Perhaps Sinha has been realistic

innocentindian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#1

There is going to be a program on channel5 tonight in the UK regarding the sia-abhi attraction phenomena...So perhaps Mr. Sinha really did tackle a realistic problem...

http://www.tiscali.co.uk/entertainment/tvguide/progdetails.p hp?regionid=4&chid=49&bd=2005-09-08&bt=23:00

The Shocking Family Secret
Broadcast date/time: 08/09/2005 23:00
Duration: 60 mins
Category: None

The phenomenon of genetic sexual attraction, which occurs when adults of the same family are separated at birth and reunited years later. This documentary tells the stories of a woman who developed strong feelings for her son, a brother and sister brought together after nearly 40 years apart, and Spanish siblings who began dating after meeting in a Madrid nightclub, only to discover later they had the same parents

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

1.7k

Users

7

Frequent Posters

vazz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#2
He may have been... I did not find the Abhi-Sia infatuation unrealistic, may be because I have seen younger girls getting attracted to older men.

But here, everything happens in one family and that's what causes the overdose. I guess he cannot have different families with their problems, as the focus will not be on ... Simran, right?
chikoo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#3
Ah! perhaps Sinha took dad-daughter infatuation from such place and not his real life close experience. I wonder in the above programme in UK if they show any such co-incidence from Indian origin people 😕

innocentindian thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#4

I saw some of this program - they didn't have anyone from india...but i have no doubt it can happen in india as well as anywhere else...

The attribute it to some sort of genetic attraction taking place (sorry - it was late at night and i forget the offical wording they used)

It was intrigueing - but didn't interest me for some reason..

It was quite sad watching the program....I felt v. sorry for the people involved....This topic reminds me of another program I saw in which people that had had organ transplants suddenly began to get an aversion for things they didn't like. e.g. someone hated milk, but after the liver transplant he began to love milk - became his favourite drink..and they later found out that the person who's organ it was also had a similar liking for milk......Also other changes in personality resembling the person who's organ had been taken....so i'm sure there's more to this genetic thing than meets the eye so far....bound to be more research that brings out all sorts of wierd and wonderful things.


I can't say I liked sinha bringing in that topic into Astitva (especially as it is not a common problem in society), but at least he did not do it tastelessly or repulsivley....in his own way, he handled it well....

Edited by innocentindian - 20 years ago
vazz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: innocentindian

I can't say I liked sinha bringing in that topic into Astitva (especially as it is not a common problem in society), but at least he did not do it tastelessly or repulsivley....in his own way, he handled it well....

Well said... infatuation to older men is not uncommon in India either. It is not that I have seen this in India, I have seen students get so infatuated with professors and that gave me shivers when I was a student.

Like you said, he did not do it dis-tastefully. No matter what is said, Ajai Sinha has a style different from people and he does his point across.

Even in the Astha issue, we are able to see how bad parenting, incorrect upbringing can cause issues and are able to see things from both parties' perspective. He is not making Simran a devi and Astha a devil. He has potrayed the 'parent side' of Simran and the hurt in Astha well.

Vini thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#6

i have seen a soap here in US called Passions in which siblings have a realtionship and share a child too.
princessjojo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 20 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Vini


i have seen a soap here in US called Passions in which siblings have a realtionship and share a child too.

oh boy!! thats messed up. and quite gross. ewww!

chikoo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#8
Infact, in Hindu Marriage Act, such weddings are illegal and biologically also such kids have a significant birth defect, such as mental retardation or a genetic disorder.

Minnie thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 20 years ago
#9
Well,actually at the risk of grossly turning you all off, if any of you ever have read "Femina", the Indian woman magazines, few years back, it used to have an agony aunt column of late Pearl Padamsee. Her column used to be replete with such gross incidents.

I don't remember the exact year, but it was a late 90 isuue. There was this 17 year old girl who had lost her mother young and had got badly involved with her 42 year old dad. The worst part was, the dad himself was equally involved. It was sick to read. The girl wanted to marry her dad and had written in to ask if such marriages were allowed and how she cud make it possible....that neither she nor cud her "dad" cud bear to live without each other.......It was sick, beleive me. If any one of can look up the 90's issue of Femina & Pearl Padamsee column, U will find it.

The other two incidents that I came across was worse. The first was in Allahabad, UP, and I was in Standard 5. We had a maid who used to do our chores at 5.30 in the morn. Everyday she used to come and cry in front of my mom while doing her work.I, as a child, thought probably her husband beat her up, a very usual phenomenon among the poor in India.But when I grew up to a little understandable age, I began hearing whispers long after we moved out of there and only visited some close friends in the neighbourhood. Then when I was in 11th standard, that maid died. It was then I came to know that her husband had turned her out of her own house and had started living with their own 14 year old daughter and that was the reason she used to cry every morning in our house.....her name was Saraswati....I still get shivers when I think of that lady....my mom never likes to talk about it....perhaps beleiving if you pretend such things don't exist, they don't. I also learned that many of the ladies had thrown Saraswati out of job because they beleived her story would be a bad influence on their husbands and daughters.....she died heart broken, shunned by all...and that heartless man lived on shamelessly with the equally heartless and shameless daughter.....

The second one is right before my marriage ..... a case of incest in which the teacher mom turned her husband to the police for raping their 14 year old daughter continuously for the past 3 years....This was in a small town called Khandwa, Madhya Pradesh. It became a big story there.

So yes, the reality is these things are very much prevalant in India. Only no one chooses to talk about it.
chikoo thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#10
Well, I'm glad that such incidents are not promoted an gladly talked about. These will and can only upset you and unnecessarily set precedence.

I' m sure that by closing the eyes, you can not hide the truth.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".