Originally posted by: amukta
I think in spite of being an excellent singer she is not getting votes because she is too serious and the expressions on her face while singing is the same for all the songs.may that is the resaon she is not able to connect to aam aadmi.She shd open up a little and not look so tensed and serious and be at ease.As this is not classical singing and it is film songs she should emote more feelings and be a little more light hearted .This is my opinion and how I felt.while Aishwarya is lighthearted and is very friendly and sings her songs with a lot of ease.
well, no offense, but I've to differ with you.
First of all, i don't find her serious at all, on the contrary I find her very sincere and focused all the time. Also, I've mentioned elsewhere that she taps into the feeling of the song excellently. She looked extremely cheerful while singing the likes of Tumhari adaon pe, Ami Je Tomar, barso re megha and very poised while singing Hddcs, is mod se etc...
I think she connects to the aam admi more than anyone else...that is the reason that most of us here on IF are rooting for her success and consider her a phenomenon, I guess all of us here at IF qualify as aam admi.
As this is not classical singing and it is film songs she should emote more feelings and be a little more light hearted
Again, I don't mean to offend ....firstly, I think being classically trained is big plus for any aspiring singer...most of the great singers we have are classically trained. Secondly, being classically trained adds to the emotions doesn't hampers it.
As far as Aishwarya is concerned, I've got nothing against her... she is a great talent in her own right but how you worked out that she is more friendly and lighthearted than Anwesha, I cudn't understand.
In the end, I will just like to mention that this is meant to be a singing show and not an entertainment show.
Edited by arian_1c - 17 years ago