shilpa shetty misfit judge?

Page

Poll

do u think shilpa shetty is misfit for being a judge

shinningstar

@shinningstar

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

yes i think so...she unreasonably praises the guys team without any valid pointers...i think arshad warsi is the best judge of the 3 ...he never gets carried away always to the point and correct n reasonable he gives proper reasons for his points for either team.

p.s arshad was never my fav by after seeing this show and his reasonablity i must say..i m his fan now.

they shud have got malika arora back instead of shilpa she was damn gud as a judge .

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sneha Desai

@-Sneha

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

It's not like I love Shilpa or anything, but Malaika was as misfit a judge as Shilpa is. Both of them can be nice hip-movers but neither of them are good judges, and that's a fact!

They should have roped in a choreographer or a trained dancer like Arshad, but then they also look out for the Star Quotient in the show I guess. Frankly speaking, as long as Arshad and Vaibhavi especially are there, Shilpa doesn't really annoy me, because I don't really listen to what she says! 😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

shinningstar

@shinningstar

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

mallika always told valid point was impartial in season 1 ...everyhting she said was correct and accurate wrt to dance ...hence i think it wud have been better to have her

Quote

Aisha

@MOTHERHOOD

Stunner

+ 10

Posted: 15 years ago

Shipa is not fit to be a judge.Vaibhavi is the best judge ever.

Quote

cemre

@cemre

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

Vaibhavi is the best judge ..... the others 😕

Edited by cemre - 15 years ago

Quote

jinnie

@missmasakalli

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

vaibhavi is the best....arshad and shilpa are so so...andmany a times uses vaibhavis language or try to judge like her...

Quote

Sumaiya M. Rasul

@usmrasul

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

I find all 3 of them very comical, Bhaivaby for example....supposed to see choreography but dont find her saying where the contestants should have stretched hands further or make more gap between legs or whether hands in opposite direction was really parallel or not.......

Arshad...well a very peculiar person...he judges according to his mood i think...dont even know what area he judges🤪

Shilpa..i didnt want to talk about her....lets forget dancing...she is supposed to see style & soul, right??? well to her style only means flirting and smiling excessively...she can never judge the sober or race of a dance🤪🤪🤪🤪🤪
but, choreography is so weak and copied from other shows that i dont think thee is anything to judge either.......🤪

besides its scripted so why do they need to judge????🤪

Quote

Shreyacool

@Shreyacool

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Yes i thinkso to some extent she is & even arshad falls in the same category. Only vaibhavi is a perfect judge amongst them, I think ZND should drop one, either arshad or shilpa & get some dance expert or professional choreographer who really has full knowledge of dance!

Quote

Sneha Desai

@-Sneha

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: missmasakalli
vaibhavi is the best....arshad and shilpa are so so...andmany a times uses vaibhavis language or try to judge like her...

I second that! A lot of times, Shilpa can be seen repeating Vaibhavi's comments.

Oh Vaibhavi's just THE best. One of the finest choreographers and judges India has seen. I'll put her alongside Terence Lewis if you ask me, because the style of choreography she does is not the same so it might not come out as beautiful at times, and it's for commercial purposes, but needless to say that it's as powerful and spot on! And then, it's one thing being a superb choreographer, quite another being a good judge, a very well known example could be Saroj Khan. I appreciate her choreography, but in my opinion, she's not at all anywhere near a good judge. But yeah, that's just my opinion of course.