Humsafar-dhoop chaun ka alaam raha..

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

disha

@disha15

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: -Crescendo-

I see that you are quite insecure for the show otherwise why would you go on explaining as to why one was better than the other in a thread which was about to discuss HS.
From what I gather is that you give ZGH credit in having a better storyline than HS and the TM has also said the very same thing.So what's the point in telling something we all know,i.e. HS was a blockbuster in the home country.

I ,for now, have realised that the comparisons between ZGH and HS are inevitable because I myself somehow start thinking on those lines while watching HS but then we don't degrade something to prove another better.

Exactly my point. Thank you!

Quote

sillage.

@sillage.

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#32

Disha,the thing is we are watching HS with an open mind giving the due appreciation and criticising it where we think its appropriate.But even then some people are hell bent on shoving down their opinions and proving superiority of one over the other.The term 'ZGH brigade'-now when and where did this happen.😆

Edited by -Crescendo- - 10 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

pinkeye

@pinkeye

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: The.Patthaaka.
NOTE :So what vibes Im getting here,is that if u loved ZGH,u must hate HS. what kind of nonsense logic is that? Am I missing something?
The whole of last night we had discussions of how I am loving how they're handling this phase of heartache.
I love ZGH,true. But when did I say that I hate HS?🤓

Yes I guess thats the pattern in social media which just infected this forum too. I mean is it really difficult to put your points logically and get into a healthy discussion? What kind of equation is that zgh lover is equal humsafar hater and vice versa. Annoying to say the least. More so, few people are only fonfined in their own opinions and do not even bother to go and read zgh lovers posts on humsafar episode thread too. I mean arent we watching the epis and discussing them whole heartedly too? And good or bad , pros and cons, its perspective of each of us, why this mocking? Oh too much to ask for I guess.

Toh for my sanity, let it be. Jane do Disha.

Edited by pinkeye - 10 years ago

Quote

904129

Hibernated

Posted: 10 years ago

#34

Originally posted by: The.Patthaaka.
NOTE :So what vibes Im getting here,is that if u loved ZGH,u must hate HS. what kind of nonsense logic is that? Am I missing something?
The whole of last night we had discussions of how I am loving how they're handling this phase of heartache.
I love ZGH,true. But when did I say that I hate HS?🤓

Dishu, Chill!!!! 😆 This HS Insecured Fanatic is out with a stengun for every ZGH fan! I remember in sum other thread she too was Blah! Blah! Blah! On my views when I asked her not to Compare both! Back Up Ppl.. Think what u wanna.. Im loving HS but still Im gonna say ZGH is much much more closer to me than HS! Its still Zaroon over Asher and Kashaf Over Khirad.. ZGH And ZaShaf are my favorites and will always be..😃 So Peace Out!? But that DOES NOT mean Im Hating HS!!

Edited by Bubbly_Shanaya - 10 years ago

Quote

sia

@Serendipity..

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#35

LOL @the ZGH Brigade. I dont think there is any brigade here. All of us are here to watch and enjoy the shows. Yes, some people love ZGH and some people love HS more. So whats the big deal in having favorites ? And, we are just discussing a show. It does have pros and cons. Though it stars our favorites, one cannot be blind about the cons. I mean every show might have some flaws, they are inevitable. Whats the big deal about discussing them and its done in a healthy way. Not once has HS been dissed here. So why the unnecessary hoopla around the topic.

I have no qualms in accepting that i love ZGH a tad more than HS. And i love it more for my own personal reasons. But that doesn't mean i hate HS and i dont believe in degrading HS just to make ZGH look like a better show. Infact, i loved HS. The show has some fabulous performances and is beautifully directed. And one has to accept the fact that comparisons are inevitable. Though the shows are of difference genre and cannot be compared but one cannot help it and as long as it is done in a decent manner, there should be no problem IMO.

Quote

904129

Hibernated

Posted: 10 years ago

#36

Bang On Point Sia. I too love ZGH much more than HS cuz of my personal reasons. The first being, ZGH was introduced to us when we all were suffering frm the Rotten Indian Sitcoms.. It came as a fresh air for all of us Indians. 2ndly, My Love FK! ❤️ was first introduced to us as Zaroon. The Chauvinist, Dominating Flawed Male but still lovable and desirable. Plus Sanam.. An actress worth poweress..!! An immense powerhouse of talent whom we dont see often in our sitcoms. So yeah! ZGH is very very close to me as Compared to Humsafar! But dat doesnt means that I hate HS! Humsafar has sum beautiful performances and brilliant direction. Yes, Agree its still Zaroon over Asher, Kashaf over Khirad and ZaShaf over KhiSher but that doesnt means we hate Humsafar. We all have our personal favorites and I dont think its necessary to explain my reasons! And yes the comparison seems Inevitable. Its lyk many ppl wud have Compared HS to ZGH in Pakistan right? So its the Vice-Versa in India! Simple! Grow Up Fanatics! Seriously!

Quote

sia

@Serendipity..

