1 gud happened! - Page 2

Originally posted by: Nyxigniflex

Maybe, actually would be good if they did. But first they need "workshops" for their writers.😡

Writing maybe bad... every other actor was still able to understand their character.

And we really like most of them for still carrying the script through coz of their acting.

But Manjari is making the bad writing worse.

Originally posted by: Nyxigniflex

Just don't show these scenes if they can't do their research (that should be illegal though, if you can't respect a profession enough to show it properly than just don't show it).

Mahima or someone of the expertise in vocal department I don't know what they are called(would have done my research if I was yrkkh writer) and she should try to throw Abhi out of the OT and he refusing to budge, so she lets him stay. It would have been great to watch Abhi freaking out but able to do anything but watch. He take so much pride in his profession but his frustration and helplessness at not being able to do anything when it matters the most would have been a treat to watch.

If they can't do even that then just skip the scene (someone in the background performed the surgery) and should have focused on the aftermath.

Agreed. As a non-medical person, I was watching with my mouth open at the rubbish they were showing - can't imagine any medicos on here watching this episode and not cringing right into the ground and/or dying of laughter.

I agree, the way to make this poignant would have been to show Abhimanyu watching helplessly while Mahima or whoever did the actual surgery (who makes someone who can't hold a scalpel without shaking do a surgery🤔). Not that they did anything that can be called surgery in this episode... 🤣

I didn't even want to watch today episode and seeing all the comments when I went to watch. It was like I watched a live performance ( watching operations through mobile) inside another live performance(Goenka's bekaar love for akshu).

These writers na. They should really change Birla family profession. I don't want 100 % logic atleast 1% logic would do.

Regarding Manjari I don't have much problem with this actress but yaar they made such a character for her that people can't believe such people live nowadays and top it she ruined abhi's life with her gyaans so we started hating her this much.

Today episode looked more like stage drama than a serial episode.

I was talking about today's episode actually.

I can do a better job and I am not a writer by any means.

Ya Abhimanyu being helpless would be so amazing, HC would have mailed it.

Originally posted by: Prettywitty

Manjari is an infuriating character but I like Ami Trivedi's acting - she plays a timid, confused, scared woman really well. You can see the fear in her eyes around Harsh and the desire to please him in her shaky smile and she really brings that MAA waala love into her face when she looks at Abhimanyu. Hope her health is ok - these are rough days...

I dont know what you are seeing. I dont see anything of the sort in her.

I think the character needs a Krishna devotee, submissive but a happy person who has raised a strong son who is dedicated to his mother.

His mom is his friend with whom he shares all his heart's thoughts.

He protects her from his father's wrath but he is a baby infront of her.

I dont see that equation at all.

Instead Pranali is doing the role much better of taming the lion and yet she is like an adorable kitten when it needs to be.

The actors bring their own interpreation and she has no clue how to be a submissive woman yet a strong mom to an Alpha man.

Originally posted by: hari15

I didn't even want to watch today episode and seeing all the comments when I went to watch. It was like I watched a live performance ( watching operations through mobile) inside another live performance(Goenka's bekaar love for akshu).

These writers na. They should really change Birla family profession. I don't want 100 % logic atleast 1% logic would do.

Regarding Manjari I don't have much problem with this actress but yaar they made such a character for her that people can't believe such people live nowadays and top it she ruined abhi's life with her gyaans so we started hating her this much.

Today episode looked more like stage drama than a serial episode.

Originally posted by: Ekahriz

Unfortunately, even Manjari's disappearance did not make today's epsiode any better. 😕

TBH, I loved Arohi's picture reading the most...woh jaise KG mein picture read karte the...waise hi kar rahi thi.....😂

Originally posted by: Illuminatus.

I dont know what you are seeing. I dont see anything of the sort in her.

I think the character needs a Krishna devotee, submissive but a happy person who has raised a strong son who is dedicated to his mother.

His mom is his friend with whom he shares all his heart's thoughts.

He protects her from his father's wrath but he is a baby infront of her.

I dont see that equation at all.

Instead Pranali is doing the role much better of taming the lion and yet she is like an adorable kitten when it needs to be.

The actors bring their own interpreation and she has no clue how to be a submissive woman yet a strong mom to an Alpha man.

Originally posted by: Illuminatus.

I dont know what you are seeing. I dont see anything of the sort in her.

I think the character needs a Krishna devotee, submissive but a happy person who has raised a strong son who is dedicated to his mother.

His mom is his friend with whom he shares all his heart's thoughts.

He protects her from his father's wrath but he is a baby infront of her.

I dont see that equation at all.

Instead Pranali is doing the role much better of taming the lion and yet she is like an adorable kitten when it needs to be.

The actors bring their own interpreation and she has no clue how to be a submissive woman yet a strong mom to an Alpha man.

Interesting - see, to me the expressions on the current Manjari look like those on women with abuse-induced PTSD I met when I volunteered at a women's shelter. She's got this fear and sadness behind her eyes. In the scenes with Harsh - her expression and smile open up when she thinks she's caught him in a good mood (like after the HARNISH scenes) but one can see her close up again when he speaks sharply to her.

To me, that portrayal makes sense - Harsh raised his hand to hit her in front of everyone, he's openly rude to her. Who knows what he says or does to her in private...

As for Abhimanyu she makes her face brighten when she looks at him - well maybe not so much in recent episodes but in the early episodes.

Would she have phalaoed all the raita needed to drive this particular plot forward if she'd been a strong mom and happy woman - I'm not sure... The plot needed her to be confused and people-pleasing and wishy-washy.