Fatmagul DT # 5 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

75.2k

Users

26

Likes

6.9k

Frequent Posters

ngayou thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: Dloves1D

Hi @Gayu, @Defleppard and the rest,

It's actually good to look at the same situation from different perspectives. It's interesting that all of you have a POV which sounds different but underlying meaning is the same somewhere as mine.
Yes Gayu, she decided to heal herself and began trusting Kerim only after that night after crying her heart out in front of him. But again, remember, it was Meryem who suggested her to see a counsellor or at least share/write her emotions and inner turmoil with someone. It was then FG's decision to share her pain with Kerim. Like you said, it was Meryem who encouraged her to study, supported her to work and so on.
My POV is just that Meryem has always been a mother figure to her. Meryem could relate to FG, so her role in recovery has been more important, especially during the initial days of moving to Istanbul. Like Vidya explained, at that time, neither Rahmi nor MQ could understand her trauma. And Kerim was more of an enemy (from FG's POV). So, FG's last and only resort was Meryem. And we know that a woman understands another woman better. So, this is the only reason that I wrote Meryem played more pivotal role in her recovery, especially in the beginning. Kerim was always there but FG could not trust him.

PS: Defleppard, is your name Vidya? I'm still confused. Hope I didn't write wrong name. 😛



Like u said, its always good to hear different point of views on the same subject 😊. Yes, Meryem has played a big part in FG s healing definitely, i disagreed with the word "only support" that s all 😆 & she understood FG s pain more, though Mukku, being a woman too, just taunted & rubbed it in her face more & added to FG s pain 😕. Meryem was a big help at those times too 😊, she spoke up for FG against Mukku which Kerim couldnt do for obvious reasons, but otherwise everytime FG became weak & wanted to withdraw from the case, its been Kerim who consoled her & encouraged her never to give up or lose hope 😳. In fact, FG herself acknowledged Kerim s part in her life just in last week s epi when she said not to break up bcos where she d wanted to die the same time last year, now she had a reason to live & she didnt mean Meryem am sure 😆

PS: Yes Defleppard is Vidya too though i prefer calling her Dummyjii(hatke naam haina 😆)
ngayou thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: shalu79

@whiterose Agree with u...Theraphy session dubbing was done very beautifully ... loved the hindi version more than english subtitles this time...
Yaa...the Indian touches which dubbing artists giving to Yasaran club are very funny...yes most of the time its not there in original...

@Gayu @Dloves1D Agree with both of u. Meryem n Kerim both have played very important role in FG's recovery...
In initial days Meryem was big support for her...in a way Meryem presence helped Gullie to see Kerim's goodness...
But than again If FG was not married to Kerim in first place...Meryem would not be part of her life...

So, it was package deal😉😆
N the major turning point was Kerim's letter... though she was in denial for long time ...her barriers slowly started crumbling down after that...


Shalu 🤗

Evet, Meryem & Kerim package deal hain 😆, but that turning point thing hasnt been shown as yet na, spoiler dediya 😉😆
ramanika thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#43
How come evryone expect Kerim to make up with his father just because he is helping FG.What about Mr. F abandoning his son (makers gave no plausible reason) Is it so easy for Kerim to accept him in his life .well i dont think so .Even Denis the cute had become Denise the cold.Her attitude toward Kerim has changed. First Meryam then Denise ,they all shift their loylties from kerim to Fg.and poor kerim is left alone to fight his demons.
NO scene between Meryam and kerim resolving thier issues after kerim said on phone that he loves him Merym cares abt Fg moost and then Mr. Kadir ( since that night ,before that makers say kerim was her world,but that bond is no more visible.Perihan Hilmiye leman wept for their sons when they were in jail while Meryam was busy in Mr. Kadir).Maker are putting many isues under the carpet while giving undue importance to mustafa.
Wrote what i felt. Many may disagree but i am finding seaon 2 very unplanned compared to season 1. Emotional connect
is missing in season 2 .
Edited by ramanika - 8 years ago
FlawSomeME thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: shalu79

Loved reading all reviews here...Yesterday episode indeed was very very special... the scene outside court where huge crowd gathered to support FG was so powerful and encouraging... love it...

