~beds-of-roses~ thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1
ive posted a few topics in this forum but no one has really replied 2 ne of dem but i honestly am requestin ur viewpoint on this one
in my opinion what the boys did 2day (not performin in the grup round) as bad behaviour but in sumways sort of justified n ill tell u guys why
from day 1 on wards the judges have been totally biased towards the guys
there have been so many lagi bet rounds where i honestly thought that the boys were better for example the one where chaitanya bhaktiyaar n amit performed from the elastic ropes i honestly thot they deserved to win to try sumthin like dat requires so much guts n not onli did dey attempt it but they did it perfectly in comparison the girls pulled off their standard routine wid no real risk or experiment
then cums the khallas round where there have been in numerous times where i disagreed with the judges
the KATHAK round i honestly thot that vikas shud have gone to the bench coz mouni was fabulous n she deseved 2 win
the CONTEMPORARY dance how on earth cud they have sent chaitanya 2 d bench he was amazin n i thot he was way better than mouni whose performance i honestly thot was highly over rated
the ITEM SONG round amey was to die for in that round he is so small with so much stage presence he was outstandin fantastic n mindblowin n i thot he was better than mouni wo did do well but wat amey did was slightly better
the JAZZ round where i didnt like ashita one bit i thot technically her performance was very weak n i liked vikas's better
in todays episode
cummon lets be serious bhaktiyaar 1st routine was soooo much better than karishma's oop cha he clearly deserved to win i honestly thot that d 2 women on the panel were really biased n chunky d person dat he is just copies malaika
in the face off i thot the level of difficulty in bhaktiyaar 's routine was far higher dan ashita's but honestly i do think that ashita was splendid too but bhaktiyaar deserved that face off hands down
si in conclusion id like t say that i get y d guys did wat dey did tho it wasnt the right thing to do but still i understand
pls feel free to comment
mods can close the topic if they feel it isnt appropriate
cheers

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

694

Users

7

Frequent Posters

sonia_sanya thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
in the tashan round..i agree the boys shud have won...and the judges excuse tht bakhtyar was doing nothing diff. was hideos ....c'mon its the final round,they'll play the way they r best in..and frankly though karishma was amazing,she was not tht great...her steps were no diff. aswell.so why the baised attitude.
josh135 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Judges said that Ashita and Bhaktiyar were on a tie in the face off round...but Ashita won by 1 point il tell u y? COz shes got grace both their performances were flawless agreed...but her expressions were much much better!!! n y u think that bhaktiyar 's difficulty level was more coz hes a guy and can do more those kind of steps..n girl needs to have her postures n have smoothness in her dance n she had that!!

n secondly u have not mentioned about the hum tum round ..i found girls much much better ...but guys won now thats soo partial...

ProdigalStudent thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: sonia_sanya

in the tashan round..i agree the boys shud have won...and the judges excuse tht bakhtyar was doing nothing diff. was hideos ....c'mon its the final round,they'll play the way they r best in..and frankly though karishma was amazing,she was not tht great...her steps were no diff. aswell.so why the baised attitude.



Agreed... I feel Saroj Khan is extremely biased against Bhaktiyaar, the way she talked to him and treated him was extremely rude... And I did not like how she undermined his AMAZING and FABULOUS dancing with "your not doing anything different".

Honestly for the first time I'm supporting Bhaktiyaar, coz I felt really bad for him... Though I felt his and the groups revolt was uncalled for!!! A better way for the guys to rebel would've been to give a FABULOUS - SHOW-STOPPING performance which would give the judges no room for criticism or biasedness... And even if the judges were biased, atleast we the public, the supporters of the guys group and the GUYS themselves could way away proudly saying they did the best, just the judges were unfair!!! 👏👏👏

So I feel the guys revolt was totally UNCALLED for!!! Though I do agree judges have not been completely fair to them in todays episode - but thats relative!!!
Edited by meteora_smt - 17 years ago
saccy_mybaba thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
JUDGES WERE VERY VERY BIASED TOWARDS GIRL AND FAVOURED THEM BLATANTLY WHICH IS VERY VERY WRONG
IN GRAND FINALE FIRST ROUND BAKHTAYAR'S PERFORMANCE WAS MUCH BETTER AND MUCH INNOVATIVE THAN THAT OF KARISHMA MY MOM BELIEVES THAT TOO, THAT SPRING DANCE AND VIDEO SCREEN DANCE(AMAZING RHYTHM BY BAKHTAYAR) WERE JUST AMAZING.
BUT STILL JUDGES FAVOURED KARISHMA BECAUSE SHE IS FEMALE AND JUDGES WERE BIASED TOWARDS GIRLS.WHICH IS VERY VERY UNFAIR.
I THINK BOYS MUST HAVE WALKED OUT MUCH BEFORE IN THE SHOW
Edited by saccy_mybaba - 17 years ago
Riya.pk thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
I just thought that Bakhtiyar deserved to win the Tashan round... I was shocked when I heard Karishma won because I didn;t think her performance was as good.
bushraw thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
I agrre with u all i think that the boys should have won the tashan round bakti was soooo much better then karishma. I think its all becasue of Malika she hates that poor guy i mean come on i dont think anyone had anything bad to say about bakti's performance and yet she did after what he did i was soooo sure they were going to win. if i was him i would have wlaked of rite there and then. As soon as i saw her face i ws like shes going to say it sucks which she pretty much did in her nice stupid wards. And chunky was the worst guy judge ever come be a man and stand up for ur boys but no. It all started bad and ended bad. The judges were just stupid and didnt know how to judge if they were judging for dancing then the results would have been different. Im a girl and im saying this i think that the judges were not fair with the boys.
Malika a BIG NONONONO for Dance show Judging🤢
And chunky a big NONONON for anything evrything 🤢 hes a shame to all man kind for not being a MAN

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".