Humsafar Discussion thread-2 - Page 107

Originally posted by: ---Kaushi---

Girls like Sara actually shud not live...

I think this is too harsh to say.Sara did commit mistake(read sin) by proving an innocent woman characterless for the man who she claimed to love.
But falling in love for that man was not her fault in anyway,,love just happens.For some people it is difficult to move on from love while rest may move ahead in life.In Sara's case she was shown false hopes by that Farida woman that one day eventually Asher will marry her and when she realized it that impossible to happen she committed suicide.

Originally posted by: -Crescendo-

I think this is too harsh to say.Sara did commit mistake(read sin) by proving an innocent woman characterless for the man who she claimed to love.
But falling in love for that man was not her fault in anyway,,love just happens.For some people it is difficult to move on from love while rest may move ahead in life.In Sara's case she was shown false hopes by that Farida woman that one day eventually Asher will marry her and when she realized it that impossible to happen she committed suicide.

Originally posted by: RockChicGirl

Today's episode made me wonder only one thing-Could Sara's suicide have been avoided? While she may have not moved from Asher pre-leap...I think she had accepted he was happy with his married life. But Fareeda gave her hopes...which later led to intense disappointment.

Originally posted by: shweta_r

Maybe they could have avoided showing the suicide scene and just shown her as going to London as her mom suggested

Would have been much better this way.I condemn suicide because it is matter of cowardice.They have shown extremes here implying that what goes around is what comes around.She did probably the worst thing to Khirad and committed the same for herself.

Episode 22 is just reaching the climax with a bang to the last one
So much this episode has , but some scenes which stood out for me . I am writing what i am watching .

1- Asher,s answer to her mother when she is talking about his shaandar ( fabulous ) son . And Asher as if rubbing the salt on the wounds tells her that itas not he but she has rejected me . ( Can not stop laughing ) But that devious mind was working over time . Farida is really a Devil in disguise who does not has heart ,so has no emotions)

2- Khirad doing her packing to leave and then her talk to her daughter about her being the poor mother and all . Mhira is doing brilliant job as she is broken mother leaving he daughter behind

3- Aher when reads Khirad letter where she tells him never ever let Hareem know about her past and all that all left Asher also broken and he seems to be lost and then Khizar in the office and his only naming Khirad , Asher erupts and gives him slap . FK is always brilliant in intense scenes

4- His reading Khirad,s letter which more pushes him in to dark and guilt . All the sounds of past are echoing in his mind . As he goes on reading all becoming clear to him and that pushes him in to dark alley of guilt and his inner conscious mocking him with his own words . Both the letters were the best of this show
5 - Listening to his mother then that was the last blow to him where he could have never imagined that his own mother was the cause of ruining the innocent lives where she did not spare her own blood .

6- Moving as if is lost everything and standing near the pipe . Father Khirad all voices are muddling his mind . As if again going to suffer nervous break down
I do not have the adjectives to describe Asher,s expressions and his devastation .
Sara,s sequence was very sad ,what a waist of life and felt so sad for the mother when she asks sara what about her love? Sara has already lost interest in the life . Farida still was not least bothered that her niece is no more . So its understood that woman was devoid of any emotions , any relations .

Originally posted by: -Crescendo-

Would have been much better this way.I condemn suicide because it is matter of cowardice.They have shown extremes here implying that what goes around is what comes around.She did probably the worst thing to Khirad and committed the same for herself.

It was Farida who again took her to Asher land . She might have accepted after sometime that Asher is not hers when asher comes to her and accepts he still loves Khirad , not in plain words but she understood and then quietly leaves him saying go after taking tea. She could have come from her depression but Farida went on giving her hopes . Sara was selfish where not once she thought that what about her mother who will be alone ? Why she did not go abroad as her mother suggested ,Farida,s betrayal made her loose her mental balance .

The main highlight of Khirad's parting message to Asher was her statement going like 'aap Hareem ko uski ma ki badkirdari ke baare mat pata chalne dena warna woh kabhi sir uthake nahi jee sakegi'.
This was just piercing and hard hitting.How difficult it would have been for her to write those lines when she was anything but 'badkirdaar'.The voice modulation by Mahira was perfect there.

Needless to say Fawad aced the revelation scene.I wouldn't go on much about it because it has been beautifully said by everyone and we know what tremendous actor he is.Generally I haven't seen men crying so it was unusual but heart touching scene.Men do have emotions and perfectly enacted by Fawad who had the potential of going OTT in these emotionally charged scenes but not for once overacted.

OK !!

2nd Last Episode HS ..!! Words are less to describe Emotions,Feelings & Sheer Brilliance by FM !!

Episode 22 : whnevr I watch it , It brings Tears in my eyes .. For Khirad 😭 💔 How difficult things were fr her :( !!
& fr Asher it ws the dau to get Letters 🤣 ! On a Serious Note the way he ws missing Khirad 😔 All previous memories of The days whn he ws living the love of his life ❤️ whn they were together ... !! & Now only lonliness left fr him..!!

"Kabhi yeh haal k dono main yaq dili thi bohat
Kabhi yeh marhala k jese Ashnayo na thi..."

& Now Coming to the thing which he wanted to...BUT in this way 😭 !! Asher feelings were portrayed by FK in a Bestest way ...👍🏼 U cn feel his inner turmoil..!

Ah !! Tomorrow is the Finale ❤️

Originally posted by: -Crescendo-

The main highlight of Khirad's parting message to Asher was her statement going like 'aap Hareem ko uski ma ki badkirdari ke baare mat pata chalne dena warna woh kabhi sir uthake nahi jee sakegi'.
This was just piercing and hard hitting.How difficult it would have been for her to write those lines when she was anything but 'badkirdaar'.The voice modulation by Mahira was perfect there.

Needless to say Fawad aced the revelation scene.I wouldn't go on much about it because it has been beautifully said by everyone and we know what tremendous actor he is.Generally I haven't seen men crying so it was unusual but heart touching scene.Men do have emotions and perfectly enacted by Fawad who had the potential of going OTT in these emotionally charged scenes but not for once overacted.

Why man can not cry , woman is supposed to be more strong mentally . Asher was never over the top when was reading the letters both time . His teary eyes first time when sitting besides hareem,s bed . and then walking in the corridor and comes and stops looking at the rain automatically he says I love you Khirad . Khirad was the part of his existance thats why he never came out of that hazy phase as Payal perhaps wrote somewhere that he was frozen in time frame and thats why it did not struck him that if Khirad came to his office .. Asher was shown to be sensitive person , his this side of nature , people took advantage . He was scared for Sara also if she went the destructive way again and started keeping his distance . Yes he did not shout in the last sequence as if was just going deeper and deeper with his guilt . And the revelation of his mother as the the last person he would have thought will ruin the lives of her owns .

TheMahiraKhan id on twitter...is that the real Mahira Khan?