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: Bubbly_Shanaya
Bang On Point Sia. I too love ZGH much more than HS cuz of my personal reasons. The first being, ZGH was introduced to us when we all were suffering frm the Rotten Indian Sitcoms.. It came as a fresh air for all of us Indians. 2ndly, My Love FK! ❤️ was first introduced to us as Zaroon. The Chauvinist, Dominating Flawed Male but still lovable and desirable. Plus Sanam.. An actress worth poweress..!! An immense powerhouse of talent whom we dont see often in our sitcoms. So yeah! ZGH is very very close to me as Compared to Humsafar! But dat doesnt means that I hate HS! Humsafar has sum beautiful performances and brilliant direction. Yes, Agree its still Zaroon over Asher, Kashaf over Khirad and ZaShaf over KhiSher but that doesnt means we hate Humsafar. We all have our personal favorites and I dont think its necessary to explain my reasons! And yes the comparison seems Inevitable. Its lyk many ppl wud have Compared HS to ZGH in Pakistan right? So its the Vice-Versa in India! Simple! Grow Up Fanatics! Seriously!

Well said. Most of them dont seem to understand this point. For some indians like me and you, ZGH will always remain special as it was the first Pak drama we watched. Needless to say, it was like a breathe of fresh air here and the drama was so darn good that it touched our hearts. And many of us got introduced to Pak dramas and FK through this. So this will always have a special mention. Having said that, i dont think any of us have anything bad to say about HS. Its a great show and has a place of its own. Everyone is loving it here. And again, comparisons are inevitable so its best not to get into it. And its all about personal choices. Its better to respect it and have a healthy discussion and not cry over which show is better etc etc.

Quote

904129

Hibernated

Posted: 10 years ago

#38

Agree! Im very sure that If a nation loved this show so much then It must have sum quality! We didnt say anything negative. We are just discussing the Pro's And Con's of the show and characters. Which, If I may add was discussed at the tym of ZGH too! In the AT's if u remember. I cant be all blind and ignore the flaws too. Having said that, here this HS fanatic is talking about the bad direction, poor excuted story and The ending being inspired frm HS! We ZGH brigade..(As she fondly calls us! 😆) Can go on debating on these. Every1 has their own personal choices, So please! DO NOT try to SHOVE ur opininons down our throats. You know Sia, this happened just after ZGH's finale too. Maat had taken its slot. I have heard about the show being good but ppl were hell-bent on shoving their opinions about being a regressive, saas-bahu ahow. The TW and FB sites were full of these craps! Even if sum ppl liked the show and were keeping there opinion, sum were hell bent on proving them wrong..!! But Maat was good! 😊

Quote

disha

@disha15

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 10 years ago

#39

Very well said people. I think ZGH will always remain special for us bcoz of its realistic approach,every character had a little of us in them. Their mannerisms we could relate to,and if not us,could associate with people around us. ofcourse Kashaf will always be my most favourite coz I dont know of any other female lead who was so close to how I was in reality. Also,since ZGH was our first,well,first love is first love.

That being said,HS has it positives. As a love story,it puts on a great show. As I said,for such a typical story,if there could such impeccable execution,imagine what could have happened with a good storyline as well. For all those who feel we are picking flaws in HS,just coz we love ZGH,please read our discussions in the humsafar discussion thread. These are all ardent ZGH fans appreciating HS. And if you'll were here some months bk,you'll could have seen how we discussed things we didnt like in ZGH too,thus why cant we do the same for HS? no show is perfect,it has pros and cons both.

Anyway,I can go on and on about why I love ZGH. But thats not my intention, not atleast in this thread.

Guys,I request everyone to come back to the original discussion on HS 😊

Quote

sia

@Serendipity..

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 10 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: Bubbly_Shanaya
Agree! Im very sure that If a nation loved this show so much then It must have sum quality! We didnt say anything negative. We are just discussing the Pro's And Con's of the show and characters. Which, If I may add was discussed at the tym of ZGH too! In the AT's if u remember. I cant be all blind and ignore the flaws too. Having said that, here this HS fanatic is talking about the bad direction, poor excuted story and The ending being inspired frm HS! We ZGH brigade..(As she fondly calls us! 😆) Can go on debating on these. Every1 has their own personal choices, So please! DO NOT try to SHOVE ur opininons down our throats. You know Sia, this happened just after ZGH's finale too. Maat had taken its slot. I have heard about the show being good but ppl were hell-bent on shoving their opinions about being a regressive, saas-bahu ahow. The TW and FB sites were full of these craps! Even if sum ppl liked the show and were keeping there opinion, sum were hell bent on proving them wrong..!! But Maat was good! 😊

Exactly. If we are discussing HS now, we did the same for ZGH too. I can list down the things i liked and disliked about Zgh.. and i can do the same for HS.. But at the end of the day, they are two great shows and that is why people love it. i hope the point is loud and clear that both the shows are loved and have a place of its own. And its better to respect each other's views and move on.

And about Maat, well i havent watched it so cannot comment on it but about the opinions well its social media and we have to deal with it😆

Chalo chodo. Let us enjoy the HS discussions. The brilliant phase is about to begin. Looking forward to some great discussions 😃