FERIM'S first counselling session together was very heart breaking n emotional... These sessions help us to understand FG n her feelings more...though earlier too FG had confessed to Halide that she is glad that Musti n family didnt support her back then...but telling all this infront of Kerim was good...(*but yeh dil maange more while talking to Halide she had said she was saved from being condemned to a life based on benefits. A life without love. Kaash she had said this too infront of Kerim)

In hindi version, FG addresses herself as "Hum" it would ve been better if she would have used "mein"...coz at a times when she includes Kerim n is saying something as "we"...in Hindi version we can't make out the difference...

@Red! Yes, and itz so much important here...waise hi FG iss show mein bahut confuse karati hai & humare translaters ne iss Hum/We siyappe se ise kuch aur increase kar diya hai + some scenes loose their essence...for example; when FG first time used "WE" for Kerim & Her-self, that was means a lot...but in hindi version, viewers didn't feel it all 😒
DefLeppard thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#45
Yes, there is an increasing fans for Deg F. Its purely based on his current behaviour. The past remains to be reconciled...if so.
Coming to Kerim, yes he has all rights to showcase his anger, frustruation & those antipathy. However IMO he should never wash his dirty linen in public...esp Kadir Killa where evil.MQ can get free feeds to use to her convience.
Man2Man is needed in a privacy...after its their problem. Others will give lip service or free suggestions.
Agree tbat Maryem- Kerim kiss n makeup scene was required. Dunno if its missed the plot or avoided by crisp editing.
*inner voice- rumour was all kiss scenes will be cut* lol
Lastly Season 1 was stronger in execution cuz the characters were few &plot was focussed.
Season 2 is a little candy floss...in terms of romance, media, family reunion & ofcourse court room scenes & therapy...and thosr many characters as well.So its seems a like too many loose ends now. But Hilal is tying them up...all redundant characters are taking exit...emin, semsi, turaner, rifaf, vural ...
Am sure we are treated for a gourmet dessert.from Gul.Muftagi!!
Enjoy!
DefLeppard thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#46
HAPPY DEEPAVALI WISHES TO ALL @FG DT
*Lights, Laugh, Love*
FlawSomeME thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: ramanika

How come evryone expect Kerim to make up with his father just because he is helping FG.What about Mr. F abandoning his son (makers gave no plausible reason) Is it so easy for Kerim to accept him in his life .well i dont think so .Even Denis the cute had become Denise the cold.Her attitude toward Kerim has changed. First Meryam then Denise ,they all shift their loylties from kerim to Fg.and poor kerim is left alone to fight his demons.

NO scene between Meryam and kerim resolving thier issues after kerim said on phone that he loves him Merym cares abt Fg moost and then Mr. Kadir ( since that night ,before that makers say kerim was her world,but that bond is no more visible.Perihan Hilmiye leman wept for their sons when they were in jail while Meryam was busy in Mr. Kadir).Maker are putting many isues under the carpet while giving undue importance to mustafa.
Wrote what i felt. Many may disagree but i am finding seaon 2 very unplanned compared to season 1. Emotional connect
is missing in season 2 .

@Black&Bold! B'coz, so is about 'What's FG fault?' not Kerim's 😛
Anyways, i agree with u at this point...where everyone supported/supporting FG for taking time to forgive Kerim, but all want super fast recovery in Kerim and his father relationship...i agree, no comprision between a lifetime bound like rape & this bound of Kerim, but still itz 19years old bound 😳

@Red! itz actually unplanned compared to season1...i do't think, makers had planed to introduce Mr.F when they made season1...and, Mustafa toh 😒
FlawSomeME thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: DefLeppard

HAPPY DEEPAVALI WISHES TO ALL @FG DT
*Lights, Laugh, Love*

Same to you, Vidya 😊

And, i just loved ur version of Judwa song for Kerim...FG is confused b'coz of Judwa Kerim, but Kerim ko toh single piece FG ne hi Maar Dala 😛
FlawSomeME thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#49
I just love hen/egg disscussn here...lol! 😛
FlawSomeME thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#50

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".