Anwesha never got highest votes - Why?? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

40

Views

3.5k

Users

10

Frequent Posters

Dabulls23 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: vasamv

The saddest part of these shows is that much depends on regional voting and even judges and channels encourage this.So the first reason for Anwesha not getting high votes may be this.If you accept this brutal truth it may also be a fact that another singer in another show --Bangla speaking-may be garnering votes from the region.
Secondly,voting public does not always recognize the differnce between great singing and good singing.
Anwesha,as the judges rightly pointed out last week,is "thinking" too much about her rendering.Shreya put it so nicely.
Aishwarya is an equally talented singer,but the diffence is that she has performed so many stage shows and is quite comfortable with herself in stage presentation.
Fortunately,as the format goes,both these girls may be in the finals--hopefully it will be a three-way race there and Anwesha,Aish,Prakriti may be in finals.Though,Gaj ji may not like all-girls final.
At this stage they should bring in other neutral judge or judges to decide the winner-not public voting.Say,Pt Jasraj,Ghulam Mustfa,Vishal-Shekhr,Shankar etc.Anyways,they are not getting millions of votes.Why not forgo SM in finals? Star can afford this.
Whatever the results,Anwesha has made a niche for herself in singing world.
We have also to brace up for the fact that the best rarely win--Nihira,Hema,Karunya,Abhilasha-all lost as pointed out by Varsha and others..Anwesha will be in good company--sory to sat this.

Very well said Maheshbhai 👏. All the singers you mentioned above lost due to not getting enough votes. Nihira, Hema, Karunya, Amey, ABhilasha, Abhaas, and Amanat. It has happened b4. These singers were classically trained and technically great singers too.

No one is debating on Anwesha as good singer. We all are discussing why she is not getting higest votes.

Same Q can applies to Aishwarya not getting higest votes too. Has anyone thought of that???? She has also received sarvottams and super sarvottams too.

anonmember thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Same Q can applies to Aishwarya not getting higest votes too. Has anyone thought of that???? She has also received sarvottams and super sarvottams too.



True, but I think she topped votes in one of the earlier episodes. If they're not topping votes, they shouldn't be in scaryland.
*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#23
Oh I agree that many good singers also lost in the earlier contests.. as people typically vote for all reasons other than music... Anwesha has probably survived this far just because the judges have some power in the show and want to see the best talent through till the end... But, I will tend to agree with some here that - if not the junta, the judges need to distinguish between good singing and great singing... Yes, they have given a Super Sarvottam to her more than others (she is the only one who hasnt got anything below a Sarvottam this far), but the way other singers have been hyped and praised by other gestures from the judges and the guests (and I am not talking of personal stories here) has not been done for her so far.. and some of the musically non-inclined audience does tend to get influenced by that... How I wish, this was not the case and she would have got as much, if not more, importance..
Bottomline - She is the best talent out there, she has been most consistent with great performances, and is the most deserving one.. The results have not reflected it thus far, hope to see better times ahead!
arian_1c thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

hope to see better times ahead!


hmmm...u reminded me of harry potter...dangerous times lie ahead....
but in this case I am pretty certain....great times lie ahead..😃
*Jaya* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: arian_1c


hmmm...u reminded me of harry potter...dangerous times lie ahead....
but in this case I am pretty certain....great times lie ahead..😃

Oh yes certainly...😃 And anyway, a singer of Anwesha's calibre doesnt have to win this competition to prove her singing worth.. its already proven 😛

We may see her in playback probably much before we are anticipating.. I am quite sure that her talent has not gone unnoticed by the big musical guns of Bollywood 😃

yipee thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: *Jaya*

Oh yes certainly...😃 And anyway, a singer of Anwesha's calibre doesnt have to win this competition to prove her singing worth.. its already proven 😛

We may see her in playback probably much before we are anticipating.. I am quite sure that her talent has not gone unnoticed by the big musical guns of Bollywood 😃

i agree jaya..i hope we get to listen to her very soon😃

Bhaskar.T thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: arian_1c

Just to clearify, so that there aren't any rash inferences....I remember watching Lata Ji sing Mere Khwabon mein jo (with Kajol as a guest performer) and then a dozen other songs from her repertoire that night but her facial expressions never changed and they never do, I mean singing is second nature to her and Anwesha is no different.....I mean think of Lata Ji singing and I am sure we will all picture the same thing....

I just hope now you are not putting her at par with Lataji 😉

Anyways it's time we get realistic. These shows are singing shows definitely but entertainment is a part of the show too. Unless proper packaging is done the show cannot get popularity. And low popularity means low votes for the show. Its here that result is bound to be wierd. Anvesha is definitely the best child contestant in such shows BUT after Shreya. And now she will have to pay the price of regionalism and also low popularity of the show. If she had been the lone contestant from east take it from me she would have won the contest hands down.

When did talent become the bottom for becoming the winner. The shocker will come when the show gets into 100% public voting. All thats coming soon and much more too. A big drama was created today by all these contestants today INCLUDING Anwesha. It will be out soon in the media. Hope that drama will now help the poor girl to get some extra votes.😛

avijee thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28
I think the region she belongs to are not very active in voting system. We have seen same kind of results for Pranthik Sur in VOI - Adults, and to some other participants in other shows belonging to same region.

If she loses the contest just because of poor voting, then it must be a big setback.
In today's tough competition in Bollywood, I donlt think Music composers will get attracted by Anwesha in presence of Shrya, Alka, Richa Sharma, Sunidhi etc.
arian_1c thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: Bhaskar.T

I just hope now you are not putting her at par with Lataji 😉

Anyways it's time we get realistic. These shows are singing shows definitely but entertainment is a part of the show too. Unless proper packaging is done the show cannot get popularity. And low popularity means low votes for the show. Its here that result is bound to be wierd. Anvesha is definitely the best child contestant in such shows BUT after Shreya. And now she will have to pay the price of regionalism and also low popularity of the show. If she had been the lone contestant from east take it from me she would have won the contest hands down.

When did talent become the bottom for becoming the winner. The shocker will come when the show gets into 100% public voting. All thats coming soon and much more too. A big drama was created today by all these contestants today INCLUDING Anwesha. It will be out soon in the media. Hope that drama will now help the poor girl to get some extra votes.😛

I just hope now you are not putting her at par with Lataji 😉

No I am not, I was merely trying to respond to ppl who think facial expressions are an integral part of singing.

A big drama was created today by all these contestants today INCLUDING Anwesha. It will be out soon in the media. Hope that drama will now help the poor girl to get some extra votes.😛

Hmmm...sounds like Vinit, Hemu, Himani AND Nihira walking out on Debojit...wat say...do u think you can enlighten us a bit more abt this situation Bhaskar....did I say plz

Edited by arian_1c - 17 years ago
arian_1c thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#30
Hey Bhaskar so this is wht you meant by the drama...
http://www.india-forums.com/tellybuzz/article.asp?id=1785

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".