the nurse there The nurse became nervous without any doctor by her side under pressure handling the case all by herself Her hands started trembling but Ganga she is a confident woman Under pressure still she don't lose her presence of mind especially when it is up to save someone 's life

so this all does make sense Ganga is not ordinary woman but a trainee nurse so at the end cvs didn't mock medical profession as well its a nurse under training did so 😆

yes acting was exceptional very well done 👏The actors were superb Actors made the episode worth a watch 👏but cvs were not total failures in what they wrote They did make some sense 😆More than the all the time grosser The three idiots which was idiotic here




Edited by sidra08 - 12 years ago
sectoreight thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#58
Actually, I don't know what gehna's complications were.
But baby delivery doesn't really require so many trained people. It is a simple and natural process. Baby has to come out when it is time. It doesn't require extreme manpower etc. to do it. It Is a natural process like a bowel movement. When the poop has to come out, it will.
In olden cultures, they have the pregnant woman hang by a rope, so that the baby can slip out due to gravity and they would catch the baby on a pillow as it fell out. This was purely due to gravity. 😆😆
Only nowadays, all this thing is there of woman lying horizontal on a bed and pushing while on her back.
Even my friend in the U.S. -- when being on her back was not working and she was too tired to push, the doctor made her get up on all fours on the table -- her positioning was that of a cat or dog on all four legs with her back towards the ceilings -- and the baby slipped out automatically.
meena678 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#59
The episode was OTT a deliberate attempt to make ganga a star they tried to copy thtee idiots but failed miserabaly and in three scene looked far more realistic and the vacum cleaner they adjusted the pressure and then used it,the whole involvement of men was something i dint like but it was a well written scene but here it was deliberate aytempt to male ganga mahaan and brave while the trained nurse who was much before ganga was shown so cowardly and made to run away ,in every hospital there was some old nurses experienced ,they could even a daima as the hospital is situated in village itself ,go close by any house and call old ladies.But cvs spoiling their show by doing such attempts ,Now we audience can predict ,just to get ganga back in badi haveli ,they created this situation.Is this show only credits ,once its ok,no story,relations depend on how much we do for others,why ganga is always above gehna and sumitra!The cvs have gone bonkers.
sectoreight thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: aparnauma

.


But what was unrealistic is the way the hospital has been emptied off just because the CVs wanted to show Ganga conducting a delivery.

If only one nurse is around they could have shown her being occupied with some other emergency that came up just then instead of making that nurse sound nervous and unsure etc etc.

That nurse could have been shown to be handling an other emergency and could have come later to help Ganga.

It was very wrong on the part of the CVs to show a trained nurse being nervous about doing something she was trained to do while an untrained person shown to be going ahead and doing the same job.

I agree that the other nurse could have been shown to attend to another sudden emergency that had cropped up -- and facing the dilemma of having to be in two places at once -- and Jagya officially assigning her to that emergency instead of gehna's delivery and assigning ganga to look after gehna.
It did look in poor form that a trained nurse was uncertain of herself.
However, I also feel that sometimes, people even with training don't function well under pressure ... and sometimes people without training also do well under pressure, because of their personality type or because of their dedication to the person (here ganga was very dedicated to taisa).
Maybe the trainee nurse had only gone through a lot of classroom simulations or practice situations when there were hundreds of doctors or trained professionals in the teaching hospital. Maybe she was only trained to assist a doctor by only following a doctor's instructions -- not necessarily using her own independent thinking processes. So without a doctor, she feels paralyzed.
Acc to what Jagya said yesterday, Ganga herself has given birth to Manu, so she has a first hand sense of what a delivery is like. In addition, she has assisted Jagya with 12 deliveries (they said that yesterday). In addition, Ganga has a personality that performs well under pressure. So overall, Ganga as an unofficial midwife may indeed have been better than the academically trained trainee nurse.
You know when the army recruits surgeons, they go through intense pressure tests ... performing surgery is one thing ... but performing surgery in a war zone with no lights, bombs exploding etc. is a different thing. And many surgeons who are brilliant in hospital operating rooms just fold under pressure when they are put in military simulation situations. They simply cant do it. It requires a different kind of personality to be a military trauma surgeon -- quick on feet, quick in thinking.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".