Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai 19 Nov 2024 Written Update and EDT - Page 19

Originally posted by: WhimsicalMind

Not forum, I was on twitter during that track and I would see so many tweets of everyone bashing Virat

In twitter, virat was bashed by neutrals too. But in forum there are many posts defending him.

Originally posted by: Agni_Jytsona

Abhira is as much a victim in all this as Ruhi. But sure let us also drag her for something that's not even her fault.

She's a victim . But shes also at the fulcrum this major issue ...All this is happening coz "abhira can't take it if she knows her child is no more " . Ye saari nautanki ka core reason hi yahi hai . .

She was hoping for a miracle but when miracle didn't happen she can't take it. Well we don't know if she can take it or no but her husband assumed she won't ? She willingly gave her injection to save her sister but her child died and hers survived so now she can't take it .actions have consequences you see..

She might not have another chance at pregnancy (her devar said so ) , but she willingly accepted her fate & married arman previously and now she will die without a baby ? Who made the baby so important? Arman time and again stressed that she's enuf for him , he asked her to abort to save her from this heartbreak but she was adamant but now she can't face the consequences of it so yes . She's not spot free.

Originally posted by: WhimsicalMind

Only two incidents have occurred after baby thing, in one I don't blame her but she is not understanding that Ruhi needs time

First she told Ruhi that her child was dead instead of letting the news come from a more neutral or a positive source, Ruhi doesn't like her

Then after being told not to go to Ruhi, she took baby to her and kept it on her lap and addressed her as baby's "Matashree", a relationship she lost which was reminiscent of her hate for Abhira

Then after being told repeatedly to stay away, she went to Ruhi's room in this episode too

https://x.com/Viebsolo/status/1858712693567345004?t=fkP-kaXw346F4eIQpuaE6w&s=19

Writing an essay would not convert ONE INCIDENT into multiple. That would remain a single incident. She tried ONCE and she was wrong about it

Still does not make her a culprit. Abhira is as much a victim as Ruhi. Ruhi will eventually get her baby back while ABhira will loose two.

Originally posted by: WhimsicalMind

I wasn't bashing Armaan, I was defending him, stealing baby is actually in line with his character

He always chose Abhira, he even chose her over his own father when his father was in bigger danger and Abhira had no issues after donating blood, but father would have died for sure but he made that choice

It doesn't surprise me that he stole the baby, he would choose Abhira over others, that's why I blame Rohit more because he cares for neither his wife nor his child.

Armaan ko defend karne ki zarurat nahi h, aap Rohit Ruhi par focus rakho.

Haan Ab ko kuch hua nahi but ho sakta tha, to risk kyu le? Aur agar ye insignificant baat hoti to doctor kehta hi kyu?

Jaise Ab ka pregnancy continue karna risky tha vaise hi blood donate karna, Ar dono mein initially against tha.

Haan he always choose his wife kyunki sab Rohit thodi naa hote h. Though Ar ne bhi wife ke regarding bohot galtiyan ki h.

Bachha chori ka main culprit Ro hi h kyunki vo khud bachha dene aaya tha, koi maangne nahi gaya tha us se.

Originally posted by: Drna7

Armaan ko defend karne ki zarurat nahi h, aap Rohit Ruhi par focus rakho.

Haan Ab ko kuch hua nahi but ho sakta tha, to risk kyu le? Aur agar ye insignificant baat hoti to doctor kehta hi kyu?

Jaise Ab ka pregnancy continue karna risky tha vaise hi blood donate karna, Ar dono mein initially against tha.

Haan he always choose his wife kyunki sab Rohit thodi naa hote h. Though Ar ne bhi wife ke regarding bohot galtiyan ki h.

Bachha chori ka main culprit Ro hi h kyunki vo khud bachha dene aaya tha, koi maangne nahi gaya tha us se.

Why do you have copyright on Armaan?

You are saying what I said but you have problem because I said it?

Armaan being bacha chor doesn't surprise me because it makes sense so I don't blame him

Seriously chaitu?You said Ruhi will blame Abhira if Abhira keeps her HAQ and not feeding Ruhi's baby.Ruhi said she won't let Abhira touch her baby.Ruhi would have wished to keep the haq of her feeding her own baby .Because Ruhi would have kept her HAQ above ,won't mind if the her own baby died due to hungriness than letting Abhira feeding her.

Originally posted by: Krinya

She's a victim . But shes also at the fulcrum this major issue ...All this is happening coz "abhira can't take it if she knows her child is no more " . Ye saari nautanki ka core reason hi yahi hai . .

She was hoping for a miracle but when miracle didn't happen she can't take it. Well we don't know if she can take it or no but her husband assumed she won't ? She willingly gave her injection to save her sister but her child died and hers survived so now she can't take it .actions have consequences you see..

She might not have another chance at pregnancy (her devar said so ) , but she willingly accepted her fate & married arman previously and now she will die without a baby ? Who made the baby so important? Arman time and again stressed that she's enuf for him , he asked her to abort to save her from this heartbreak but she was adamant but now she can't face the consequences of it so yes . She's not spot free.

A mother unable to imagine a life without a baby she carried for so many months is nataunki? I don't think there any mother in this world jo apne bacche ki maut se Kaap na uthe

Abhira risking her life for the baby was wrong. Ofcourse, she would move on eventually jab usse pata chalega. But initially toh kissi bhi parent ko aisa hi lagega ki uski khud hi jaan nikal gayi haa. Duniya ki aisi koi Maa nahi hogi jo aapne bacche ki death imagine karke usse seham na jaaye

You have lot of unnecessary hate for a fictional character because calling a mother's pain on loosing her kid as "Nataunki" has to be heights

There is no point in this conversation because this is pathetic. I am sorry but it is

Originally posted by: Agni_Jytsona

Writing an essay would not convert ONE INCIDENT into multiple. That would remain a single incident. She tried ONCE and she was wrong about it

Still does not make her a culprit. Abhira is as much a victim as Ruhi. Ruhi will eventually get her baby back while ABhira will loose two.

It wasn't a single incident, these were 3 separate incidents where Abhira is imposing herself on Ruhi instead of letting her grieve, other than feeding thing, she should have stayed away.

Abhira is not as much a victim because Ruhi has lost initial days of her child's life, and will lose her husband too.

Abhira's pregnancy was always complicated but she has a husband who loves her, a partner who would support her through this. Maybe she'll get Ruhi's baby too

I mean a lot of us here don't like Ruhi but I don't think anybody called her pain of loosing her kid as "Nataunki"

Originally posted by: Drna7

In the show Ab had some platelets issue and she cannot donate blood as it will be risky for her health. And Ab also told her mother never allowed her to donate blood.

Father ko save karne ke liye Ab ko marne chor deta kya?? Fir vo kehlata inhumane and selfish.

Arre re ! Somebody with such medical conditions will NOT be allowed to donate blood , who is arman to decide 😆

It's the same as this risky pregnancy. She won't be allowed to continue in normal conditions, na doctors kahege na ghar wale na husband and medically it's a rule of thumb that a mother's life is saved first incase only one could be saved.

There r so many other ways to show their fl mahaan science ki ma behen kiye bina.🤣

Ps. A woman can have a normal pregnancy with low platelet count but this is yrkkh verse so logic and science doesn't apply.