Judges Partiality - Page 3

Originally posted by: nikitagmc

Franklly speaking I don't have a problem if judges give kritika 10. Fine, go ahead and give everyone 10. I don't mind it at all.

What I DEFINITELY do mind is that Sushant and Mukti do not get 10's so easily. give Kritika 10 by all means, but then give Sushant Mukti Akshat Siddesh 10 also!!!!

I just love how you express yourself, maybe because it comes really near to what I have to say as well.


At the topic in question, look I am a great Kritika fan, even before I was a Karan fan, since when Kitani just started, initially, even though it may seem unbelievable now, I thought Karan sucked. 😆 So, as such, no one can tell am against Kritika or hate her or anything since it's all the contrary.

That said and done, she didn't deserve a 10 from Arshad, actually if you ask me, not even a 9, perhaps an 8 yes. The problem with this show, the HUGE problem, is that as a clever viewer, you spark the disparities almost immediately. Sushant, Mukti, Siddhesh, Akshat, Abhishek who are amazing dancers, have to toil so hard to reach that 9 or 10, whilst one funny act from Karan, one little bit contemporary from Angad and one little sexy jig from Kritika earns them perfect 10s. I don't say no, obviously give them 10s, it's great to encourage non-dancers, always is, but then, at least APPRECIATE the dancers. Give them their due. Sushant deserved at least two tens for that duet performance, he was amazing in it. I usually have absolutely no problem with Vaibhavi's judgment almost always, but I couldn't understand for a moment why she said he lacked finesse which Mukti had. I mean COME ON, it's because he had the finesse of lifting her beautifully and providing support for every lift that she could come up with some amazing finesse.

See I am not against giving Kritika or Karan or any other contestant good marks, sure do and go ahead. I am their fan too after all! But I just hate it how, in the process, people like Aditi, Kapil (even though I am not and will never be a fan of them), Sushant or Abhishek get sidelined. It seems way, way too scripted to be able to believe otherwise. 🤢

Originally posted by: Tannistha

the aditi lovers might kill me for this, i liked aditi's attitude and all, but in both her performances , last week and this week's bazzigar, she didnt perform with the energy, its like she has been taught moves and she was doing them mechanically, bazigaar maybe coz she was under super pressure but the week before also, she was just doing the moves, no energy, thats why maybe she got eliminated.
kritika on the other hand wasnt technically perfect or she didnt dance skill fully but she kind of made it up with energy and attitude .

Tannistha, as much as I am an equally ardent fan of Kritika, and as much as it's nice to see fans backing her up, I still would like to add a few details.

1) Technically speaking, Kritika was as weak as Aditi was, give or take a few steps. If judgment has to be made, better it be made the same for ALL the performers, why the difference?

2) Ethically speaking, Arshad said he found parts on the table a bit restricted. Why the 10 then? What was that for? At least one mark should be deducted.

3) Going by what the judges said, the level bar has been raised. So why are they lenient to some dancers and not to others? Why don't they get equal correction or treatment?


See I love how Kritika got good marks, but as a true fan, I also feel it would have been better to give her what she deserved to let scope for improvement the next time. She would then have come back once again with a more jhakaas performance. That's all I've got to add.

And somehow, somewhere, knowing how Kritika is true always to what she says, I think she knew it as well, because she didn't look THAT happy when they gave her excellent comments. Either it's scripted, or deep down, she knew they weren't that right. Her face and body language definitely showed that, and I was happy to, as a fan, to see that! 😛

Because she was better than Ayush. Ayush, too didn't deserve a 27 but I think they lowered the standard for the round yesterday.