I also agree with the fact that Abhijeet has the best musical sense among all though he is a bit short tempered n straight forward.
Alka is really controversial. If she thinks Priyani was inconsistent, how couldnt she notice tht Supriya's voice was out of sur slightly at a high pitch note in the antara???? Was she listening to the song or looking at her face? Or is she scared tht Priyani may bcome a competing singer for her in future (like Kavita Krishnamurthy has a leading edge over her bcoz of her classical base)????
Anirrudh was definitely not upto the mark..n how she can be so sure tht it was bcoz of his nervousness???
On the other hand, Priyani was very close to perfect n I think she was the best among all the singers, though I admit Aabhaas, Ira, Aanchal, Kini n Sanchari were also good.
Even Vidya was also good. It was only bcoz her voice was a bit more soft n was not suitable for stage singing. But as Abhijeet rightly pointed out her voice is more apt for recording studios.